The Rules of Investing
The Rules of Investing

Sep 18, 2026 · 42 min

Volatility widens Australia’s value-investing gap

Hofflin: Big moves are creating great value on the ASX

Philipp Hofflin argues that unusually wide valuation differences and sharp market reactions are creating opportunities, while macroeconomic and AI risks complicate the case for value.

3 key takeaways
  1. 1Reduced liquidity and shifting expectations are driving unusually large share-price moves across major Australian companies.
  2. 2Hofflin sees opportunities among fallen angels and less fashionable sectors, including healthcare, nickel and wine.
  3. 3He selects IDP Education as a five-year holding despite severe recent earnings pressure and political risks.

Don't miss

Philipp Hofflin selects IDP Education as the company he would own if markets closed for five years.

The brief

Lazard portfolio manager Philipp Hofflin defines value investing as buying businesses priced for low expectations, then tests that discipline against inflation, geopolitics, debt and AI spending.

Large Australian companies including CSL and Cochlear are making unusually large moves around results, a sign that reduced liquidity has made markets less tolerant of disappointment.

Hofflin argues that the unusually wide gap between expensive and cheap stocks supports a portfolio approach built on repeated purchases, disciplined selling and empirical results.

His opportunity set includes fallen angels and less fashionable sectors, with Sonic Healthcare, Nickel Industries and Treasury Wine Estates among the areas he discusses.

Asked what he would own if markets closed for five years, Hofflin chooses IDP Education, citing its quality, balance sheet, market-share gains and buybacks despite recent pressure.

What was said on this episode

53 statements · 24 positive · 26 negative · 3 mixed

  1. Buying low-expectation, low-multiple companies outperforms betting on future transformations over the long run.

    “if you buy low expectations, low multiples, high cash flow yields and so forth, in the long run, you do better than if you... hope for some great transformation in the future.”

    Listen at 1:21

  2. Inflation is currently the biggest problem facing markets.

    “inflation. And that is, I think, the biggest problem out there at the moment.”

    Listen at 2:29

  3. Philipp Hofflinon Australia’s re-regulated labour marketNegative4:54

    Australia’s re-regulated labour market makes the economy less flexible and more inflation-prone.

    “that means the economy is less flexible and more inflation-prone because it can't sustain the same sort of growth rates.”

    Listen at 4:54

  4. Philipp Hofflinon United States fiscal deficitNegative5:10

    The United States fiscal deficit is unsustainable despite economic growth and low unemployment.

    “They're running a 6% deficit. in a boom with low unemployment. It is completely and utterly unsustainable.”

    Listen at 5:10

  5. Philipp Hofflinon United States fiscal deficitNegative5:16

    The United States’ 6% deficit during an economic boom is unsustainable and reckless.

    “It is completely and utterly unsustainable. It's just reckless, it seems to me.”

    Listen at 5:16

  6. Philipp Hofflinon United States fiscal deficitNegative5:43

    The United States will either curb its deficit or face a market crisis.

    “So either they stop or the market will stop them. There's a crisis.”

    Listen at 5:43

  7. Philipp Hofflinon US and Australian bond yieldsNegative5:49

    Rising bond yields in the US and Australia are harmful for markets.

    “Bond yields are going up. And then both in the US and Australia, bond yields just hit a 15-year high. And that is bad for the market.”

    Listen at 5:49

  8. Philipp Hofflinon High inflation, tight monetary policy, and high asset pricesNegative8:55

    High inflation, tight monetary policy, and high asset prices are incompatible.

    “high inflation and tight monetary policy and aggressive central banks and high asset prices just don't mix.”

    Listen at 8:55

  9. AI is likely to remain inflationary for the next couple of years before becoming deflationary.

    “I think AI will eventually turn deflationary. But at the moment, yes, it is absolutely for the next couple of years. It looks like, you know, that boom is just going to roll on.”

    Listen at 9:44

  10. AI will eventually become deflationary, but its boom will continue for the next couple of years.

    “AI will eventually turn deflationary. But at the moment, yes, it is absolutely for the next couple of years. It looks like, you know, that boom is just going to roll on.”

    Listen at 9:44

  11. Philipp Hofflinon Military spendingNegative10:13

    Military spending contributes to inflation.

    “military spending also is an inflationary force in that sense.”

    Listen at 10:13

  12. Philipp Hofflinon Western inflationary dynamicsNegative10:44

    Current Western inflationary dynamics are unlikely to change soon.

    “it's very hard to see the dynamics at the moment changing.”

    Listen at 10:44

  13. Philipp Hofflinon Interest ratesNegative10:57

    Interest-rate uncertainty warrants caution among investors.

    “We don't think we can forecast interest rates any better than anybody else. I think it makes you cautious.”

    Listen at 10:57

  14. Philipp Hofflinon Interest-rate outlookNegative11:03

    Uncertainty about interest rates warrants investor caution.

    “It makes you cautious.”

    Listen at 11:03

  15. Philipp Hofflinon CSLPositive14:14

    CSL shares rose 38% in one month after its reporting result.

    “the stock just, you know, it was up 38% in a month.”

    Listen at 14:14

  16. Philipp Hofflinon CSLPositive14:27

    CSL’s 38% rally was justified because the stock had been substantially underpriced.

    “I think it was justified in the sense that the stock was just so underpriced.”

    Listen at 14:27

  17. Philipp Hofflinon Market liquidityNegative16:07

    Reduced market liquidity increases volatility.

    “Therefore, any volatility becomes greater because there's less depth in the market.”

    Listen at 16:07

  18. Philipp Hofflinon CochlearNegative17:01

    Cochlear shares fell 32% on its warning day and 45% over that week.

    “cochlear fell 32% on that day of the warning in April, and it was down 45% in the week.”

    Listen at 17:01

  19. Philipp Hofflinon CochlearPositive17:16

    Cochlear became mispriced after its decline and subsequently rallied 50%.

    “it became completely differently priced. We bought it. It's already rallied 50%.”

    Listen at 17:16

  20. Philipp Hofflinon Market inefficiencyPositive17:33

    Greater market inefficiency creates opportunities for fundamental investors.

    “it gives us opportunities.”

    Listen at 17:33

  21. Vibe coding may cause companies to replace SaaS subscriptions with internal development.

    “That companies are going to turn around to their service provider and say, look, I'm paying you $2 million for this license. I can get my own people to do my own stuff.”

    Listen at 18:30

  22. AI could eventually replace white-collar workers and their software simultaneously.

    “The real risk is that sometime over the next five or ten years, the company replaces the workforce and the software in one hit.”

    Listen at 19:04

  23. Philipp Hofflinon SaaS providersNegative19:43

    AI-driven replacement of workers and software poses an existential risk to SaaS providers.

    “And that's an existential risk, right?”

    Listen at 19:43

  24. AI may become capable enough to dominate mathematical research discussion within a year.

    “I think it's pretty clear that in a year or so... the entire mathematical community will probably just be commentating on what AI does.”

    Listen at 20:35

  25. AI may become capable enough to dominate mathematical research within about a year.

    “in a year or so... the entire mathematical community will probably just be commentating on what AI does.”

    Listen at 20:37

  26. Philipp Hofflinon SaaS stocksNegative21:00

    SaaS stocks remain expensive at roughly 50 times earnings despite falling from 120 times.

    “these stocks have gone from trading on 120 times to trading on 50 times. 50 times isn't exactly cheap.”

    Listen at 21:00

  27. BHP and Woodside have predictable roles supplying materials for future economic expansion.

    “I know what BHP is going to be doing, or Woodside.”

    Listen at 21:16

  28. BHP and Woodside should benefit from materials demand during an AI-driven economic boom.

    “I know what BHP is going to be doing, or Woodside. Because if all this works out well, and we get an enormous economic boom, we're going to need to build things”

    Listen at 21:16

  29. Philipp Hofflinon White-collar software companiesNegative21:44

    White-collar software companies are currently too difficult to buy confidently.

    “So very hard to buy them at the moment.”

    Listen at 21:44

  30. Philipp Hofflinon Valuation dispersionPositive23:18

    Valuation dispersion still offers a strong opportunity for value investors.

    “So in that sense, yes, it's a very good opportunity still.”

    Listen at 23:18

  31. Sonic Healthcare is under active consideration as a value opportunity.

    “We are looking very carefully at Sonic Healthcare.”

    Listen at 24:17

  32. Sonic Healthcare is a current healthcare investment opportunity under consideration.

    “We are looking very carefully at Sonic Healthcare. which is a more recent opportunity.”

    Listen at 24:17

  33. Domino’s is recovering slowly, and Hofflin’s fund still owns it.

    “We're still in dominoes. That one's turning out to be a slow recovery.”

    Listen at 25:23

  34. IDP Education is currently an attractive investment proposition.

    “It's a good proposition, I think, now.”

    Listen at 26:12

  35. Nickel Industries remains an attractive stock.

    “One stock we still like is Nickel Industries.”

    Listen at 27:04

  36. Treasury Wine Estates remains attractive as a long-term investment.

    “So still like that one.”

    Listen at 27:54

  37. Philipp Hofflinon Australian banksNegative28:02

    Australian banks remain too expensive for value investors.

    “The banks are still far too expensive for us”

    Listen at 28:02

  38. Philipp Hofflinon Australian minersNegative28:20

    Hofflin’s portfolio is currently underweight Australian miners.

    “we're now actually underweight.”

    Listen at 28:20

  39. Philipp Hofflinon US value portfolioPositive30:40

    US value portfolios outperformed growth portfolios twentyfold over 75 years.

    “over the 75 years, the value portfolio has beaten the growth portfolio 20-fold. That's over 4% per annum on average.”

    Listen at 30:40

  40. Value investing’s cumulative earnings advantage appears across major global markets.

    “This is a universal phenomenon.”

    Listen at 34:06

  41. Philipp Hofflinon Investment returnsPositive34:16

    Increasing earnings is necessary for sustainable superior investment returns.

    “It's the only way to make sustainable, superior returns.”

    Listen at 34:16

  42. Whitehaven Coal rose thirteenfold from its COVID-era low within two years.

    “the stock pushed $11 two years later. It went up 13-fold from the bottom.”

    Listen at 36:15

  43. Philipp Hofflinon US equity marketNegative36:54

    The US equity market is currently extremely expensive.

    “the US, I think, is horrendously expensive.”

    Listen at 36:54

  44. Philipp Hofflinon US equity marketNegative37:28

    The US equity market could lose at least half its value.

    “US, I think, is in that position. It's a market that can halve or more than halve”

    Listen at 37:28

  45. Philipp Hofflinon US stock marketNegative37:30

    The US stock market could halve or more because its earnings are overstated.

    “It's a market that can halve or more than halve and it doesn't bounce because the earnings are just completely overstated.”

    Listen at 37:30

  46. Philipp Hofflinon US equity marketNegative37:43

    The US equity market is probably the biggest risk to Australia’s market.

    “I think it's probably the biggest risk to our market as well.”

    Listen at 37:43

  47. Philipp Hofflinon CSLPositive38:17

    CSL was recently considered very cheap by Hofflin.

    “In principle, two or three months ago I would have said, easy, CSL, right? This is so cheap.”

    Listen at 38:17

  48. IDP Education remains fundamentally a good business despite weak revenue.

    “it's actually a good business.”

    Listen at 39:01

  49. IDP Education continues gaining market share and signing new university clients.

    “They still gain market share. They sign up new universities.”

    Listen at 39:12

  50. IDP Education has an asset-light model, strong returns, sound balance sheet and substantial buybacks.

    “Asset light, good returns, good balance sheet. They're buying back 10% of their register at these prices.”

    Listen at 39:20

  51. “It is now at this low point on less than seven times.”

    Listen at 39:58

  52. IDP Education’s asymmetric outlook makes it worth owning.

    “But the asymmetry in the outlook here is great. So I think it is worth owning some.”

    Listen at 40:49

  53. Investors should own some IDP Education shares because the outlook is asymmetric.

    “So I think it is worth owning some. That's why we own some.”

    Listen at 40:51

Statements are attributed to the speaker as said on the episode and reflect their view at the time, not PodLume's. They are not advice.

Weekly email

State of the Pod, every Monday

The week's most-discussed names and stories from podcasts, with the moments behind them. Free, five minutes, unsubscribe in one click.

Listen to the full episode and explore every guest, topic, and moment on PodLume.