
Nov 16, 2026 · 26 min
Listen from 21:22
Listen at 21:22
Carlin tests six stocks against value-investing discipline
S&P 500 (459 to 440) - 6 Extremely Interesting Investing Stories (PNW, SOLV, GNRC, ECHO, GEN, IVZ)
The review shows how debt, cyclical timing, financial engineering, and speculative narratives can distort apparent bargains.
- 1Utilities and infrastructure can benefit from growth, but valuation and capital requirements determine whether the timing works.
- 2Spinoffs and acquisitions may reveal value or conceal debt, weak businesses, and management incentives that undermine shareholders.
- 3EchoStar offers the episode’s most unusual upside case through SpaceX exposure, but its declining core business makes the thesis highly risky.
Don't miss
Carlin’s EchoStar analysis turns on whether its SpaceX stake can outweigh a weak legacy business and justify the company’s apparent discount.
The brief
Sven Carlin opens with six investment stories spanning utilities, spinoffs, AI infrastructure, and EchoStar’s indirect SpaceX exposure, then tests each against valuation discipline.
Pinnacle West and Generac show two sides of infrastructure investing: utilities may reward patience at cyclical lows, while backup-power demand could benefit from data-center expansion.
Solventum looks cheap after its 3M spinoff, but restructuring, litigation, and possible debt-shedding raise the question of whether a low multiple reflects value or complications.
EchoStar is the episode’s sharpest valuation puzzle: wireless spectrum and roughly 2% of SpaceX offer upside, yet declining legacy operations and skepticism about SpaceX keep the thesis risky.
The remaining names reinforce the broader lesson: buybacks, acquisitions, passive flows, and spinoffs can obscure weak economics, while attractive prices often appear when businesses look unattractive.
What was said on this episode
28 statements · 13 positive · 10 negative · 5 neutral
Pinnacle West growth is projected at 5–6% annually through 2030.
“The company's growth is projected to hit 5-6% per year up to 2030.”
Listen at 1:37
Pinnacle West plans approximately $10 billion of investment over four years.
“10 billion invested over four years is not a small amount”
Listen at 1:56
A cyclical downturn could reduce Pinnacle West stock 40% and raise its yield to 5–6%.
“This stock is 40% down. The dividend yield goes to 5-6%”
Listen at 3:54
Utilities such as Pinnacle West are better purchased at cyclical lows.
“it's better to buy at cycle lows”
Listen at 4:20
Solventum appears inexpensive at a price-to-earnings ratio of 11.
“The PE is at 11, thus it seems cheap.”
Listen at 5:12
Solventum is considering spinning out its health information systems business.
“they have another idea to spin out the health information systems”
Listen at 5:55
Generac has a $1.6 billion backlog and 30% industrial-segment growth expectations.
“their backlog is already 1.6 billion. That led to 30% growth expectations for their industrial segment.”
Listen at 8:49
Generac has data-center contracts, potentially including $8 billion from Amazon over several years.
“we already have contracts with Amazon and another hyperscaler that might go for Amazon just 8 billion over the years”
Listen at 9:17
Generac earnings per share could exceed analysts’ 2028 expectation of 16.
“earnings per share can go even higher than the expected 16 from the analyst by 2028.”
Listen at 9:53
Generac could rise at least 50% from current levels under the stated assumptions.
“that's 50% up or more from the current levels.”
Listen at 10:04
Generac may still be an attractive time to buy.
“this might still be a good time.”
Listen at 10:32
EchoStar owns approximately 2% of SpaceX.
“They just own 2% of SpaceX”
Listen at 11:50
Sven predicts SpaceX will eventually be worth zero.
“SpaceX will be worth zero down the road.”
Listen at 13:08
EchoStar offers cheaper indirect SpaceX exposure for investors who believe in SpaceX.
“if you believe in SpaceX, you can get it much cheaper here.”
Listen at 13:24
Gen Digital trades at 14 times earnings and yields a 2% dividend.
“The P ratio is 14, the dividend is just 2%.”
Listen at 13:41
Gen Digital is pursuing GoDaddy and other acquisitions that Sven considers excessive.
“they go out and try to buy GoDaddy, make crazy acquisitions”
Listen at 14:05
Invesco deserves a price-to-earnings ratio of 30 if markets continue rising.
“Therefore, it deserves a P ratio of 30.”
Listen at 17:13
If the market bubble bursts, Invesco could decline 50–70%.
“If the bubble bursts, yes, Invesco will go down 50, 70%”
Listen at 17:17
Textron is too risky and cyclical for Sven’s investment criteria.
“For me, it's simply too risky, too cyclical.”
Listen at 18:40
JM Smucker offers little upside and carries meaningful risks.
“I don't see the upside. I see risks.”
Listen at 19:26
Allegiant is a fairly priced compounder.
“Allegiant. Fairly priced compounder”
Listen at 19:49
Allegiant would become interesting around a 15-times earnings multiple.
“Perhaps P-Ratio of 22 should be at 15 for making it interesting”
Listen at 20:27
GoDaddy’s legacy products are declining, churn is 85%, and AI competition is difficult.
“the legacy products are declining 85% churn rate is pretty high in my opinion ai is hard to compete with the hyperscalers”
Listen at 21:22
Avery Dennison needs returns above 10% to qualify as a value investment.
“Should be above 10% for these to be value investments.”
Listen at 22:19
FedEx Freight raised $4 billion in debt during its spinoff.
“They raised $4 billion in debt”
Listen at 22:55
The discussed REITs have occupancy below 100%.
“the occupancy is not 100%”
Listen at 23:51
Tyler Technologies remains excessively valued at a 50-times earnings ratio.
“when I see a p ratio of 50 which was then 100 just two years ago to me this is still crazy”
Listen at 24:26
EchoStar is the best buy among these names if SpaceX is not fairly valued.
“if you don't think spacex is fairly priced then echo is the best buy here”
Listen at 25:49
Statements are attributed to the speaker as said on the episode and reflect their view at the time, not PodLume's. They are not advice.
Weekly email
State of the Pod, every Monday
The week's most-discussed names and stories from podcasts, with the moments behind them. Free, five minutes, unsubscribe in one click.