The Megyn Kelly Show
The Megyn Kelly Show

Aug 26, 2026 · 1h 54m

Listen from 1:11:58

Listen at 1:11:58

Clancy trial turns on psychosis, medication and courtroom testimony

Every Key Moment From the Lindsay Clancy Trial, Blake Lively's Final Humiliation, and Brian Entin's Dispatch From Clancy Courtroom | Ep. 1386

The episode examines how competing accounts of Lindsay Clancy’s mental state could shape the trial’s interpretation of the killings and any insanity verdict.

3 key takeaways
  1. 1Testimony traces Clancy’s anxiety, insomnia, hospitalization and medication concerns before the killings.
  2. 2Prosecution and defense experts sharply disagree over whether psychosis explains Clancy’s actions.
  3. 3Courtroom observations capture Patrick Clancy’s anguish, the jury’s dynamics and the public’s divided reaction.

Don't miss

The courtroom account of Patrick Clancy discovering the children moves from initial coherence to anguished screams.

The brief

The episode follows testimony about Lindsay Clancy’s escalating anxiety, severe insomnia, hospitalization and medication concerns before the deaths of her children.

A seemingly ordinary dinner order and a brief, coherent phone call become central to the argument over how psychotic Clancy could have been.

Brian Entin describes Patrick Clancy’s reaction after discovering the children, while the courtroom absorbs testimony from competing psychiatric experts.

The central dispute is whether alleged command hallucinations and postpartum psychosis explain the killings, or whether the prosecution’s account better fits the evidence.

The discussion closes with the possible consequences of an insanity verdict and allegations involving Timothy Busfield, alongside Melissa Gilbert’s defense of him.

What was said on this episode

34 statements · 5 positive · 26 negative · 3 neutral

  1. Megyn Kellyon U.S. House controlNeutral1:51

    A House flip would significantly affect the economy.

    “if the house flips, it's a big deal for our economy”

    Listen at 1:51

  2. Megyn Kellyon GoldPositive2:04
    “the price of gold jumped over 12%”

    Listen at 2:04

  3. Megyn Kellyon GoldPositive2:07

    Gold hedges against uncertainty.

    “It's a hedge against uncertainty.”

    Listen at 2:07

  4. Megyn doubts Clancy experienced postpartum psychosis or any psychosis.

    “I personally am not convinced that she suffered from postpartum psychosis or any psychosis at all.”

    Listen at 6:03

  5. Megyn believes Clancy should not receive an insanity-based acquittal.

    “I don't think that this case is one for a not guilty by reason of mental disease or defect.”

    Listen at 6:11

  6. Kelly believes the prosecution is losing the courtroom likability contest.

    “I think the prosecution, though they are absolutely losing the likability contest”

    Listen at 15:08

  7. Kelly believes jurors are bonding more with defense counsel than the prosecutor.

    “The jury's bonding much more with defense counsel, in my estimation, than they are with the ADA.”

    Listen at 15:26

  8. Megyn Kellyon Lindsay Clancy sentenceNegative20:52

    Kelly recommends life imprisonment for Lindsay Clancy.

    “And he was sent off to prison for the remainder of his life, which I think is what should happen to Lindsay Clancy.”

    Listen at 20:52

  9. Megyn believes Clancy should receive a life prison sentence.

    “he was sent off to prison for the remainder of his life, which I think is what should happen to Lindsay Clancy.”

    Listen at 20:52

  10. Megyn Kellyon Lindsay Clancy suicide hotline contactsNegative27:45

    Clancy contacted a suicide hotline twice about wanting self-harm.

    “She called a suicide hotline twice and spoke about wanting to hurt herself.”

    Listen at 27:45

  11. Kelly says suicide hotlines should help callers without a specific suicide plan.

    “The suicide hotline needs to have a come to Jesus moment about, helping the people who have gone to the trouble to tell you they want to kill themselves, but haven't yet come up with a plan.”

    Listen at 28:20

  12. Clancy’s medications appeared to worsen her condition.

    “the medications made the problem worse or so it appeared.”

    Listen at 29:27

  13. Megyn Kellyon SSRIsNegative29:39

    Megyn says SSRIs reportedly help only about 30% of patients.

    “reportedly they only help like 30% of the people.”

    Listen at 29:39

  14. Megyn Kellyon Fragmented psychiatric careNegative30:01

    Fragmented psychiatric care can worsen risks for patients.

    “the right hand doesn't know what the left hand's doing. And before you know it, you're really playing with fire.”

    Listen at 30:01

  15. Megyn believes Clancy understood her conduct was wrong.

    “And she did understand that. She absolutely understood that.”

    Listen at 30:38

  16. Kelly believes Clancy understood her conduct was wrong.

    “She absolutely understood that.”

    Listen at 30:40

  17. Kelly interprets Clancy’s restaurant choice as evidence of planning.

    “That, that is planning.”

    Listen at 31:14

  18. Megyn interprets Clancy's restaurant diversion as evidence of murder planning.

    “That, that is planning. That looks like somebody who had murder on her mind and was planning how to get rid of the husband”

    Listen at 31:14

  19. Kelly believes Clancy genuinely intended suicide.

    “I think she did want to die.”

    Listen at 37:12

  20. Kelly says Clancy’s methodical actions indicate sound mind.

    “all of that is evidence that she was of sound mind.”

    Listen at 37:38

  21. Megyn says Clancy's pill preparation indicates sound, ordered thinking.

    “all of that is evidence that she was of sound mind. She was making logical decisions and she had ordered thinking.”

    Listen at 37:38

  22. Megyn says Clancy sounded lucid during the phone call before the killings.

    “She stopped. She took a call. She was lucid. She did not sound out of her mind.”

    Listen at 49:32

  23. Megyn Kellyon Lindsay ClancyNegative1:10:01

    Megyn says Clancy knew killing her children was wrong.

    “She knew her conduct was wrong.”

    Listen at 1:10:01

  24. Megyn Kellyon ZoloftNegative1:11:58

    Megyn says Zoloft or Prozac generally do not cause psychosis and child killing.

    “generally taking zoloft or prozac does not cause psychosis and make you kill your children”

    Listen at 1:11:58

  25. Brian Entinon Lindsay ClancyPositive1:13:05

    Brian says an insanity acquittal could eventually allow Clancy to leave treatment.

    “If she's not guilty by reason of insanity, She could get out.”

    Listen at 1:13:05

  26. Brian Entinon Lindsay ClancyNeutral1:18:55

    Brian predicts the jury will deliberate for a long time.

    “I think it's going to be a long deliberation.”

    Listen at 1:18:55

  27. Megyn Kellyon Blake Lively and Justin Baldoni disputeNegative1:24:20

    Megyn says Lively's side held power while Baldoni had none.

    “The roles were reversed. Blake Lively was the bully. She and her husband with her dragons, Taylor Swift and Ryan Reynolds. They had all the power. Justin Baldoni had none.”

    Listen at 1:24:20

  28. Megyn Kellyon Justin Baldoni legal-fee rulingPositive1:25:14

    Megyn evaluates the fee ruling as a major victory for Baldoni.

    “What a great, great result for Justin Baldoni. Congratulations to him because he fought hard and he won. He won.”

    Listen at 1:25:14

  29. Megyn Kellyon Timothy BusfieldNegative1:25:54

    Timothy Busfield is on trial over alleged sexual abuse of two boys.

    “Timothy Busfield, is currently on trial for allegedly sexually abusing two young boys”

    Listen at 1:25:54

  30. Busfield privately settled the 17-year-old's civil assault case.

    “They settled the case privately.”

    Listen at 1:32:07

  31. Megyn says Michelle Trachtenberg died from diabetes complications at age 39.

    “Michelle Trachtenberg died at the age of 39 in February of 25 from complications from diabetes.”

    Listen at 1:42:49

  32. Megyn Kellyon DeVay ChaseNegative1:43:04

    Megyn says DeVay Chase died of AIDS at age 36.

    “DeVay Chase, who died on June 16th at the age of 36. She voiced Lilo in Lilo and Stitch. She died of AIDS”

    Listen at 1:43:04

  33. Megyn Kellyon Cell phones and mental healthNegative1:47:00

    Megyn says cell phones have harmed everyone's mental health.

    “The cell phone's been a terrible influence on mental health for everyone.”

    Listen at 1:47:00

  34. Megyn Kellyon Hollywood exploitation and sexual abuseNegative1:52:11

    Megyn says Hollywood has widespread exploitation and sexual abuse.

    “I do think there's a massive problem in Hollywood with the exploitation of children, with the serial sexual abuse of young women, and more mature women as well”

    Listen at 1:52:11

Statements are attributed to the speaker as said on the episode and reflect their view at the time, not PodLume's. They are not advice.

Books & mentions

Some links are affiliate links — PodLume may earn a commission if you buy.

Weekly email

State of the Pod, every Monday

The week's most-discussed names and stories from podcasts, with the moments behind them. Free, five minutes, unsubscribe in one click.

Listen to the full episode and explore every guest, topic, and moment on PodLume.