The Bulwark Daily
The Bulwark Daily

Sep 29, 2026 · 1h 17m

Authoritarian power faces pressure in Washington and Moscow

Amanda Carpenter and Evan Gershkovich: Trump's and Putin's Authoritarian Projects

The episode connects threats to democratic accountability in the United States with the personal and political costs of repression in Russia.

3 key takeaways
  1. 1Trump’s election claims and executive-power theories remain dangerous even as parts of his governing machinery falter.
  2. 2Evan Gershkovich describes how Russia fabricated his espionage case and used his imprisonment as a bargaining instrument.
  3. 3Both conversations reject complacency about authoritarianism, whether it appears through state repression or democratic personality cults.

Don't miss

Gershkovich describes the calculated conditions of his 500-day imprisonment and the guilt of knowing he was more likely to be exchanged than many fellow prisoners.

The brief

Tim Miller and Amanda Carpenter argue that Trump’s election-fraud campaign and executive-power ambitions remain dangerous, even as weak databases, departures, and political failures expose limits in the administration’s machinery.

Their discussion turns to congressional oversight, appropriations, alleged corruption, and impeachment, asking whether lawmakers can constrain executive power when officials obstruct investigations and refuse accountability.

Evan Gershkovich recounts his arrest in Russia, a fabricated espionage case, and 500 days in Lefortovo prison, where authorities maintained legal theater while treating him as a bargaining chip.

After release, Gershkovich describes the difficulty of recovering ordinary life and processing trauma, while explaining how repression has narrowed the space for Western journalism in Russia.

The episode closes by resisting easy theories about Russia or its people, linking Putin’s authoritarianism to the broader danger of political loyalty, charisma, and democratic complacency.

What was said on this episode

59 statements · 13 positive · 42 negative · 1 mixed · 3 neutral

  1. Amanda Carpenteron MAGANegative3:25

    Visible MAGA enthusiasm appears weak in Carpenter’s local observations.

    “the signs have not been out. It is very low-key.”

    Listen at 3:25

  2. Amanda Carpenteron Trump-aligned election-subversion effortsNegative5:39

    Trump-aligned election-subversion efforts have not worked so far.

    “None of that has worked so far.”

    Listen at 5:39

  3. The SAVE database mandate has largely failed.

    “The SAVE database that they've tried to get everyone to use on a mandatory basis has largely flopped”

    Listen at 5:44

  4. Amanda Carpenteron Naturalized citizensNegative5:57

    Naturalized citizens face the greatest risk of false election-registration flags.

    “the people most at risk for being flagged on this falsely are naturalized citizens”

    Listen at 5:57

  5. Amanda Carpenteron Naturalized citizensPositive6:05

    Naturalized citizens planning to vote should check their registration immediately.

    “please check your registration now”

    Listen at 6:05

  6. Amanda Carpenteron Trump-aligned election liesNegative7:23

    Trump-aligned election lies are failing to establish election-control processes.

    “the big lies that they have tried to push as pretext to set up these processes are not working”

    Listen at 7:23

  7. Amanda Carpenteron Access to the ballot boxPositive7:37

    The current path to voting remains clear despite election-subversion efforts.

    “right now that path to the ballot box is clear”

    Listen at 7:37

  8. Amanda Carpenteron Trump-aligned election-subversion plansNegative7:52

    Trump-aligned election-subversion plans are failing spectacularly.

    “their plans are failing spectacularly”

    Listen at 7:52

  9. The administration’s election-related plans are failing spectacularly.

    “their plans are failing spectacularly.”

    Listen at 7:52

  10. Amanda Carpenteron Trump-aligned officialsNegative9:21

    Trump-aligned officials still seek pretexts to potentially seize voting machines.

    “they very much want this pretext so that they can go raid voting machines potentially”

    Listen at 9:21

  11. Amanda Carpenteron Trump-aligned election claimsNegative9:31

    Trump-aligned election claims currently lack their 2020 level of public momentum.

    “they don't have the momentum and the buy-in from the public for that fever pitch that we saw in like 2020”

    Listen at 9:31

  12. Tim Milleron Trump-aligned election operationsNegative10:51

    Trump-aligned actors lack personnel to execute their desired election operations at scale.

    “they don't really have the people to execute the scale of what they would like to do with the election”

    Listen at 10:51

  13. Trump’s 2025 project is failing broadly.

    “the whole Trump 2025 project is going down the tubes.”

    Listen at 11:53

  14. The Trump 2025 project is failing broadly.

    “the whole Trump 2025 project is going down the tubes”

    Listen at 11:53

  15. Amanda Carpenteron Trump weaponization projectNegative12:25

    Trump’s weaponization project lacks a prosecutable case and has produced no prosecutions.

    “They have no case. They have left without prosecuting anyone.”

    Listen at 12:25

  16. Amanda Carpenteron Trump campaign of retributionNegative12:36

    Trump’s promised campaign of political retribution has not materialized.

    “this big campaign of retribution that they said was going to rain down on anyone who ever criticized Trump or pointed out his illegality, it's just not come true”

    Listen at 12:36

  17. Amanda Carpenteron Trump presidencyNegative12:55

    If polling holds, Trump’s presidency should be branded the worst ever.

    “if the midterms go the way that the polling indicates, I think we really need to start branding this presidency as the worst one we've ever seen”

    Listen at 12:55

  18. Amanda Carpenteron Trump presidencyNegative13:00

    Trump’s presidency should be branded as the worst ever seen.

    “I think we really need to start branding this presidency as the worst one we've ever seen”

    Listen at 13:00

  19. The Trump administration is failing across its stated policy standards.

    “I am trying to generously think of one thing that they are succeeding at”

    Listen at 14:54

  20. Amanda Carpenteron Trump-connected defense and technology projectsPositive16:55

    Trump-connected investors stand to profit substantially from Pentagon-backed loans.

    “they stand to make a lot of money because the Pentagon budget is gone and big on the loans”

    Listen at 16:55

  21. Amanda Carpenteron Government-backed defense and technology projectsNegative17:08

    The government-backed projects constitute a scam.

    “it's a scam”

    Listen at 17:08

  22. Amanda Carpenteron Government-financed projectsNegative17:08

    The government-financed projects are a scam.

    “it's a scam.”

    Listen at 17:08

  23. Amanda Carpenteron Trump ballroom projectNegative17:43

    Diverting public funds to Trump’s ballroom is illegal spending.

    “this is illegal spending”

    Listen at 17:43

  24. Amanda Carpenteron Trump White House ballroom spendingNegative17:43

    Trump’s ballroom spending is illegal.

    “this is illegal spending.”

    Listen at 17:43

  25. Amanda Carpenteron Congressional spending powerPositive17:52

    Congress must protect its constitutional spending power.

    “Congress does not protect its spending power”

    Listen at 17:52

  26. Clark Construction is illegally working on property Trump does not own.

    “they're doing illegal work on property that Trump does not own.”

    Listen at 18:37

  27. Amanda Carpenteron Trump ballroom projectPositive19:06

    Congress and investigators can identify and hold ballroom-project wrongdoers accountable.

    “I don't have any doubt that we're capable of finding out what happened and who is responsible and holding them accountable for it”

    Listen at 19:06

  28. Amanda Carpenteron Russ Vought’s OMB rescission theoryNegative20:42

    Russ Vought cannot override Congress and redirect appropriated funds at will.

    “once it goes to OMB, he thinks that he can override Congress and redirect the money however he would like to do it. That is not true.”

    Listen at 20:42

  29. Russ Vought cannot override Congress and redirect appropriated funds at will.

    “he thinks that he can override Congress and redirect the money however he would like to do it. That is not true.”

    Listen at 20:43

  30. Amanda Carpenteron Trump ballroom projectNegative21:53

    The ballroom project has a fire hazard serious enough to prompt the architect’s resignation.

    “the architect quit because of health and safety standards because there is a fire hazard”

    Listen at 21:53

  31. Amanda Carpenteron Future Democratic Congress oversightPositive24:10

    A future Democratic Congress should investigate diverted funds and identify those responsible.

    “you have to investigate like you do have to do the fact finding exercise of finding where the stolen money is, who is responsible for taking it”

    Listen at 24:10

  32. Amanda Carpenteron Congressional appropriations ridersPositive24:30

    Congress should use appropriations riders to block unauthorized spending.

    “You can start to pass things called riders on appropriations bills”

    Listen at 24:30

  33. Amanda Carpenteron Presidential anti-corruption reformPositive24:48

    Congress should pursue anti-corruption reforms limiting presidential misconduct.

    “we also have to start thinking about like what kind of anti-corruption reform package could be passed one day so that a president can't get away with this again”

    Listen at 24:48

  34. Amanda Carpenteron Congressional spending powerPositive25:08

    Congress should litigate to defend its constitutional spending authority.

    “Congress does have to go to court to defend its spending power”

    Listen at 25:08

  35. Amanda Carpenteron Congressional investigationsNeutral26:44

    Congressional investigations will remain extensive for two to four years.

    “I think it's going to keep Congress busy for the next 2 to 4 years”

    Listen at 26:44

  36. Evan Gershkovichon Russia’s treatment of perceived opponentsNegative31:27

    Russia classifies perceived opponents as traitors, enemies, or opponents.

    “one thing that I think, uh, I do get right is their approach to, uh, the way they class people as either traitors or, let's say, enemies or opponents”

    Listen at 31:27

  37. Evan Gershkovichon Russian wartime censorship lawsNegative35:52

    Russia enacted highly restrictive wartime censorship laws after invading Ukraine.

    “it passed these really draconian censorship laws”

    Listen at 35:52

  38. Evan Gershkovichon Russian censorship lawsNegative35:52

    Russia passed highly restrictive censorship laws after invading Ukraine.

    “it passed these really draconian censorship laws.”

    Listen at 35:52

  39. Evan Gershkovichon FSBNegative39:22

    The FSB fulfills Putin’s orders to domestic intelligence services.

    “when Putin gives an order to his domestic intelligence service, the FSB, they fulfill that request”

    Listen at 39:22

  40. Putin genuinely believed the narrative that Gershkovich was a spy.

    “Whether he believes I'm a spy is not an open question because I think he truly believed the narrative.”

    Listen at 40:37

  41. Evan Gershkovichon Western journalists in RussiaNegative44:42

    Western journalists remaining in Russia are increasingly self-censoring.

    “The people that are there are, you know, putting more handbrakes on. They're sort of censoring what they can do.”

    Listen at 44:42

  42. Evan Gershkovichon Journalists reporting in RussiaNegative45:25

    Journalists reporting in Russia should exercise heightened caution.

    “the environment's obviously changing. And so I would, you know, advise just being careful.”

    Listen at 45:25

  43. Evan Gershkovichon Russian courtsNegative52:18

    Russian courts convict approximately 99% of defendants.

    “only 99% of people are guilty”

    Listen at 52:18

  44. Evan Gershkovichon Russian antiwar protesterNegative53:00

    A Russian man received a 17-year sentence for writing four antiwar words.

    “one guy I met wrote 4 words on a wall protesting the war, like in spray paint, and he got arrested and sentenced to 17 years”

    Listen at 53:00

  45. Evan Gershkovichon Authoritarian regimesMixed1:01:39

    Authoritarian regimes can appear permanent before suddenly changing or collapsing.

    “often everything seems like forever until it's not”

    Listen at 1:01:39

  46. Evan Gershkovichon Putin’s rule and Russian repressionNegative1:02:27

    Putin’s continued rule sustains Russia’s repression.

    “while he's alive and in power, the, the, the logic of continued repression is in place”

    Listen at 1:02:27

  47. Evan Gershkovichon Putin’s RussiaNegative1:02:41

    Russian authoritarian paranoia deepens over time under Putin.

    “the paranoia deepens with time.”

    Listen at 1:02:41

  48. Evan Gershkovichon Russia’s authoritarian systemNegative1:02:41

    Russia’s authoritarian paranoia intensifies over time under Putin.

    “the paranoia deepens with time”

    Listen at 1:02:41

  49. Evan Gershkovichon Russia’s political liberalizationPositive1:04:08

    Russia could eventually reopen politically and pursue liberal reforms.

    “I don't think it's impossible”

    Listen at 1:04:08

  50. Evan Gershkovichon Russia’s political futurePositive1:04:08

    Russia could eventually reopen politically after Putin.

    “I don't think it's impossible.”

    Listen at 1:04:08

  51. Trump’s orbit is likely a counterintelligence nightmare for U.S. authorities.

    “I assume as much as you do that it's a counterintelligence nightmare.”

    Listen at 1:05:05

  52. Evan Gershkovichon Russian contacts in Trump’s orbitNegative1:05:51

    Russian contacts in Trump’s orbit create a counterintelligence nightmare.

    “it must be a counterintelligence nightmare”

    Listen at 1:05:51

  53. Evan Gershkovichon Russian one-off agentsNegative1:06:48

    Russian actors increasingly pay online one-off agents to conduct operations.

    “they're paying on, on the internet for people, yeah, to do a job. And these are called sort of like one-off agents.”

    Listen at 1:06:48

  54. Evan Gershkovichon Russia-West shadow spy warsNegative1:07:05

    Shadow spy wars between Russia and the West are increasing.

    “these kind of shadow spy wars really increase.”

    Listen at 1:07:05

  55. Evan Gershkovichon Russian cultural rotNegative1:10:48

    Russian cultural rot contributes to authoritarian outcomes, though its scope is uncertain.

    “I just think it's a really complicated question. I think you're right that there is cultural rot at play, but how far does it go back?”

    Listen at 1:10:48

  56. Evan Gershkovichon RussiansNeutral1:13:09

    Ordinary Russians should not be treated as inherently different or predisposed to autocracy.

    “The Russian soul is not different than any other. People are people. You can't essentialize them.”

    Listen at 1:13:09

  57. Evan Gershkovichon RussiansNeutral1:13:11

    Russian people should not be treated as inherently different or authoritarian.

    “People are people. You can't essentialize them.”

    Listen at 1:13:11

  58. Evan Gershkovichon Russia’s authoritarian traditionPositive1:13:25

    Russia’s authoritarian tradition is deep but can change.

    “Russia's is much longer. It's much deeper. Again, maybe it's cultural rot, but it can change, right? It can change in a different way.”

    Listen at 1:13:25

  59. Evan Gershkovichon Russia’s political culturePositive1:13:28

    Russia’s political culture can change despite possible cultural rot.

    “Again, maybe it's cultural rot, but it can change, right? It can change in a different way.”

    Listen at 1:13:28

Statements are attributed to the speaker as said on the episode and reflect their view at the time, not PodLume's. They are not advice.

Books & mentions

Weekly email

State of the Pod, every Monday

The week's most-discussed names and stories from podcasts, with the moments behind them. Free, five minutes, unsubscribe in one click.

Listen to the full episode and explore every guest, topic, and moment on PodLume.