This Week in Startups
This Week in Startups

Oct 22, 2026 · 1h 41m

Listen from 21:20

Listen at 21:20

VCs debate whether Silicon Valley would fund Elizabeth Holmes again

We asked 3 VCs: would you invest in Elizabeth Holmes’ next startup? | E2353

The discussion tests whether venture capital can separate genuine redemption from charisma, reputation, and the trust networks that repeatedly weaken diligence.

3 key takeaways
  1. 1Investors debate whether a working product could outweigh Elizabeth Holmes’s criminal record and the difficulty of sustaining trust with her.
  2. 2The panel argues that referrals, prestigious co-investors, and founder-friendly rhetoric can obscure warning signs rather than replace independent diligence.
  3. 3Pro rata rights and AI voice licensing expose how financing and identity rules lag behind the power of investors, founders, and platforms.

Don't miss

The panel confronts whether it would take Elizabeth Holmes’s meeting or invest in a hypothetical company with a working product after her prison sentence.

The brief

Jason Calacanis, Sam Lessin, Jenny Fielding, and Paige Doherty use Elizabeth Holmes and You Can See Everything to examine how charisma turns uncertainty into conviction.

The panel’s Holmes debate asks whether a working product could overcome fraud, prison, and damaged trust, distinguishing extreme ambition from deception without pretending diligence can catch everything.

FTX becomes the cautionary counterexample: prestigious investors and co-investors reinforced collective confidence, showing how trust networks can produce collective diligence failure.

The conversation broadens to pro rata rights and founder-friendly financing, arguing that fair terms must be settled early rather than reshaped by later financing pressure.

An ElevenLabs voice-cloning dispute brings the same trust problem into identity rights, as the panel weighs publicity law, NIL, licensing, and compensation for recognizable voices.

What was said on this episode

35 statements · 14 positive · 13 negative · 2 mixed · 6 neutral

  1. Sam Lessinon Consumer skiing and snow options marketPositive3:13

    A consumer options market for skiing and snow could become a viable business.

    “I think there is definitely a business to be had in an options market around specifically for consumers around skiing and snow.”

    Listen at 3:13

  2. Sam Lessinon MarketsPositive6:06

    Markets for everything can transmit information and improve understanding.

    “there should be a market in everything because that's actually how you can pump information through the world, understand what's going on.”

    Listen at 6:06

  3. You Can See Everything is an exceptionally brilliant film.

    “it's just an incredibly brilliant film.”

    Listen at 21:20

  4. You Can See Everything brilliantly comments on human unknowability.

    “This is like a hugely brilliant commentary on the unknowability of humans.”

    Listen at 22:24

  5. Lon Harrison Nathan FielderPositive24:27

    Nathan Fielder’s film method is a brilliant combination of comedy and documentary techniques.

    “it's such a brilliant idea, a way to bring together like the comedy he's done in the past with this new concept.”

    Listen at 24:27

  6. Elizabeth Holmes intentionally lied about Theranos.

    “she was absolutely—”

    Listen at 29:24

  7. Sam Lessinon Sam LessinNegative30:48

    Sam Lessin’s fund experiences approximately a 1% fraud rate.

    “I think we probably run about a 1% oops, it was fraud rate at our fund.”

    Listen at 30:48

  8. Sam Lessinon Venture-capital due diligenceNeutral31:50

    Due-diligence intensity should scale with investment check size.

    “I think it scales with the size of check”

    Listen at 31:50

  9. Sam Lessinon Venture-capital due diligenceNeutral32:01

    Larger venture checks require substantially more due diligence.

    “you can't afford that much due diligence if you're writing a $100,000 check. Correct. If you're writing a $100 million check or a billion dollar check, you can't afford to not do it.”

    Listen at 32:01

  10. Sam Lessinon Large venture checksNeutral32:05

    Large venture checks require extensive due diligence.

    “If you're writing a $100 million check or a billion dollar check, you can't afford to not do it.”

    Listen at 32:05

  11. Paige Finn Dohertyon Founder diligencePositive34:33

    Investors should repeatedly ask simple diligence questions and observe founder responses.

    “continuing to ask those questions. That may feel weird or obvious. Um, and like seeing how someone responds is the approach that I've taken.”

    Listen at 34:33

  12. Jenny Fieldingon Jenny Fielding’s early-stage investment diligenceNegative35:26

    Jenny overlooked reference checks because of strong founder conviction.

    “I did not do enough reference checks on this person because I had such a great kind of like chemistry with him and just like I really wanted to believe.”

    Listen at 35:26

  13. Sam Lessinon Venture-capital co-investment diligenceNegative37:33

    Trusted co-investors caused Sam’s fund to rely on their diligence.

    “the diligence was we love these people. They think this founder is great. They're doing it. And like, we're sidecarrying it and coming along for the ride, drafting on their diligence.”

    Listen at 37:33

  14. Sam Lessinon Venture-investment relationshipsNeutral37:54

    Relationships materially influence venture-investment decisions.

    “relationships matter a lot.”

    Listen at 37:54

  15. Elizabeth Holmes’s portrayal was highly manipulative and Oscar-worthy.

    “this was a huge manipulation, and I thought she did a brilliant job and should get the Oscar.”

    Listen at 45:02

  16. Elizabeth Holmes will return to Silicon Valley.

    “I think she'll be back.”

    Listen at 52:20

  17. Elizabeth Holmes’s entrepreneurial career is over.

    “I think she's done.”

    Listen at 52:24

  18. Elizabeth Holmes will never regain others’ trust.

    “I do think the line Nathan says of like, no one will ever trust you again is accurate.”

    Listen at 54:17

  19. Sam Lessinon a16z funding of Elizabeth HolmesNegative54:34

    a16z will not fund Elizabeth Holmes’s next company.

    “Adam Neumann, can his next company get funded by a16z? That's not going to happen for Elizabeth Holmes is my bet.”

    Listen at 54:34

  20. Sam Lessinon Elizabeth Holmes’s hypothetical companyMixed55:41

    Sam Lessin might trade Holmes’s company but would not hold it long term.

    “as a capitalist, I might have to take the trade and the risk on the trade, but I would not be a holder of it.”

    Listen at 55:41

  21. Sam Lessinon Private-market secondary salesNegative57:07

    Private-market sellers create adverse selection, requiring independent diligence.

    “anyone calls you and tells you they're selling in the private market, whatever reason they're telling you for There is an adverse selection to that and you better be doing your own homework.”

    Listen at 57:07

  22. Paige Finn Dohertyon Elizabeth Holmes’s hypothetical companyNegative1:00:21

    Paige Finn Doherty would initially decline investing in Holmes’s company.

    “First small check. My heart is saying out.”

    Listen at 1:00:21

  23. Elizabeth Holmes will eventually solve a real biotech problem with AI or a partner.

    “she's gonna actually solve a real problem in the world.”

    Listen at 1:02:19

  24. Jenny Fieldingon Elizabeth Holmes working prototypeNegative1:02:29

    Jenny Fielding predicts Holmes will not have a working prototype within five years.

    “I'll take the under on it.”

    Listen at 1:02:29

  25. Sam Lessinon Seed venture pro rata rightsPositive1:04:23

    Seed investors should secure durable, unconditional pro rata rights.

    “these docs have pro rata rights in them, right? They're not pro rata rights contingent on other people. They're not pro rata rights that kind of die after a round, they're pro rata rights.”

    Listen at 1:04:23

  26. Sam Lessinon Seed venture business modelNegative1:04:42

    Seed venture funds cannot operate successfully without pro rata rights.

    “the seed business model doesn't work without pro rata rights.”

    Listen at 1:04:42

  27. Sam Lessinon Pro rata rightsPositive1:06:40

    Sam Lessin considers pro rata rights essential and will defend them indefinitely.

    “for me, they're completely ironclad and important, and I will fight for them forever.”

    Listen at 1:06:40

  28. Jenny Fieldingon Founder-friendly venture normsNeutral1:08:58

    Founder-friendly norms correlate with the amount of capital entering the market.

    “they correlate with how much money is flooding into, you know, the market”

    Listen at 1:08:58

  29. Jenny Fieldingon AI voice rightsNeutral1:23:24

    Courts have not yet clearly resolved AI voice-rights questions.

    “I don't think we have a clear answer from the courts, to tell you the truth.”

    Listen at 1:23:24

  30. Jason Calacanison AI voice usePositive1:24:25

    AI systems should obtain permission and compensate people for using their voices.

    “get permission, uh, and compensate me.”

    Listen at 1:24:25

  31. Jason Calacanison Right of publicityNegative1:25:04

    Publicity rights prohibit using Jason’s identity to sell products without permission.

    “the right of publicity means you can't use me to sell your thing.”

    Listen at 1:25:04

  32. The MH370 video used open-source technology or a platform based on Chris Williamson’s voice.

    “that MH370 video that was done— I believe this is where I stand currently in the truth, and I could be proven wrong again— that MH370 video was made with open source or some platform based on Chris's voice.”

    Listen at 1:29:44

  33. Jason Calacanison ElevenLabsPositive1:31:09

    Public figures can test demand by pricing access to their cloned voices on ElevenLabs.

    “put your cloned voice on ElevenLabs with a price and see if there's a market for it.”

    Listen at 1:31:09

  34. Knox Metals recently reached $25 million in annualized revenue.

    “they recently announced they hit $25 million in annualized revenue a year.”

    Listen at 1:36:10

  35. Obliteration provides LLMs designed for high-risk industries.

    “It is for high-risk industries, LLMs for high-risk industries.”

    Listen at 1:39:16

Statements are attributed to the speaker as said on the episode and reflect their view at the time, not PodLume's. They are not advice.

Books & mentions

Some links are affiliate links — PodLume may earn a commission if you buy.

Weekly email

State of the Pod, every Monday

The week's most-discussed names and stories from podcasts, with the moments behind them. Free, five minutes, unsubscribe in one click.

Listen to the full episode and explore every guest, topic, and moment on PodLume.