Modern Value Investing with Sven Carlin

Listen from 7:19

Listen at 7:19

China’s battered internet stocks test the value-investing case

Unloved Chinese Stocks - Value, Buy for 2X

The episode examines whether deep investor pessimism around Chinese internet companies reflects opportunity or demands more caution.

3 key takeaways
  1. 1The China Internet ETF’s long-term underperformance has made pessimism a central part of the investment case.
  2. 2Unloved Chinese stocks may offer substantial upside, but only investors willing to analyze them carefully and wait patiently.
  3. 3Pinduoduo, Tencent, and Alibaba illustrate the broad Chinese internet landscape under consideration by value investors.

Don't miss

Sven Carlin turns the China Internet ETF’s weak long-term performance into the episode’s key value-investing question: warning sign or opportunity?

The brief

Sven Carlin opens with China investing and a striking question: does the China Internet ETF’s long-term underperformance signal structural risk or neglected value?

The episode treats widespread pessimism as an investment variable, not a conclusion, asking whether unloved Chinese stocks can deliver significant upside from depressed expectations.

Pinduoduo, Tencent, and Alibaba place the discussion in the real Chinese internet market, where company-specific analysis matters more than a broad bullish or bearish label.

The central discipline is patience: potential value in China does not remove the need for careful analysis, a long-term horizon, or tolerance for investor doubt.

What was said on this episode

56 statements · 35 positive · 11 negative · 5 mixed · 5 neutral

  1. Sven Carlinon Tencent, JD.com, and AlibabaPositive0:46

    Tencent, JD.com, and Alibaba are strong global companies.

    “when you look at these companies, the Tencents, the JDs, the Alibabas, those are global companies. Strong companies”

    Listen at 0:46

  2. Sven Carlinon Tencent, JD.com, and AlibabaPositive0:51

    Tencent, JD.com, and Alibaba are strong global companies

    “those are global companies. Strong companies”

    Listen at 0:51

  3. Sven Carlinon Chinese internet stocksPositive1:12

    Leading Chinese internet stocks exhibit value characteristics.

    “low P ratios, high cash flows, profitable, still growing, it screams value”

    Listen at 1:12

  4. Sven Carlinon TencentPositive3:48

    Tencent offers dividends, buybacks, double-digit growth, and a 15 P/E

    “A dividend, buybacks, still growing, double digits, P-ratio 15.”

    Listen at 3:48

  5. Sven Carlinon TencentPositive4:09

    Tencent is currently priced low

    “At that price, now low.”

    Listen at 4:09

  6. Sven Carlinon TencentPositive4:09

    Tencent may be worth buying during market pessimism and selling during exuberant peaks.

    “At that price, now low. perhaps waiting for those peaks that arrive every few years the market gets exuberant that is the time to sell and when the market is in a bad mood that might be the time to buy”

    Listen at 4:09

  7. Alibaba’s AI strategy remains a speculative bet

    “it remains a bet”

    Listen at 5:12

  8. Alibaba’s legacy-business cash flows are declining

    “The cash flows are declining from the legacy businesses”

    Listen at 5:14

  9. Alibaba is currently too expensive for Sven

    “Alibaba, too high now for me”

    Listen at 5:22

  10. Alibaba is currently too expensive for Sven Carlin.

    “Alibaba, too high now for me, given the situation.”

    Listen at 5:22

  11. Sven Carlinon PDDPositive5:44

    PDD Holdings may successfully build its new business

    “They might be able to do it”

    Listen at 5:44

  12. Sven Carlinon PDDPositive5:53

    PDD Holdings is cheaply valued

    “But the company is cheap.”

    Listen at 5:53

  13. Sven Carlinon PDDPositive5:53

    PDD Holdings is cheap, cash-rich, and likely able to build its new business.

    “But the company is cheap. There is a lot of cash. They will likely be able to build it.”

    Listen at 5:53

  14. Sven Carlinon PDDMixed6:03

    PDD Holdings has potentially significant hidden future value if its investments succeed.

    “This might be an interesting solution, but it is more of that hidden potential future value there.”

    Listen at 6:03

  15. Sven Carlinon MeituanNegative6:54

    Meituan’s intense competition lowers margins and causes losses

    “which lowers margins. And that turns into losses.”

    Listen at 6:54

  16. Sven Carlinon MeituanMixed7:19

    Meituan’s profitable growth remains uncertain because of intense competition.

    “Interesting, but there is a big if on the profitable growth.”

    Listen at 7:19

  17. Sven Carlinon MeituanMixed7:20

    Meituan’s profitable growth is highly uncertain

    “there is a big if on the profitable growth”

    Listen at 7:20

  18. Sven Carlinon NetEaseNeutral7:58

    NetEase is fairly valued

    “fairly priced”

    Listen at 7:58

  19. Sven Carlinon LenovoNegative8:49

    Lenovo’s loss resulted from warrants issued to fund AI investment.

    “The loss here is because of the warrants they issued to invest in AI a year and something ago.”

    Listen at 8:49

  20. Sven Carlinon LenovoMixed9:00

    Lenovo’s valuation depends on a Chinese AI bet

    “it is a bet on AI, on Chinese AI”

    Listen at 9:00

  21. Sven Carlinon AI investmentsNegative9:10

    AI investments face competition, so Sven Carlin waits for a downturn before investing.

    “as soon as i see ai i know competition i'm waiting for a downturn not to invest in the exuberant part of it”

    Listen at 9:10

  22. Sven Carlinon AI industryPositive9:12

    Sven recommends waiting for an AI-sector downturn before investing

    “I'm waiting for a downturn not to invest in the exuberant part of it”

    Listen at 9:12

  23. Sven Carlinon BeikeNegative9:49

    Beike lacks sufficient upside at its current valuation.

    “I don't see it with this company.”

    Listen at 9:49

  24. Sven Carlinon JD.comPositive9:52

    JD.com offers buybacks, a 3.7% annual yield, and growing dividends.

    “JDcom buybacks, 3.7% annual yield, growing dividend yield. We discussed this. I own this for the record.”

    Listen at 9:52

  25. Sven Carlinon JD.comPositive10:00

    Sven owns JD.com

    “I own this for the record.”

    Listen at 10:00

  26. Sven Carlinon JD.comPositive10:24

    JD.com sentiment cycles may produce 50–70% gains

    “you can make 50, 70% on that”

    Listen at 10:24

  27. Sven Carlinon JD.comPositive10:45

    JD.com has a basis for future growth through logistics and its competitive moat.

    “So they have something to bank on the growth and the future of the company.”

    Listen at 10:45

  28. Sven Carlinon Trip.comPositive11:25

    Trip.com has a monopoly in online travel

    “It has a monopoly.”

    Listen at 11:25

  29. Sven Carlinon Trip.comPositive11:57

    Trip.com trades at 10 P/E while growing and may offer upside.

    “Therefore, the stock is trading at the P ratio of 10, still growing. Therefore, target analysts are also seeing it higher. It might be interesting.”

    Listen at 11:57

  30. Sven Carlinon Trip.comPositive11:58

    Trip.com trades at 10 P/E while continuing to grow

    “the stock is trading at the P ratio of 10, still growing”

    Listen at 11:58

  31. Sven Carlinon BaiduNeutral14:25

    Baidu will likely invest its cash in AI

    “They will likely invest it in the AI.”

    Listen at 14:25

  32. Sven Carlinon BaiduPositive14:34

    Baidu’s valuation approximates buying its cash at book value plus AI-related upside options.

    “So you're practically buying cash at book value, plus on top all the bets that might work.”

    Listen at 14:34

  33. Sven Carlinon BaiduPositive14:47

    Baidu trades below the value of its market capitalization and cash

    “you're buying it down below market cap and cash value”

    Listen at 14:47

  34. Sven Carlinon KuaishouNeutral15:52

    Kuaishou has approximately a $20 billion market capitalization

    “you are buying here. What's that? 20 billion US dollar market cap.”

    Listen at 15:52

  35. Sven Carlinon KuaishouPositive16:02

    Kuaishou’s AI exposure is valued at approximately 10 P/E

    “So you're getting AI practically at a P ratio of 10”

    Listen at 16:02

  36. Sven Carlinon Full Truck AlliancePositive17:08

    Full Truck Alliance is profitable with a strong balance sheet and cheap valuation

    “it looks good, profitable, balance sheet. Good balance sheet. We could say fair and cheaply priced.”

    Listen at 17:08

  37. Sven Carlinon Full Truck AlliancePositive17:12

    Full Truck Alliance has a good balance sheet and appears fairly or cheaply priced.

    “Good balance sheet. We could say fair and cheaply priced.”

    Listen at 17:12

  38. Sven Carlinon Chinese education companiesPositive18:23

    Chinese education companies returned to profitability and growth at 7 P/E

    “Back to profitability, back to growth, everything looks good, P ratio of seven.”

    Listen at 18:23

  39. Sven Carlinon New OrientalPositive18:25

    New Oriental has returned to profitability and growth at a seven P/E ratio.

    “everything looks good, P ratio of seven.”

    Listen at 18:25

  40. Tencent Music has a low P/E, profitability, buybacks, and dividends

    “Very interesting, low P ratio, good position, Tencent ecosystem, profitable buybacks, dividends.”

    Listen at 19:16

  41. Sven Carlin prefers the top 15 companies in the China Internet ETF.

    “I like the top 15.”

    Listen at 20:12

  42. Global investors should buy large Chinese companies cheaply and sell during exuberance.

    “for us global investors, I think perhaps the best approach to China, the less risky, is when it's really cheap, when the big companies are really cheap, dip when there is exuberance, out, risk management, rinse and repeat.”

    Listen at 20:33

  43. Buying large Chinese companies when very cheap is the less risky approach

    “the best approach to China, the less risky, is when it's really cheap”

    Listen at 20:36

  44. Investors should use a China internet ETF for smaller-company exposure

    “Perhaps of the smaller ones, an approach to get to it is just to invest in the ETF.”

    Listen at 21:03

  45. Investors should add to the China Internet ETF when it falls and sell after recovery.

    “If it goes lower, you double down. And then when it comes again back, you sell it.”

    Listen at 21:22

  46. Sven Carlinon Chinese global stocksPositive21:41

    Chinese global stocks could return at least 50% within three years

    “It's possible to make 50%. That's a minimal target in three years.”

    Listen at 21:41

  47. Sven Carlinon China VIE structurePositive24:21

    China is unlikely to abolish the VIE structure

    “it's unlikely that China will go against the variable interest entity structure”

    Listen at 24:21

  48. Sven Carlinon Variable interest entity structurePositive24:30

    China poses very little risk to the variable interest entity structure.

    “Very little risk of something happening there on the Chinese side.”

    Listen at 24:30

  49. Sven will not invest in Chinese companies for US investors due to sanctions risk

    “I will not invest in Chinese companies for that investors. Too risky to get sanctioned, to get illiquid.”

    Listen at 26:18

  50. Sven Carlinon Chinese ETFsPositive27:28

    Western investor pessimism toward Chinese ETFs creates an opportunity to investigate them.

    “And because the market went from uninvestable to redemption, now down again. And when the West is fed up with the Chinese ETFs, ad years, things like that, that's the time to look at it.”

    Listen at 27:28

  51. Sven Carlinon Chinese ETFsPositive27:36

    Investors should examine Chinese ETFs when Western sentiment is highly negative

    “when the West is fed up with the Chinese ETFs, ad years, things like that, that's the time to look at it.”

    Listen at 27:36

  52. Sven Carlinon Chinese stocksNegative27:54

    Investors should sell Chinese stocks when sentiment drives prices high

    “Again, the time to sell.”

    Listen at 27:54

  53. Sven Carlinon JD.com and Prosus holdingsNeutral28:13

    Sven’s JD.com and Prosus holdings comprise 10% of his portfolio

    “I own jd process that's already 10 of the portfolio”

    Listen at 28:13

  54. Sven Carlinon JD.com and Prosus holdingsNeutral28:13

    Sven Carlin’s JD.com and Prosus holdings already comprise 10% of his portfolio.

    “I own jd process that's already 10 of the portfolio and now i'm thinking should i go to 20 maybe too much now”

    Listen at 28:13

  55. Sven Carlinon Chinese investmentsNegative29:09

    Chinese investments need substantially lower prices to offer attractive returns relative to alternatives.

    “China needs to be much cheaper for hitting the better side of things.”

    Listen at 29:09

  56. Sven Carlinon Chinese investments and Taiwan tensionsNegative29:31

    Investors should reduce Chinese exposure if Taiwan tensions escalate

    “If they start doing too much hanky-panky around Taiwan, you know, okay, sell, reduce, things like that.”

    Listen at 29:31

Statements are attributed to the speaker as said on the episode and reflect their view at the time, not PodLume's. They are not advice.

Weekly email

State of the Pod, every Monday

The week's most-discussed names and stories from podcasts, with the moments behind them. Free, five minutes, unsubscribe in one click.

Listen to the full episode and explore every guest, topic, and moment on PodLume.

China’s battered internet stocks test the value-investing case · PodLume