Yet Another Value Podcast
Yet Another Value Podcast

Oct 1, 2026 · 1h 20m

Turning Point bets on pouches to become nicotine’s third force

$TPB: can Turning Point Brands be the third player in nicotine pouches? | Saberpoint Capital

The thesis hinges on whether Turning Point’s legacy businesses can fund Free and Alp before regulation, manufacturing, and management execution test the growth story.

3 key takeaways
  1. 1Zig-Zag and Stoker’s provide downside support while Free and Alp offer exposure to a fast-growing nicotine-pouch category.
  2. 2Domestic manufacturing could narrow Turning Point’s cost disadvantage, but regulatory constraints have delayed the transition and preserved execution risk.
  3. 3Alp’s brand momentum and distribution reach support the upside case, while valuation depends on uncertain ownership, financing, and growth assumptions.

Don't miss

Baxter links Alp’s early Tucker Carlson promotion to a broader brand identity and asks whether its momentum can survive beyond the celebrity association.

The brief

George Baxter of Saber Point Capital presents a bull case for Turning Point: Zig-Zag and Stoker’s support the downside while Free and Alp could challenge Zyn and Velo.

The pouch thesis rests on habit and convenience-store distribution, where portability and discreet use may help the category convert consumers and build repeat purchasing.

Turning Point is investing ahead of earnings, importing pouches from India while pursuing domestic manufacturing that could materially improve costs and margins.

The central competitive question is whether a larger sales force and independent-retailer access can overcome regulation, major tobacco rivals, and brand-building costs.

Alp becomes the episode’s biggest upside variable, with Tucker Carlson’s early promotion giving way to a broader identity whose durability remains unproven.

Baxter’s valuation separates legacy-business downside from an ambitious 2030 scenario, while his discussion of confirmation bias underscores the thesis’s uncertainty.

What was said on this episode

48 statements · 35 positive · 8 negative · 1 mixed · 4 neutral

  1. George Baxteron Turning Point BrandsPositive4:38

    Turning Point leads the declining U.S. chewing-tobacco market.

    “they're the market leader in, uh, in chew, which is a, a declining, a small declining market”

    Listen at 4:38

  2. George Baxteron Stoker'sPositive4:48

    Stoker’s has grown despite declining chew and moist-snuff markets.

    “Stokers has managed to grow despite that decline, given its position within the market”

    Listen at 4:48

  3. George Baxteron ALPPositive7:10

    ALP is probably the fastest-growing sizable consumer product in the United States.

    “ALP brand, which is probably the fastest growing consumer product in the United States today, you know, of, you know, of any size.”

    Listen at 7:10

  4. George Baxteron Nicotine pouchesPositive11:11

    Nicotine pouches are inexpensive to manufacture and generate high margins.

    “they have the same type of characteristics— very inexpensive to make, uh, very high margin.”

    Listen at 11:11

  5. George Baxteron Nicotine-pouch marketPositive12:28

    The nicotine-pouch market is currently worth about $6.5 billion.

    “This market has grown from nothing, uh, really prior to COVID, uh, to today. It's about a $6.5 billion market right now, according to latest Nielsen data.”

    Listen at 12:28

  6. George Baxteron Nicotine-pouch marketPositive12:40

    The nicotine-pouch market is growing at approximately 22%.

    “The market's growing at about 22%.”

    Listen at 12:40

  7. George Baxteron Nicotine pouchesPositive12:46

    Nicotine-pouch sales averaged roughly 37–38% annual growth over five years.

    “on average for the last 5 years, it's been something like 37-38% average annual growth”

    Listen at 12:46

  8. George Baxteron Turning Point BrandsPositive13:02

    Free and ALP reached 48% of Turning Point’s revenue after launching nationally.

    “TurningPoint has managed within, you know, since they launched their nationally launched free in 2024, between free and ALP, Uh, you know, they've managed to take that from, you know, really nothing in their revenues to 48% as of the, the last earnings report.”

    Listen at 13:02

  9. George Baxteron Turning Point BrandsPositive13:22

    Nicotine pouches now generate 48% of Turning Point Brands’ revenue.

    “48% of their revenue now comes from nicotine pouch.”

    Listen at 13:22

  10. George Baxteron ALP and FREPositive16:22

    George Baxter usually returns to using ALP and FRE wintergreen and mint products.

    “I personally almost always come back to using, uh, Uh, Alpenfree wintergreen and mint”

    Listen at 16:22

  11. George Baxteron NicotinePositive16:43

    Habitual nicotine-pouch users tend to gravitate toward one brand.

    “but ultimately you tend to gravitate towards, uh, towards a particular brand”

    Listen at 16:43

  12. George Baxteron NicotineNeutral19:01

    Online nicotine-pouch sales are about one-third in Sweden versus 4% in the United States.

    “in Sweden, I believe about a third of all sales are done online for nicotine pouches. Conversely, in the United States, it's about 4%.”

    Listen at 19:01

  13. George Baxteron U.S. nicotine-pouch online salesNeutral19:08

    About 4% of U.S. nicotine-pouch sales occur online.

    “in the United States, it's about 4%.”

    Listen at 19:08

  14. George Baxteron Nicotine pouchesPositive23:12

    Nicotine pouches can be used on airplanes where smoking and vaping cannot.

    “If you're on an airplane for 4 hours, you can't smoke a cigarette, you can't vape, but you can use a nicotine pouch”

    Listen at 23:12

  15. George Baxteron Nicotine-pouch market structureNeutral26:27

    The nicotine-pouch market will narrow to one or two smaller competitors plus big tobacco brands.

    “I personally believe that over time we will narrow this down to basically 1 or 2 competitors that are not large, big tobacco today and the big tobacco competitors.”

    Listen at 26:27

  16. George Baxteron Convenience-store nicotine-pouch brandsNegative26:46

    Convenience stores cannot sustainably support five or six major nicotine-pouch brands.

    “there's not, there's not room for, for 5 or 6”

    Listen at 26:46

  17. George Baxteron VELONegative30:24

    The original Velo nicotine pouch was an inferior product.

    “Velo, by the way, the first one was just— it was just sawdust in a little sachet. Uh, horrible.”

    Listen at 30:24

  18. George Baxteron Velo PlusPositive30:35

    George Baxter considers Velo Plus a very good nicotine-pouch product.

    “Velo Plus came out, and that's a very good product, there's no question.”

    Listen at 30:35

  19. George Baxteron VELOPositive30:45

    Velo’s market share rose from roughly 2–3% to 20%.

    “they've gone from You know, essentially like a 2 or 3 share under the old Velo to a 20 share today.”

    Listen at 30:45

  20. George Baxteron ALPPositive31:12

    ALP is the fastest-growing sizable nicotine-pouch brand by percentage.

    “ALP is the fastest growing, uh, on a percentage basis, uh, nicotine pouch of, you know, among the ones that are of any size, of any real size.”

    Listen at 31:12

  21. George Baxteron ZynPositive31:55

    Combined Zyn and Zyn Ultra sales are growing 2% year over year.

    “if you take Zen and Zen Ultra and add them together, they're growing 2% year over year.”

    Listen at 31:55

  22. George Baxteron ZynNegative32:33

    Zyn’s market share fell from roughly 78% to about 54%.

    “last year, I think at the beginning of the year, I want to say Zen was something like 78% share. Today that's down to about 54%.”

    Listen at 32:33

  23. George Baxteron PMTA regulationMixed33:26

    Greater PMTA access will benefit large incumbents more than smaller nicotine companies.

    “the PMTA is opening up, that's going to benefit the larger incumbents more than it's going to benefit the smaller players.”

    Listen at 33:26

  24. George Baxteron Smaller nicotine-pouch companiesNegative36:07

    Many smaller nicotine-pouch companies will eventually run out of money.

    “I think the door has been shut for a lot of these smaller players, and it's just a matter of time before they run out of money.”

    Listen at 36:07

  25. George Baxteron Turning Point BrandsPositive37:59

    Turning Point can determine its own promotional cadence, unlike Big Tobacco’s fixed schedules.

    “Turning Point has had the flexibility, and I think some of the other smaller players can do this as well. They're like, you can determine the cadence of promotion.”

    Listen at 37:59

  26. George Baxteron Turning Point BrandsPositive38:54

    Turning Point’s durability makes it attractive to convenience-store buyers.

    “Turning Point fits that very well because one of the questions you're asking as a C-store buyer is, Is this company going to be around?”

    Listen at 38:54

  27. George Baxteron Turning Point Brands sales forcePositive39:41

    Turning Point expanded regional salespeople from 100 to about 260, targeting 320.

    “In 2024, they had 100 regional salespeople to support Zigzag and Stokers. Now, uh, they're at about 260, on their way to about 320”

    Listen at 39:41

  28. George Baxteron Turning Point BrandsPositive39:48

    Turning Point Brands has about 260 regional salespeople and plans to reach approximately 320.

    “Now, uh, they're at about 260, on their way to about 320.”

    Listen at 39:48

  29. George Baxteron Turning Point BrandsPositive44:07

    Domestic production could reduce Turning Point’s per-can cost from $1.40 to about $0.65.

    “if they produced it domestically, that $1.40 would likely go down to about $0.65 and possibly lower”

    Listen at 44:07

  30. George Baxteron Turning Point BrandsPositive46:35

    Turning Point will likely begin domestic manufacturing by the second half of next year.

    “I think that that will happen probably at the latest in the second half of next year.”

    Listen at 46:35

  31. George Baxteron Turning Point BrandsPositive49:23

    Turning Point’s slotting fees should decline significantly and improve margins.

    “I expect those to come down significantly, improving margin.”

    Listen at 49:23

  32. George Baxteron Convenience-store nicotine-pouch marginsPositive49:55

    Convenience stores earn roughly 25% to 30% margins on nicotine pouches.

    “they're getting 25%, 30% for nicotine pouch.”

    Listen at 49:55

  33. George Baxteron Turning Point BrandsPositive52:38

    Turning Point’s legacy business is worth approximately $35–$45 per share.

    “the legacy business is probably worth somewhere in the neighborhood of call it $35 to $45 a share.”

    Listen at 52:38

  34. George Baxteron FRE marketing spendNegative53:14

    The short thesis that FRE receives poor marketing-spend returns has merit.

    “there's efficacy to the short thesis that they're not getting great returns for their marketing spend.”

    Listen at 53:14

  35. George Baxteron Free marketing spendingNegative53:59

    Free’s marketing spending has uncertain returns and warrants skepticism.

    “as far as getting a great ROI on that, that really remains to be seen. And I think there's reason for skepticism.”

    Listen at 53:59

  36. George Baxteron ALP brand buildingPositive56:24

    ALP has been more successful than FRE at building its brand.

    “I would argue Alp has been more successful than that in that, in that endeavor than free.”

    Listen at 56:24

  37. George Baxteron FRENegative58:33

    FRE currently struggles to establish a clear brand identity.

    “What it struggles with is creating an identity. I think free is kind of like, what does it represent?”

    Listen at 58:33

  38. George Baxteron ALP brandPositive1:02:32

    ALP’s brand has captured Tucker Carlson’s rebellious persona.

    “they have managed to capture the spirit of Tucker Carlson in that he's a rebel.”

    Listen at 1:02:32

  39. George Baxteron ALP brandPositive1:03:28

    ALP is diversifying its brand identity beyond Tucker Carlson.

    “they're moving, not necessarily moving away from Tucker, but diversifying beyond Tucker with the brand”

    Listen at 1:03:28

  40. George Baxteron ALP and FRE productsNeutral1:05:08

    ALP and FRE use the same underlying nicotine-pouch product.

    “Anybody who uses the product knows Alp and Free are the same product. There's no difference”

    Listen at 1:05:08

  41. George Baxteron ALPPositive1:07:28

    ALP’s annualized revenue run rate was about $208 million, growing 300% year over year.

    “we think they did enough where if you just annualize last quarter, it's about $208 million worth of revenue. Okay, growing 300% year over year.”

    Listen at 1:07:28

  42. George Baxteron Turning Point BrandsPositive1:08:03

    Turning Point will use its ATM proceeds to acquire more of ALP and consolidate it.

    “I believe they're hitting the ATM. They will buy more of ALP. They will consolidate it”

    Listen at 1:08:03

  43. George Baxteron Turning Point BrandsPositive1:09:18

    Turning Point will probably increase its ALP ownership from 50% to about 70%.

    “My suspicion, the way that will be done is not through a purchase of the entire business, but it'll probably be for some fraction of it. My guess would be, you know, they go from a 50% ownership to a 70%”

    Listen at 1:09:18

  44. George Baxteron David GlasickNegative1:12:58

    David Glasick may leave Turning Point if near-term results do not improve.

    “if this doesn't— you know, if they— if we don't see results that come through in the near term, given Glasick's operational history on his resume— now, I do think he has been engaged and has been involved with Turning Point running it for some time. Uh, I don't think he's going to be there for very long.”

    Listen at 1:12:58

  45. George Baxteron Nicotine-pouch marketPositive1:15:07

    The nicotine-pouch market may grow 10%–30% annually through 2030.

    “I think this market grows anywhere from 10% to 30% CAGR from now until 2030.”

    Listen at 1:15:07

  46. George Baxteron Turning Point BrandsPositive1:15:32

    Turning Point could reach approximately 10% nicotine-pouch market share.

    “I think it's very rational to think that they could have a 10 share.”

    Listen at 1:15:32

  47. George Baxteron Turning Point Brands stockPositive1:16:10

    Turning Point’s stock could reach $1,000 by 2030 under stated assumptions.

    “you're talking about a $1,000 stock at about 36 times earnings, right, in 2030. Okay. For a $60 stock today.”

    Listen at 1:16:10

  48. George Baxteron Turning Point BrandsPositive1:18:11

    Domestic manufacturing could add $90–$100 million of incremental EBITDA.

    “we're talking about an incremental $90 to $100 million EBITDA.”

    Listen at 1:18:11

Statements are attributed to the speaker as said on the episode and reflect their view at the time, not PodLume's. They are not advice.

Books & mentions

Weekly email

State of the Pod, every Monday

The week's most-discussed names and stories from podcasts, with the moments behind them. Free, five minutes, unsubscribe in one click.

Listen to the full episode and explore every guest, topic, and moment on PodLume.