Prof G Markets
Prof G Markets

Sep 9, 2026 · 40 min

Listen from 12:37

Listen at 12:37

Trump’s pressure pushes Canada toward Carney and new alliances

Canadian Economist: Trump’s Tariffs Are A Gift To Mark Carney

The episode connects a trade confrontation, falling education performance, AI’s challenge to learning, and rising government interest costs.

3 key takeaways
  1. 1Trump’s provocations and tariffs have strengthened Mark Carney while encouraging Canada to diversify beyond the United States.
  2. 2OECD education results show broad declines, with the steepest deterioration among lower-performing students and uncertain consequences for growth and social participation.
  3. 3AI complicates assessment and learning, while rising government interest costs increasingly compete with public investment and other priorities.

Don't miss

The central reversal is the argument that Trump’s pressure has strengthened Mark Carney and encouraged Canada to look beyond the United States.

The brief

Economist Mike Moffatt argues that Donald Trump’s tariffs and provocations have strengthened Mark Carney politically, leaving only a small minority of Canadians supportive of Trump.

The tariff dispute is also pushing Canada to deepen ties with Europe, reconsider defense spending, and diversify trade—though repairing the bilateral relationship may become harder.

John Byrne Murdoch examines major OECD declines in reading, mathematics, and science, with inequality widening as the lowest-performing students fall furthest behind.

The education debate turns on AI: schools must preserve underlying skills and focus even as cheating becomes harder to police and supervised exams regain importance.

The episode closes on government debt, where rising interest payments compete with public investment and other priorities across OECD economies, including the United States.

What was said on this episode

25 statements · 7 positive · 14 negative · 2 mixed · 2 neutral

  1. Mike Moffatton Canadian retaliatory tariffsMixed5:11

    Some Canadian tariffs target U.S. swing states to reduce domestic price effects.

    “But others are a little bit more targeted towards swing states”

    Listen at 5:11

  2. Mike Moffatton CanadaPositive6:33

    Current conditions make absorbing a modest GDP hit relatively manageable for Canada.

    “if you had to do it at some point, now's really not a bad time”

    Listen at 6:33

  3. Mike Moffatton Canada trade diversificationPositive7:28

    Canada is pursuing trade diversification while still seeking a U.S. agreement.

    “we're also exploring plan B and trying to diversify our trade in the meantime”

    Listen at 7:28

  4. Mike Moffatton Trump’s provocations toward CanadaNegative8:41

    Trump’s provocations increase Carney’s popularity and bargaining room against an unfavorable deal.

    “it just makes Carney more popular in the eyes of Canadians and gives Carney more ability to back away from a bad deal”

    Listen at 8:41

  5. Mike Moffatton Canadian counter-tariffsPositive10:16

    Non-Conservative Canadians support the counter-tariffs at rates of 90%-95%.

    “Canadians who are non-conservative voters support them 90% to 95%.”

    Listen at 10:16

  6. Approximately 15% of Canadians still like Trump.

    “It does. I would say it's about 15 percent of the population.”

    Listen at 11:04

  7. Mike Moffatton USMCANegative12:37

    The U.S. share of Canadian exports declined from about 80% to 67%.

    “Canada used to, about 80% of Canadian exports used to go to the United States. A couple of years ago, it was down to 70. It's now down to about 67%.”

    Listen at 12:37

  8. Mike Moffatton Trump administration trade policiesPositive12:48

    Trump’s policies have accelerated Canada’s trade diversification.

    “the Trump administration has kind of done us a bit of a favor in a strange way because we've always talked in Canada about the need to diversify our trade. Well, we're actually doing it now.”

    Listen at 12:48

  9. Mike Moffatton Canadian defense spendingNeutral13:30

    Canada will shift its defense spending in the short to medium term.

    “I think in the kind of short and medium term, I think we're going to see a shift in defense spending.”

    Listen at 13:30

  10. Mike Moffatton Canadian F-35 purchaseNegative13:43

    Canada may abandon its planned F-35 purchase.

    “we might see that go away”

    Listen at 13:43

  11. Mike Moffatton Canada-U.S. relationshipMixed13:46

    The Canada-U.S. relationship can be repaired, but recovery will take time.

    “I do think the Canadian-US relationship is repairable, but it's going to take a while.”

    Listen at 13:46

  12. Mike Moffatton Mark CarneyPositive15:03

    Carney is viewed as a steady leader during intense turmoil.

    “I think that's how he's seen as the kind of steady hand who's, you know. keeping us through this at a time of intense turmoil.”

    Listen at 15:03

  13. John Burn-Murdochon Global student educational performanceNegative20:34

    Global student educational performance has continued declining after the pandemic.

    “Three years on, instead of a partial recovery or even stability, we see sustained decline.”

    Listen at 20:34

  14. John Burn-Murdochon AI-assisted schoolworkNegative22:50

    AI-assisted schoolwork may leave students struggling when AI is unavailable.

    “one possibility is that some of this is that just in the last year or two some young people are using ai to help with their work, which then means when it's taken away, they struggle”

    Listen at 22:50

  15. John Burn-Murdochon U.S. educational inequalityNegative28:57

    The lowest-performing 10% of U.S. students are falling further behind.

    “the bottom 10% really falling away”

    Listen at 28:57

  16. John Burn-Murdochon Educational under-preparationNegative29:26

    Large groups of inadequately educated young people would harm societal functioning.

    “I really don't think we're headed to a good place if you end up with one in 10, one in five young people and they become adults. And these people really just do not or have not been equipped with the skills they need to navigate the complexity of modern life.”

    Listen at 29:26

  17. John Burn-Murdochon AI in educationNegative30:51

    Relying on AI for learning risks severe performance collapse without AI.

    “there's a really solid case that relying on AI as part of the learning process is extremely risky in terms of it essentially being used as a crutch that when taken away, people just collapse at the end.”

    Listen at 30:51

  18. John Burn-Murdochon Artificial IntelligencePositive33:35

    AI will become deeply embedded in future workplaces.

    “AI is going to be heavily embedded into the world of work of the future.”

    Listen at 33:35

  19. John Burn-Murdochon AI in educationNegative34:11

    Using AI too early risks preventing foundational learning.

    “the risk with AI is that the learning never happens”

    Listen at 34:11

  20. John Burn-Murdochon AI-free educationPositive34:45

    Education could keep learning experiences largely AI-free.

    “you can imagine a world where the education system is done AI-free as much as possible in terms of the actual learning experience”

    Listen at 34:45

  21. Ed Elsonon U.S. federal interest paymentsNegative35:36

    U.S. annual interest payments have reached $1.25 trillion.

    “our annual interest payment is now up to $1.25 trillion”

    Listen at 35:36

  22. Ed Elsonon U.S. federal deficitNegative36:13

    Trump’s administration increased the annual U.S. deficit to roughly $2 trillion.

    “since he took over, he has exploded our annual deficit to roughly $2 trillion”

    Listen at 36:13

  23. Ed Elsonon U.S. national debtNegative36:24

    U.S. national debt has surpassed $40 trillion.

    “our total national debt has now surpassed $40 trillion”

    Listen at 36:24

  24. Ed Elsonon U.S. fiscal policyNegative36:32

    Perceived U.S. fiscal irresponsibility raises demanded borrowing costs.

    “The more fiscally irresponsible we appear, the more money our lenders demand for holding our debt”

    Listen at 36:32

  25. Ed Elsonon U.S. debt problemNegative37:28

    America’s debt problem is approaching a critical threshold.

    “America's debt problem is reaching a tipping point.”

    Listen at 37:28

Statements are attributed to the speaker as said on the episode and reflect their view at the time, not PodLume's. They are not advice.

Weekly email

State of the Pod, every Monday

The week's most-discussed names and stories from podcasts, with the moments behind them. Free, five minutes, unsubscribe in one click.

Listen to the full episode and explore every guest, topic, and moment on PodLume.