
Nov 19, 2026 · 58 min
Underinvestment sets the stage for commodity shortages
How Deficits Will Drive the Next Wave of the Commodity Supercycle | Rick Rule
Copper, uranium, and other commodities face supply constraints that could reshape mining finance, energy policy, and investor returns.
- 1Decades of underinvestment, permitting delays, rising costs, and electricity demand could force copper rationing through higher prices.
- 2Royalty and streaming companies need durable advantages and experienced management to avoid destroying value while chasing growth.
- 3Long-term uranium contracts can reduce financing costs and help developers build mines as nuclear demand expands.
Don't miss
Rick Rule explains how decades-long uranium contracts with investment-grade counterparties can make new mine construction financeable.
The brief
Rick Rule and Jack Farley begin with a portfolio shift from physical silver to mining stocks, then examine whether royalty and streaming deals are becoming dangerously competitive.
The central argument is that copper supply cannot quickly respond to higher prices after decades of underinvestment, costly energy, slow permitting, and rising electricity demand.
Rule separates exploration, development, construction, and production expertise, warning that inexperienced junior companies often attempt more than they can execute.
Gold miners may enter a more acquisitive phase, while central-bank and private demand in India and China reflects currency protection and cultural saving.
The standout case is uranium: long-term contracts with investment-grade buyers can lower financing costs enough for developers such as NextGen to build mines rather than sell them.
The episode closes by weighing copper substitution, aluminum economics, nuclear power, Japan’s reactor restarts, and the political risks that determine which projects get built.
What was said on this episode
38 statements · 20 positive · 12 negative · 1 mixed · 5 neutral
Silver stocks have outperformed physical silver this year.
“The silver stocks as a group haven't done great, but they've done better than silver has.”
Listen at 1:45
Silver stocks offer better value than physical silver.
“I still see better value in the stocks.”
Listen at 2:46
Silver stocks currently discount silver prices of $35–$40 per ounce.
“I think that the silver stocks now are discounting somewhere between $35 and $40 an ounce.”
Listen at 2:59
Silver stocks provide better value, downside protection, and upside leverage than silver.
“there's still better value, more shelter to the downside and more leverage to the upside in the silver stocks than in silver.”
Listen at 3:07
Small royalty companies and exploration-stage royalties are overvalued.
“I think the small side of the royalty space is getting overbid.”
Listen at 4:11
Copper companies will finance development by selling gold and silver byproduct streams.
“the copper companies are going to access capital for their development expenditures by selling gold and silver byproduct streams.”
Listen at 4:48
“I think they paid a fair price.”
Listen at 7:17
BHP had a higher cost of capital than Wheaton Precious Metals.
“the largest mining company in the world, BHP, had a higher cost of capital than Wheaton Precious”
Listen at 7:22
Small third-tier royalty companies require a durable competitive advantage.
“If you're buying a third-tier royalty and streaming company, say a new one or one with less than $250 million market cap, you need to look for a durable competitive advantage.”
Listen at 8:55
Outspending competitors is a poor strategy for royalty companies.
“Outspending your competition is a poor strategy.”
Listen at 10:03
Royalty businesses generally have higher returns and lower overhead than mining businesses.
“the royalty business, and to a lesser extent, the streaming business, is a better business, with generally higher returns on capital employed and lower general and administrative charges relative to the revenue stream than the mining business.”
Listen at 11:42
Low-cost, scalable projects with at least 25% returns are likely to receive funding.
“projects that appear to be in the lowest cost quartile worldwide with scale and projects that exhibit returns on capital employed in the best quartile, but at least 25%, are likely to get funded.”
Listen at 13:20
Junior mining companies may struggle to manage exploration, development, and production simultaneously.
“the idea that a junior company, as an example, a three or four hundred million market cap company, can employ all three of those skill sets simultaneously is probably problematic.”
Listen at 13:58
Ninety percent of publicly quoted exploration companies are valueless.
“90% of the publicly quoted exploration companies worldwide are valueless.”
Listen at 15:01
Copper supply is unlikely to meet demand in five years without a global depression.
“it's very difficult for me to see where the copper will come from five years from now, absent a global depression.”
Listen at 17:53
Future copper shortages will be rationed through higher prices.
“the way we ration copper in the future will be by price.”
Listen at 19:24
Resolution is the best undeveloped copper deposit in the United States.
“The best undeveloped copper deposit in the United States by a country mile is a deposit called Resolution, jointly controlled by BHP and Rio Tinto.”
Listen at 21:08
Pebble faces significant sociological and political challenges.
“Pebble in particular suffers from sociological and political challenges.”
Listen at 23:35
Major gold and silver miners will be extremely acquisitive.
“Extremely acquisitive.”
Listen at 26:39
Gold and silver miners will need acquisitions to maintain production.
“they're going to have to acquire.”
Listen at 27:41
Strategic and tactical mining acquisitions will both occur.
“I think both of those are going to occur.”
Listen at 28:43
China continues to encourage private gold ownership.
“the Chinese state is still overtly encouraging gold ownership”
Listen at 31:47
The U.S. dollar will lose 75% of its purchasing power.
“I believe that the U.S. dollar will lose and is in the process of losing 75% of its purchasing power.”
Listen at 36:01
The U.S. dollar will outperform most other currencies.
“I think it'll outperform most other currencies in the world.”
Listen at 36:09
Higher copper prices will incentivize substitution with other materials.
“If the copper price does what I think it will do over the next five years, you will have an incentive to find ways to substitute other materials for copper.”
Listen at 39:32
Higher copper prices will incentivize more efficient copper use.
“you will have an incentive to find ways to use copper more efficiently.”
Listen at 39:40
Aluminum substitution for copper depends on energy intensity and aluminum prices.
“the ability of aluminum to substitute for copper will depend on the energy intensity in the aluminum business and what happens to the price of aluminum.”
Listen at 41:14
Greater nuclear deployment will substantially reduce nuclear plant construction costs.
“increased utilization of nuclear power and increased investment in and deployment of nuclear power plants will bring down the upfront capital cost of building nuclear power plants a bunch.”
Listen at 43:05
The long-term energy outlook is favorable over a 10–15-year horizon.
“the future in energy is great as long as you define the future 10 or 15 years from now.”
Listen at 43:55
The energy outlook over five to seven years is unfavorable.
“If you define it five or six or seven years from now, the outlook is not good at all.”
Listen at 44:00
Japan will become a major unexpected uranium user within two years.
“within the next two years, the surprise user will be Japan.”
Listen at 44:29
Japan offers the easiest near-term source of additional uranium demand.
“The lowest hanging fruit in the uranium demand space is Japan.”
Listen at 45:25
Long-term uranium contracts can help NextGen secure mine-construction financing.
“they can absolutely take that purchase order to the bank to secure the financing necessary to build the mine.”
Listen at 48:59
Investment-grade uranium offtake contracts lower issuers’ cost of capital.
“That goes an awful long way to ensuring the security of capital and will absolutely lower the cost of capital to the issuer”
Listen at 49:38
Long-term contracts allow NextGen to credibly threaten to build its mine.
“it allows NextGen as an example to do something else. threatened to build a mine.”
Listen at 50:04
Uranium Royalty paid a high price for the Sweetwater royalty.
“They paid a very full price.”
Listen at 52:42
Uranium Royalty could create substantial value by applying uranium multiples to Soda and Trona cash flow.
“If they can perform the magic of using Soda and Trona cash flow at uranium multiples, they will have hit a long ball home run.”
Listen at 53:13
Family offices will enter the royalty and streaming sector at scale.
“I think you're going to see the family offices, among other things, come into the royalty and streaming space. particularly the streaming space in size.”
Listen at 56:18
Statements are attributed to the speaker as said on the episode and reflect their view at the time, not PodLume's. They are not advice.
Weekly email
State of the Pod, every Monday
The week's most-discussed names and stories from podcasts, with the moments behind them. Free, five minutes, unsubscribe in one click.