Politics Politics Politics
Politics Politics Politics

Oct 20, 2026 · 1h 38m

Listen from 1:12:36

Listen at 1:12:36

Aggressive midterm ads expose libertarian fault lines and JFK’s hidden life

WILD Midterm Ads! Libertarian Votes and the Mistresses of JFK (with Andrew Heaton and Laurence Leamer)

The episode connects volatile 2026 campaign politics with a reassessment of how personal scandal, illness, and myth shaped Kennedy’s legacy.

3 key takeaways
  1. 1Early-voting signals and aggressive Ohio and Texas ads offer little certainty about the 2026 midterms.
  2. 2Libertarian voters remain divided over Trump, immigration, foreign policy, and whether opposing Democrats is enough to drive turnout.
  3. 3Laurence Leamer argues Kennedy’s affairs, health problems, and risky relationships belong at the center of his historical record.

Don't miss

Laurence Leamer argues that Kennedy’s mistresses and their experiences must be restored to biographies long shaped by the Camelot myth.

The brief

Justin opens with aggressive Ohio and Texas campaign ads, warning that early-voting numbers can mislead and that midterm narratives are forming before votes are counted.

Andrew Heaton and Justin debate whether libertarian-leaning voters will support Trump, Democrats, third parties, or abstention as immigration and foreign policy split the movement.

Their midterm forecast turns on a basic question: can Trump retain libertarian support when many voters oppose Democrats but reject his foreign-policy priorities?

Laurence Leamer argues that John F. Kennedy’s affairs, chronic health problems, amphetamine use, and links to risky political circles are essential—not incidental—to his biography.

The interview’s sharpest challenge to Camelot is its insistence that the women involved, and their accounts of Kennedy, should not disappear behind presidential mythology.

What was said on this episode

50 statements · 14 positive · 23 negative · 3 mixed · 10 neutral

  1. James Tallarico dominates Texas Senate billboard advertising.

    “James Tallarico is dominating the billboard game.”

    Listen at 4:54

  2. Justin Youngon Ken Paxton campaignNegative8:44

    Ken Paxton is running a bad campaign and deserves to lose the Texas Senate race.

    “I have now officially come to the opinion that he is running a bad campaign and he deserves to lose this race.”

    Listen at 8:44

  3. Justin Youngon Ken Paxton campaignNegative8:50

    Ken Paxton is running a bad campaign and deserves defeat.

    “he is running a bad campaign and he deserves to lose this race.”

    Listen at 8:50

  4. Justin Youngon Ken PaxtonPositive8:59

    Ken Paxton will probably win despite running a bad campaign.

    “I still don't think he will.”

    Listen at 8:59

  5. Justin Youngon Ken PaxtonPositive9:03

    Ken Paxton will narrowly win the Texas Senate race.

    “I still believe that he will eke it out”

    Listen at 9:03

  6. Justin Youngon early voting trendsNegative9:50

    Early voting trends do not reliably predict final election results.

    “They do not reliably predict final results.”

    Listen at 9:50

  7. Justin Youngon Democratic early voting figuresPositive12:35

    Early voting figures are favorable signs for Democrats.

    “These are very good signs for Democrats”

    Listen at 12:35

  8. Justin Youngon early voting turnoutMixed12:53

    High early voting may reflect enthusiastic voters voting early.

    “did all of your most enthusiastic voters go out and vote on it?”

    Listen at 12:53

  9. Andrew Heatonon 2024 libertarian presidential votePositive24:11

    Among two-party libertarian voters, Trump likely led Harris 80–20 in 2024.

    “I'd put it at like probably 80-20 Trump versus Harris.”

    Listen at 24:11

  10. Andrew Heatonon Libertarian-leaning votersPositive24:11

    Libertarian-leaning voters choosing major parties favored Trump over Harris roughly 80–20.

    “I'd put it at like probably 80-20 Trump versus Harris.”

    Listen at 24:11

  11. Andrew Heatonon 2024 libertarian presidential voteNeutral25:27

    Heaton estimates Harris received 10% and Trump 30% of libertarian universe votes.

    “Kamala Harris gets maybe 10% and Trump gets 30%”

    Listen at 25:27

  12. Andrew Heatonon 2024 libertarian-leaning votersNeutral25:27

    In 2024, libertarian-leaning voters gave Harris about 10% and Trump 30%.

    “Kamala Harris gets maybe 10% and Trump gets 30%”

    Listen at 25:27

  13. Andrew Heatonon 2024 libertarian presidential voteNeutral25:50

    Heaton estimates abstention or third-party choices received 60% of libertarian votes.

    “That gets 60 percent.”

    Listen at 25:50

  14. Andrew Heatonon 2024 libertarian-leaning votersNeutral25:50

    About 60% of libertarian-leaning voters chose nonmajor-party or nonvoting options in 2024.

    “That gets 60 percent.”

    Listen at 25:50

  15. Andrew Heatonon Trump-Harris 2024 contrastNeutral27:00

    Trump and Harris presented clearly distinguishable political differences in 2024.

    “Trump and Kamala Harris, I think, did have very clearly delineated differences between them”

    Listen at 27:00

  16. Andrew Heatonon Libertarian movement divisionsNeutral27:59

    Libertarian divisions increasingly separate libertarians from anti-left participants.

    “The fault lines in the libertarians, insofar as I see them, are now more of libertarian versus anti-left.”

    Listen at 27:59

  17. Andrew Heatonon Libertarian political divisionsNeutral28:19

    Libertarian divisions increasingly center on anti-left sentiment rather than anarchism versus minarchism.

    “What I saw more of was libertarians and people that just fucking hate Democrats.”

    Listen at 28:19

  18. Immigration has become a major dividing line within the Libertarian Party.

    “the new fault line in the Libertarian Party is the same fault line we're seeing everywhere”

    Listen at 30:24

  19. Immigration has become a major fault line within the Libertarian Party.

    “the new fault line in the Libertarian Party is the same fault line we're seeing everywhere, but it goes right down the LP.”

    Listen at 30:24

  20. “Trump is an asshole and he says mean things, but he's not killing anybody.”

    Listen at 32:45

  21. Trump’s supporters viewed him as preferable because he supposedly avoided killing people.

    “Trump is an asshole and he says mean things, but he's not killing anybody.”

    Listen at 32:45

  22. Andrew Heatonon Ron Paul and Mike GravelPositive34:56

    Ron Paul and Mike Gravel helped drive libertarian opposition to interventionist American foreign policy.

    “The libertarians really had a big push with Mike Gravel and particularly with Ron Paul”

    Listen at 34:56

  23. Andrew Heatonon Libertarian foreign policyNegative35:23

    The libertarian foreign-policy position favors leaving multilateral treaties and the Middle East.

    “we should get out of multilateral treaties, we should get out of the Middle East”

    Listen at 35:23

  24. Andrew Heatonon Donald Trump support among libertariansNegative37:20

    Trump’s immigration and foreign-policy positions would dissuade some libertarians from supporting him.

    “Both of those, I think, are things that would dissuade a libertarian from supporting Trump.”

    Listen at 37:20

  25. Andrew Heatonon Donald Trump support among foreign-policy libertariansNegative38:11

    Principled foreign-policy libertarians have likely lost faith in Trump.

    “they've almost certainly lost whatever faith they had in Donald Trump.”

    Listen at 38:11

  26. Andrew Heatonon Trump administration Middle East warNegative38:30

    The Trump administration entered another Middle Eastern war.

    “we got into another war in the Middle East.”

    Listen at 38:30

  27. Andrew Heatonon Trump administration Middle East warNegative38:30

    The Trump administration entered another Middle East war.

    “we got into another war in the Middle East.”

    Listen at 38:30

  28. Andrew Heatonon U.S. federal spendingNegative43:32

    The United States has an excessive federal spending problem.

    “the big problem right now is we have a runaway spending problem.”

    Listen at 43:32

  29. Andrew Heatonon U.S. federal spendingNegative43:32

    The United States has an excessive federal spending problem.

    “the big problem right now is we have a runaway spending problem.”

    Listen at 43:32

  30. Andrew Heatonon U.S. entitlement programsNegative43:38

    Addressing federal spending requires changes to major entitlement programs.

    “You're going to have to go over Medicaid, Medicare, Social Security”

    Listen at 43:38

  31. DOGE efforts did not substantially restrain government spending.

    “I don't see a lot of evidence that they were actually doing things to restrain the government fiscally.”

    Listen at 44:06

  32. Andrew Heatonon DOGE-related government reformsNegative44:06

    DOGE-related actions did not provide much evidence of fiscal restraint.

    “I don't see a lot of evidence that they were actually doing things to restrain the government fiscally.”

    Listen at 44:06

  33. Andrew Heatonon Trump support among foreign-policy libertariansNegative47:43

    Trump will lose principled foreign-policy libertarian support.

    “You're definitely going to lose any principled foreign policy people.”

    Listen at 47:43

  34. Andrew Heatonon Trump support among principled libertariansNegative47:58

    Principled libertarians focused on foreign policy will abandon Trump.

    “I think Trump's out. I think they're going to be gone.”

    Listen at 47:58

  35. Andrew Heatonon Libertarian midterm turnoutNegative48:13

    Many libertarians will abstain from voting in the midterms.

    “I think there's going to be a significant amount of libertarians that are going to opt for apathy.”

    Listen at 48:13

  36. Andrew Heatonon Libertarian midterm turnoutNegative48:13

    Many libertarians will abstain from voting in the midterms.

    “I think there's going to be a significant amount of libertarians that are going to opt for apathy.”

    Listen at 48:13

  37. Andrew Heatonon 2026 Democratic House outcomePositive52:22

    Democrats will narrowly win the House in the 2026 midterms.

    “I think it'll be win in name only. I think it's going to be a squeaker.”

    Listen at 52:22

  38. Andrew Heatonon 2026 midterm Senate outcomePositive52:55

    Democrats may win the Senate by one or two seats.

    “I think the Democrats might take it, but by one or two.”

    Listen at 52:55

  39. Andrew Heatonon 2026 Democratic Senate outcomePositive52:55

    Democrats may win the Senate by one or two seats.

    “I think the Democrats might take it, but by one or two.”

    Listen at 52:55

  40. Justin Youngon high diesel pricesNegative1:02:41

    High diesel prices are a particularly powerful inflationary driver.

    “I don't believe that anything is an inflationary driver like high diesel prices.”

    Listen at 1:02:41

  41. Justin Youngon Michelle TafoyaPositive1:05:42

    Michelle Tafoya is outperforming Peggy Flanagan in campaign appearances.

    “Michelle Tafoya is able to put it on her.”

    Listen at 1:05:42

  42. Justin Youngon Michelle TafoyaNegative1:05:57

    Michelle Tafoya will probably lose Minnesota by six to seven points.

    “she's probably going to lose by six to seven”

    Listen at 1:05:57

  43. Laurence Leameron John F. Kennedy’s healthNegative1:10:17

    John F. Kennedy’s health was a central hidden aspect of his life.

    “the deep secret of his life was his health.”

    Listen at 1:10:17

  44. JFK used sexual activity to project or reassure himself of health.

    “Sex was his way of exerting his health, of false health”

    Listen at 1:10:26

  45. Laurence Leameron John KennedyNegative1:12:36

    JFK used amphetamines extensively, including injections.

    “he was the king of amphetamines. He was shooting up.”

    Listen at 1:12:36

  46. Laurence Leameron John KennedyPositive1:16:28

    JFK was an exceptionally skilled politician.

    “JFK was a brilliant politician.”

    Listen at 1:16:28

  47. Laurence Leameron JFK reelection campaignNegative1:25:30

    Republicans would have publicized JFK’s affairs during a reelection campaign.

    “I think if he had lived and he run for re-election, I think the Republicans would have brought a lot of this stuff out.”

    Listen at 1:25:30

  48. Laurence Leameron JFK health and infidelity revelationsNegative1:26:10

    Revelations about JFK’s health and infidelity would have damaged him politically.

    “I think the two things together. Yeah, that would have damaged.”

    Listen at 1:26:10

  49. Laurence Leameron John KennedyPositive1:30:36

    Kennedy’s sexual relationships should be included in historical accounts of his life.

    “I think this is part of his life. And I think we're grown up as Americans these days to be able to see that.”

    Listen at 1:30:36

  50. Justin Youngon U.S. military action against IranMixed1:34:31

    Attacking Iran may not be viewed negatively by those seeing it as a regional source of conflict.

    “going after that country specifically. is not going to be looked at particularly negatively.”

    Listen at 1:34:31

Statements are attributed to the speaker as said on the episode and reflect their view at the time, not PodLume's. They are not advice.

Books & mentions

Some links are affiliate links — PodLume may earn a commission if you buy.

Weekly email

State of the Pod, every Monday

The week's most-discussed names and stories from podcasts, with the moments behind them. Free, five minutes, unsubscribe in one click.

Listen to the full episode and explore every guest, topic, and moment on PodLume.