The Megyn Kelly Show
The Megyn Kelly Show

Sep 21, 2026 · 1h 41m

Listen from 1:31:38

Listen at 1:31:38

A grief-stricken case tests forgiveness, evidence, and parental responsibility

Presley Gerber Dead at 27, Plus Nikole Hannah-Jones Admits She Harmed Her Daughter's Education, with Stu Burguiere | Ep. 1402

The episode connects a child-death trial, addiction, and a school-choice controversy through questions about mental illness, ideology, and responsibility.

3 key takeaways
  1. 1Patrick Clancy’s public account brings forgiveness and mental illness into a trial shaped by grief, conspiracy theories, and scrutiny of a holdout juror.
  2. 2The discussion of Presley Gerber’s death questions whether privilege and family support can overcome substance dependence and the risks of child modeling.
  3. 3Nikole Hannah-Jones’s school decision becomes a broader argument about whether ideological commitments can override a child’s educational interests.

Don't miss

Patrick Clancy’s account of forgiveness and the final moments with his son becomes the episode’s emotional and ethical center.

The brief

Megyn Kelly opens with Patrick Clancy’s 60 Minutes interview, the Lindsay Clancy case, and defense arguments aimed at a holdout juror.

The discussion of Presley Gerber’s overdose examines addiction, privilege, family support, and whether child modeling exposes young people to pressures they cannot reasonably manage.

Patrick Clancy describes forgiveness, mental illness, and the deaths of his children; Megyn and Stu debate public exposure, responsibility, and the limits of sympathy.

The hosts argue that conspiracy theories resist personal testimony and evidence, while attacks on a holdout juror threaten the independence of the justice system.

The episode closes with criticism of Nikole Hannah-Jones’s school-choice decisions and a dispute over whether ideology displaced her daughter’s educational interests.

What was said on this episode

35 statements · 9 positive · 22 negative · 4 neutral

  1. Megyn Kellyon Nicole Hannah-Jones school choiceNegative2:52

    Nicole Hannah-Jones undereducated her daughter and reduced her opportunities by choosing the school.

    “she did undereducate her daughter and take away actual meaningful opportunities that that kid could have had”

    Listen at 2:52

  2. Megyn Kellyon WokeNegative3:16

    Wokeism primarily functions as virtue signaling to elevate perceived moral status.

    “The whole point of wokeism is to virtue signal so other people think you're better than you are and than they are.”

    Listen at 3:16

  3. Megyn Kellyon abrupt drug withdrawalNegative7:39

    Abrupt cessation during detox can be physically dangerous for people with drug addiction.

    “they have to go inpatient for the detox period because it's genuinely physically dangerous to them, drug addicts, if you just go cold turkey.”

    Listen at 7:39

  4. Megyn Kellyon Abrupt drug cessationNegative7:42

    Abruptly stopping drugs can be physically dangerous for people with addiction.

    “it's genuinely physically dangerous to them, drug addicts, if you just go cold turkey.”

    Listen at 7:42

  5. Megyn Kellyon Psychiatrist-supervised psychedelicsPositive10:27

    Psychiatrist-supervised psychedelics can substantially improve some people’s lives.

    “psychedelics in a controlled form under the care of a psychiatrist can be life-changing for a lot of people.”

    Listen at 10:27

  6. Nearly all of Presley Gerber’s cited medications had drowsiness as a side effect.

    “Virtually every single one of those, a side effect is drowsiness.”

    Listen at 20:11

  7. Megyn Kellyon Child modelingNegative27:55

    Putting children into modeling is reckless because modeling is a harmful industry.

    “I just think it's a reckless decision. I think it's known to be a terrible industry.”

    Listen at 27:55

  8. Megyn Kellyon SuboxonePositive31:52

    Suboxone is highly effective for helping opioid addicts taper off opioids.

    “It's actually a miracle drug.”

    Listen at 31:52

  9. Presley Gerber apparently received a high-dose ibogaine treatment at a Mexican clinic.

    “it appears that he went to a Mexican treatment clinic. and received a single high-dose administration of the naturally occurring psychoactive substance, Ibogaine.”

    Listen at 34:59

  10. Megyn Kellyon ibogaineNegative36:23

    Ibogaine treatment did not prevent Presley Gerber’s subsequent death.

    “Obviously, it didn't work.”

    Listen at 36:23

  11. Megyn Kellyon Children’s parental timePositive38:55

    Children primarily need sustained time with a loving parent.

    “What they actually do need is time with you. That's it. More than anything else, they need time with a loving parent.”

    Listen at 38:55

  12. Megyn Kellyon Parenting opportunitiesNegative41:59

    Parents cannot redo missed opportunities to support children later.

    “There's no do-overs. Now's the time.”

    Listen at 41:59

  13. Megyn Kellyon Resentment and forgivenessNegative47:34

    Resentment and refusing to forgive harm the person holding them.

    “Resentment is a poison you give to yourself, and not forgiving hurts you more than it hurts the person who hurt you.”

    Listen at 47:34

  14. Reducing the charges could allow Lindsay Clancy to face a judge instead of a jury.

    “A voluntary manslaughter, a second-degree murder would allow her to go in front of a judge instead of a jury.”

    Listen at 49:11

  15. Megyn Kellyon Parental supervision after harm threatsNegative49:46

    A spouse expressing thoughts of harming children should not be left alone with them.

    “if your spouse. is in a depressive state and says anything about having thoughts of hurting your children, it is a hard no before that spouse can spend any alone time with them.”

    Listen at 49:46

  16. Stu Bergieron Conspiracy theoristsNegative55:14

    People committed to conspiracy theories generally do not admit they were wrong.

    “there's never going to be a person who comes out. I was wrong.”

    Listen at 55:14

  17. Megyn Kellyon 60 MinutesNegative56:08

    A 60 Minutes interview will not change deeply conspiratorial beliefs.

    “A 60 minutes interview is never going to do it.”

    Listen at 56:08

  18. Stu Bergieron Parental access after harm threatsNegative1:01:05

    A parent who admits harming thoughts should not have unsupervised access to children for years.

    “If that happens, there's absolutely not a second that goes by that she's with those kids. You can't. at least for years and years and years and years to the point that maybe to the point where they could defend themselves, right? Maybe they're adults before that even happens.”

    Listen at 1:01:05

  19. Megyn Kellyon Parental duty to protect childrenPositive1:02:22

    A parent must protect children when the other parent poses danger.

    “when the danger is the other parent, it is your obligation to step in and protect them.”

    Listen at 1:02:22

  20. Megyn Kellyon Defense investigation of holdout jurorNegative1:06:19

    The defense’s investigation is intended to intimidate future jurors against dissenting.

    “it's meant to harass him and to make sure the next jury, should there be one, understands you vote not guilty by reason of mental defect or you'll get the same as the holdout juror.”

    Listen at 1:06:19

  21. Stu Bergieron Lindsay ClancyNegative1:07:38

    A person capable of strangling three children cannot safely remain in free society.

    “The person that is capable of strangling their three kids with exercise bands can't be in the same free society as them.”

    Listen at 1:07:38

  22. Megyn Kellyon Holdout juror harassmentNegative1:08:48

    Allowing harassment of holdout jurors will have serious consequences.

    “They will rue the day they allowed this kind of harassment of a holdout juror”

    Listen at 1:08:48

  23. Stu Bergieron Race-based judgmentNegative1:10:35

    People should not be judged based on skin color.

    “this is why you don't. You shouldn't be judging people based on their skin color in the first place.”

    Listen at 1:10:35

  24. Megyn Kellyon Gayle KingNegative1:11:26

    Megyn Kelly characterizes Gayle King’s reaction as racist.

    “She's a racist. I mean, that's what that is.”

    Listen at 1:11:26

  25. Nicole Hannah-Jones prioritized ideology and social credibility over her daughter’s welfare.

    “she was as a parent trying to put her own sort of ideology and honestly, like, credibility at, you know, various cocktail parties. ahead of her children's, her own child's welfare”

    Listen at 1:24:55

  26. Nicole Hannah-Jones genuinely followed the school ideology she publicly defended for a time.

    “she at least believed it for a time. I mean, at least she was authentic at some level and said, OK, I'm going to send my kids to these schools that I'm defending.”

    Listen at 1:25:27

  27. Stu Bergieron Nicole Hannah-Jones essayNegative1:29:19

    Nicole Hannah-Jones’s essay appears intended to preempt unfavorable reporting.

    “She's getting ahead of the news is what she seems to be doing here.”

    Listen at 1:29:19

  28. Nicole Hannah-Jones’s school decision harmed her daughter’s development and family.

    “She's hurt her own family. She's hurt her daughter's development.”

    Listen at 1:31:38

  29. Stu Bergieron Stu Burguiere’s children’s schoolingPositive1:31:53

    Stu Burguiere works to pay tuition for his children’s school.

    “One of the reasons I show up to work every day, Megan, is to pay for school tuition for my children who go to what I think is a really good school.”

    Listen at 1:31:53

  30. Stu Bergieron School-choice programsPositive1:32:11

    School-choice programs are making preferred schooling accessible to more people.

    “I'm glad there's school choice programs that are making it accessible for many more people today.”

    Listen at 1:32:11

  31. Nicole Hannah-Jones is publicly trying to ease her daughter’s admission to an elite university.

    “I guarantee you, Nicole Hannah-Jones is trying to very publicly grease the path into whatever vaunted university she wants her daughter to go to”

    Listen at 1:33:20

  32. Most U.S. universities will admit Nicole Hannah-Jones’s daughter regardless of academic qualifications.

    “98% of universities around the country. She will get into any school that she wants.”

    Listen at 1:34:46

  33. Nicole Hannah-Jones’s daughter will be admitted to any university she chooses.

    “She will get into any school that she wants.”

    Listen at 1:34:49

  34. The daughter might reject her mother’s politics and attend Liberty University.

    “The only justice that could possibly emerge from this is if the daughter registers Republican, declares herself a conservative. and says she wants to go to Liberty University.”

    Listen at 1:36:08

  35. Stu Bergieron Parental monitoring of schoolworkNeutral1:38:31

    A normal parent would notice if a child’s supposedly strong subject answers were all wrong.

    “any normal i think parent right any normal parent would notice when their kid thought they were proficient and it was their best topic and in reality all of the questions were wrong”

    Listen at 1:38:31

Statements are attributed to the speaker as said on the episode and reflect their view at the time, not PodLume's. They are not advice.

Weekly email

State of the Pod, every Monday

The week's most-discussed names and stories from podcasts, with the moments behind them. Free, five minutes, unsubscribe in one click.

Listen to the full episode and explore every guest, topic, and moment on PodLume.

A grief-stricken case tests forgiveness, evidence, and parental responsibility · PodLume