The Diary Of A CEO with Steven Bartlett

War expert warns of high probability of US ground troops in Iran

URGENT UPDATE - Iran War Expert: 70% Chance US Sends Troops To Iran THIS WEEK! | Robert Pape

As tensions escalate in the Middle East, a leading conflict modeler explains why current US military strategies are failing to contain Iran and how the crisis threatens the global economy.

3 key takeaways
  1. 1Iran has grown strategically stronger despite US airstrikes by leveraging its control over the vital Strait of Hormuz.
  2. 2Historical policy traps from the Vietnam War are repeating as the US struggles to force the shipping lanes open.
  3. 3Ground occupations are statistically shown to trigger suicide terrorism campaigns far more than aerial bombing campaigns.

The brief

War expert Robert Pape warns that the United States is facing a high probability of deploying ground troops to Iran, as a deadly new phase of the conflict begins to take shape.

Despite heavy US bombing campaigns, Iran has actually grown stronger by leveraging its control over the critical Strait of Hormuz to threaten the global economy.

Drawing parallels to Lyndon B. Johnson and the Vietnam War, Pape explains how the current administration is falling into a dangerous escalation trap in the Middle East.

Pape reveals that ground occupations, rather than aerial bombings, are the primary triggers for suicide terrorism campaigns, complicating US domestic political strategy.

What was said on this episode

39 statements · 14 positive · 23 negative · 2 neutral

  1. Robert Papeon IranPositive0:00

    Iran is currently stronger than before the war began.

    “Iran is stronger today than it was before the war started.”

    Listen at 0:00

  2. Robert Papeon Global economic crisisNegative0:10

    The global economic crisis will worsen over the next few months.

    “in the next few months, the world economic crisis is going to grow.”

    Listen at 0:10

  3. Robert Papeon US ground operation in IranPositive1:11

    A US limited ground operation in Iran has nearly a 70% chance by week’s end.

    “It's bordering on 70% now, probably by the end of this week.”

    Listen at 1:11

  4. Robert Papeon Foreign ground occupationNegative1:18

    Foreign ground control of territory is the strongest risk factor for suicide terrorism.

    “controlling pieces of homeland territory is the biggest risk factor for suicide terrorism.”

    Listen at 1:18

  5. Robert Papeon Air powerNegative3:37

    Air power alone has never toppled a regime since World War I.

    “air power alone had never toppled a regime going all the way back to World War I.”

    Listen at 3:37

  6. Robert Papeon J.D. VanceNegative6:21

    Vice President Vance’s business-deal approach misunderstands international politics.

    “this is just a fundamental misunderstanding of international politics.”

    Listen at 6:21

  7. Robert Papeon US-Iran Memorandum of UnderstandingPositive8:06

    The memorandum would provide Iran a roadmap to regional hegemony.

    “this mou, fundamentally a roadmap to Iran becoming the regional hegemon.”

    Listen at 8:06

  8. Robert Papeon US-Iran Memorandum of UnderstandingPositive9:27

    The agreement gives Iran lasting control over Hormuz and discretion to set transit fees.

    “This basically gives Iran control of the Strait of Hormuz, also of the discretion to set the fees for as far as the eye can see, with no constraint whatsoever.”

    Listen at 9:27

  9. Control of Hormuz would give control over 20% of global oil.

    “controlling Hormuz means controlling 20% of the world's oil.”

    Listen at 10:12

  10. Robert Papeon Iran’s control of HormuzNegative12:20

    Iran’s leverage would decline within five years if limited to Hormuz control.

    “If you only control Hormuz within 5 years, good chance your power is going to be whittled away.”

    Listen at 12:20

  11. Robert Papeon IranPositive21:23

    Iran’s control of Hormuz has made it stronger than before the war.

    “There's really no question at this point that Iran is stronger today than it was before the war started on February 28.”

    Listen at 21:23

  12. Robert Papeon Iranian drone and missile attacksNegative23:06

    Iranian drone and missile swarms overwhelm US defensive capabilities.

    “they're essentially doing swarm, they're saturating our defensive capability.”

    Listen at 23:06

  13. Robert Papeon Iranian missile and drone arsenalPositive24:03

    Iran retains a well-stocked full missile arsenal and shows no sign of exhausting ammunition.

    “the full arsenal that Iran has, the full range of the arsenal, appears to be fully there stocked very well. And they're showing no signs of running out of ammo.”

    Listen at 24:03

  14. Robert Papeon Iranian drone and missile capabilityNegative25:30

    The US cannot readily eliminate Iran’s remaining drone and missile capability.

    “it's very difficult, if not impossible, to eliminate that capability.”

    Listen at 25:30

  15. Robert Papeon Iranian drone-search areaNeutral27:08

    Iran’s drone-search area is approximately one-and-a-half times California’s size.

    “This area, this area like this is bigger than California. It's one and a half times the size of California.”

    Listen at 27:08

  16. Robert Papeon Iranian drone productionPositive29:16

    Iran was producing 55,000 drones annually for Russia.

    “These drones, they were making 55,000 a year and giving them to Russia.”

    Listen at 29:16

  17. Robert Papeon Global oil refining capacityNegative35:30

    The conflict has shut down roughly 25% to one-third of global refining capacity.

    “that means you've shut down something like 25%, or a third of the world's refining capacity.”

    Listen at 35:30

  18. Robert Papeon Trump’s military options in IranNegative40:21

    Trump is pursuing military options that are unlikely to reopen Hormuz.

    “I think he's pursuing military options he likely knows are unlikely to work.”

    Listen at 40:21

  19. Robert Papeon Iranian nuclear weaponsNegative50:27

    Iran is very likely to possess nuclear weapons within one or two years.

    “they're very likely to have nuclear weapons.”

    Listen at 50:27

  20. Robert Papeon US reopening of the Strait of HormuzNegative52:08

    The United States almost surely cannot physically reopen Hormuz before the midterms.

    “the answer is almost surely not.”

    Listen at 52:08

  21. Robert Papeon US strategy for reopening HormuzNegative55:17

    The United States cannot fully reopen Hormuz using its current strategy.

    “The answer is it the United States cannot do it”

    Listen at 55:17

  22. Robert Papeon US ground troops in IranNegative59:22

    US troops have a low chance of holding an Iranian port for several weeks.

    “there's a chance, and I say it's a low chance.”

    Listen at 59:22

  23. Robert Papeon US ground operation in IranNegative1:00:02

    A limited US ground operation could cause hundreds of American deaths over weeks.

    “So you're talking about hundreds dead over a period of at least weeks.”

    Listen at 1:00:02

  24. Robert Papeon American troop deathsPositive1:02:58

    American troop deaths can strengthen near-term public support for the war.

    “in the near term, deaths can actually harden support for the war.”

    Listen at 1:02:58

  25. Robert Papeon US ground operation in IranPositive1:03:13

    A US limited ground operation in Iran has over 50%, nearly 70%, probability.

    “Well over 50%, I think it's bordering on 70% now.”

    Listen at 1:03:13

  26. Robert Papeon American troops and civiliansNegative1:10:54

    Escalation could lead to a mass-casualty attack on US troops or civilians.

    “there could be a mass casualty attack either against our troops or against American civilians.”

    Listen at 1:10:54

  27. Robert Papeon Ground forces and suicide terrorismNegative1:15:00

    Ground forces increase suicide terrorism risk through political control, not merely killing.

    “It's the political control part that comes with the ground forces.”

    Listen at 1:15:00

  28. Robert Papeon Iran WarNegative1:16:49

    There is currently no achievable off-ramp restoring negotiations without strategic defeat.

    “No, Steven, there is not an achievable off ramp.”

    Listen at 1:16:49

  29. Robert Papeon Congressional war fundingPositive1:18:32

    Democratic control of Congress could end the war by cutting its funding.

    “the way out would be if the midterms come and the Democrats win either the House or the House and the Senate and they shut down the money for the war.”

    Listen at 1:18:32

  30. Republicans have a good chance of losing one or both congressional chambers.

    “there's a good chance he will lose in the midterms, meaning that the Republicans will lose one or both houses in Congress.”

    Listen at 1:19:50

  31. A mass-casualty attack would improve Trump and Republican midterm prospects.

    “If we have a mass casualty attack, this will increase the odds of Trump and the Republicans winning in midterms.”

    Listen at 1:25:09

  32. A global economic crisis without mass-casualty attacks would likely cause Republican midterm losses.

    “if we have a world economic crisis without the mass casualty attack, then I think it's likely that the Republicans will lose in the midterms.”

    Listen at 1:25:20

  33. Robert Papeon US missile interceptorsNegative1:27:47

    The US has a low chance of running out of missile interceptors.

    “I think that there's some chance we'll run out of those interceptors. But even there, I think it's low.”

    Listen at 1:27:47

  34. Robert Papeon Trump’s Iran-war objectiveNeutral1:28:53

    Trump’s near-term objective is to achieve a symbolic military victory.

    “President Trump's goal between now and the midterms is very simple, a symbolic victory.”

    Listen at 1:28:53

  35. Robert Papeon Trump’s symbolic victoryPositive1:29:02

    Trump’s symbolic victory might hold for one or two weeks.

    “That would look like a victory that would hold for a while, week, maybe two weeks.”

    Listen at 1:29:02

  36. Robert Papeon US Middle East strategyPositive1:29:59

    Pape recommends a multi-year strategy to rebalance regional power.

    “What I would do is try to design a several year strategy to build a better balance of power in the region”

    Listen at 1:29:59

  37. Robert Papeon Vladimir PutinNegative1:33:55

    Putin will likely escalate pressure on Europe as the Iran crisis worsens.

    “he will likely escalate more, put more pressure on Europe”

    Listen at 1:33:55

  38. Robert Papeon US ground operations in IranNegative1:34:35

    US ground operations will enter an Iranian island or coastal area within months.

    “I think we're going to, in the next few months, cross the threshold with ground operations into either one of the islands or, or part of the coast of Iran”

    Listen at 1:34:35

  39. Robert Papeon Iranian peopleNegative1:37:12

    Meaningful hope for the Iranian people is probably five to ten years away.

    “real hope for the Iranian people is five or ten years away.”

    Listen at 1:37:12

Statements are attributed to the speaker as said on the episode and reflect their view at the time, not PodLume's. They are not advice.

Weekly email

State of the Pod, every Monday

The week's most-discussed names and stories from podcasts, with the moments behind them. Free, five minutes, unsubscribe in one click.

Listen to the full episode and explore every guest, topic, and moment on PodLume.