The Bulwark Daily
The Bulwark Daily

Oct 14, 2026 · 1h 25m

Listen from 1:09:37

Listen at 1:09:37

College-educated workers test Democrats’ coalition strategy

Roy Cooper and Noam Scheiber: We Gotta Rein Trump In

The episode connects professional-class economic frustration with the Democratic Party’s struggle to build a durable cross-class coalition and win competitive states.

3 key takeaways
  1. 1College-educated workers face debt, underemployment, and class dislocation despite promises that higher education would deliver security.
  2. 2Economic convergence has not erased cultural and organizational tensions between professional voters and traditional working-class constituencies.
  3. 3Roy Cooper pairs criticism of executive overreach with practical affordability priorities while warning that a polling lead cannot justify complacency.

Don't miss

Roy Cooper explains why a polling lead in North Carolina should not inspire complacency, given the state’s unpredictable electoral history.

The brief

Noam Scheiber traces how younger workers encouraged toward college after the Great Recession encountered debt, underemployment, and economic outcomes far short of the promise.

The conversation asks why shared economic frustrations have not united professional and traditional working-class voters, highlighting tensions around student debt, labor organizing, and political language.

Scheiber and Tim Miller consider whether dissatisfied college-educated workers could fuel a new left-populist movement, or whether class identity will keep fragmenting the coalition.

Roy Cooper argues that Democrats should focus on affordability, public safety, health care, education, and democratic checks rather than abstract party reform.

Cooper’s polling lead in North Carolina becomes a warning against complacency, as he stresses the state’s unpredictability and the need to win swing races.

What was said on this episode

50 statements · 27 positive · 16 negative · 1 mixed · 6 neutral

  1. Noam Scheiberon College degreesNegative9:40

    College degree returns stagnated and began declining after accounting for student debt.

    “When they get out, the return to a college degree is suddenly stagnating and then starting to go down if you factor in all the debt that they've had to take on.”

    Listen at 9:40

  2. Noam Scheiberon College degreesNegative9:41

    College degrees’ debt-adjusted returns are stagnating and declining.

    “the return to a college degree is suddenly stagnating and then starting to go down if you factor in all the debt that they've had to take on”

    Listen at 9:41

  3. Noam Scheiberon College graduates’ support for socialismPositive10:21

    College graduates’ support for socialism roughly doubled during the 2010s.

    “The number of college grads who say they support socialism basically doubles in the 2010s from like the low 20s to over 40 percent”

    Listen at 10:21

  4. Noam Scheiberon Young college graduates’ labor marketNegative13:09

    Young college graduates’ labor market deteriorated after the Great Recession and never fully recovered within ten years.

    “the labor market for college grads really starts to kind of slow down even before the Great Recession, sort of 2003, 4, 5, and then nosedives after the Great Recession. And then we just never see it fully recover, at least for young grads, even 10 years after the Great Recession.”

    Listen at 13:09

  5. Noam Scheiberon Doctors’ employment structureNegative14:54

    Most doctors now work as employees of large healthcare systems with managerial directives.

    “Most doctors are now employees. They work for these huge healthcare systems that are run by like MBAs that give them all kinds of like marching orders”

    Listen at 14:54

  6. Noam Scheiberon DoctorsNeutral14:54

    Most doctors are now employees of large healthcare systems.

    “Most doctors are now employees.”

    Listen at 14:54

  7. Noam Scheiberon Economic conditions and ideologyNeutral17:18

    Ideology is shaped by economic conditions.

    “I personally think ideology is is downstream of economics.”

    Listen at 17:18

  8. Noam Scheiberon College-educated votersPositive18:00

    College-educated voters began moving left around 2004.

    “Beginning in 2004, we started to see the college-educated folks move a little bit left.”

    Listen at 18:00

  9. Noam Scheiberon College-educated votersPositive18:12

    College-educated voters shifted sharply left in 2008.

    “We see this huge lurch in 2008”

    Listen at 18:12

  10. The financial crisis drove both economic concern and institutional distrust among college-educated people.

    “the financial crisis is kind of impetus for both of them”

    Listen at 19:40

  11. Noam Scheiberon UnderdogismNegative23:05

    Underdogism and skepticism toward American power fuel this generation’s ideological shift.

    “Underdogism, deep skepticism of American power, of American institutions really fuels the ideological component of this.”

    Listen at 23:05

  12. Noam Scheiberon Joe BidenPositive23:56

    Biden largely pursued policies desired by college-educated left voters.

    “Biden in many ways is doing everything that this group of voters wants”

    Listen at 23:56

  13. Noam Scheiberon College-educated and non-college votersNeutral28:44

    College-educated and non-college voters are converging economically.

    “We are seeing a real convergence on economics.”

    Listen at 28:44

  14. “if you looked at, say, support for UAW, striking UAW workers, it was about 70 percent of Americans supported the workers over the companies.”

    Listen at 29:35

  15. Noam Scheiberon Public support for striking workersPositive29:39
    “it was about 70 percent of Americans supported the workers over the companies. And if you just broke it out by college educated folks, they're even higher. You know, they're like 75 percent support for the workers.”

    Listen at 29:39

  16. Noam Scheiberon College-educated and traditional workers’ coalitionNegative31:53

    Coalitions between college-educated and traditional workers are fragile and can quickly unravel.

    “you do see how, even though the, you know, you see the sort of basis for the coalition, but you also see how fragile it is and how quickly it can kind of unravel.”

    Listen at 31:53

  17. Noam Scheiberon Biden green-energy policyNegative35:10

    Biden’s union-focused green-energy policy reduced efficiency and slowed implementation.

    “that makes it less efficient. It slows it down.”

    Listen at 35:10

  18. Noam Scheiberon Political definitions of classNeutral40:35

    The left defines class by current work; the right emphasizes family background and upbringing.

    “The left, it's like what you are now in your immediate circumstances and your relationship to work and capital. And the right, it's like, what did your parents do and how did you grow up?”

    Listen at 40:35

  19. Noam Scheiberon Affordability pressuresPositive45:37

    Affordability pressures are uniting young, non-college, industrial, and college-educated workers.

    “I do think that is kind of uniting this coalition that you just talked to, you know, young people, non-college, sort of traditional industrial working class and the college educated working class”

    Listen at 45:37

  20. Housing is currently less attainable for Americans than for any prior modern-mortgage generation.

    “Housing has never been more unattainable to any generation of Americans, you know, since we started doing, you know, the kind of modern mortgage market than it is today.”

    Listen at 47:24

  21. Noam Scheiberon 2028Neutral48:36

    This election cycle’s Democratic primaries were a warmup for 2028.

    “what we saw in the democratic primaries, this election cycle was a warmup for, for 2028”

    Listen at 48:36

  22. Noam Scheiberon Left-populist Democratic candidatesPositive48:48
    “you will have a sense, you know, unless things go very badly for Democrats in the midterms that actually either, you know, you do better nominating these, you know, left populist candidates, or at least you don't do worse”

    Listen at 48:48

  23. Noam Scheiberon Democratic primary conflictsNegative49:31
    “I expect this year's. you know, sometimes divisive primaries, you know, particularly in Michigan, I suspect that we're going to see that play out on like a much bigger scale in the run up to 20, 20”

    Listen at 49:31

  24. Noam Scheiberon MamdaniPositive51:42

    Mamdani will be influential in Democratic politics during the 2028–2032 period.

    “I expect him, you know, to be a, you know, a player in this 2028, 2032 conversation.”

    Listen at 51:42

  25. Roy Cooperon Trump tariffsNegative54:27

    Trump should remove chaotic tariffs because they impose costs on people.

    “what he ought to be doing is removing these chaotic tariffs that are costing people”

    Listen at 54:27

  26. Roy Cooperon Russian diesel dealNegative56:47

    Buying Russian diesel relieves pressure on Russia and funds further attacks on Ukraine.

    “this not only relieves that pressure, but gives them more money to drop more bombs on Ukraine.”

    Listen at 56:47

  27. Roy Cooperon Congressional checks and balancesPositive57:01

    A Democratic congressional majority should restore constitutional checks and balances.

    “if we are able to take back the Senate and the House is to bring back those checks and balances that the framers of the Constitution intended”

    Listen at 57:01

  28. Roy Cooperon Healthcare subsidies and child tax creditPositive59:50

    Congress should restore healthcare subsidies and provide a child tax credit.

    “we need to pass legislation that restores. funding for health care subsidies that provides for child tax credit”

    Listen at 59:50

  29. The current administration has worsened affordability rather than reducing costs.

    “this president and the administration has not. made things less expensive. They've made it so much worse.”

    Listen at 1:00:20

  30. Roy Cooperon Cost-of-living legislationPositive1:00:28

    Congress should pass measures addressing healthcare subsidies, child tax credits, Iran, tariffs, and living costs.

    “The first thing we need to do is to try and put that kind of legislation on his desk.”

    Listen at 1:00:28

  31. Roy Cooperon Citizens United and partisan gerrymanderingPositive1:00:51

    Cooper will seek to overturn Citizens United and extreme partisan gerrymandering.

    “I'm going to be first in line to try to find a way to overturn Citizens United and extreme partisan gerrymandering.”

    Listen at 1:00:51

  32. Roy Cooperon Public officials’ personal enrichmentNegative1:01:15

    Public officials should not use elected office for personal enrichment.

    “you shouldn't be elected to office in order to make a buck.”

    Listen at 1:01:15

  33. Roy Cooperon Senate filibusterPositive1:07:35

    The filibuster has prevented passage of the SAVE Act.

    “the filibuster has helped save us from the SAVE Act.”

    Listen at 1:07:35

  34. Roy Cooperon Senate filibusterPositive1:08:02

    The filibuster currently helps protect voting rights across states.

    “what the filibuster is doing is helping to protect voting in states across the country.”

    Listen at 1:08:02

  35. American democracy is currently under threat.

    “our democracy certainly is being threatened right now.”

    Listen at 1:09:37

  36. Roy Cooperon North Carolina Republican pollingNegative1:10:37

    North Carolina polls typically understate Republican support by five or six points.

    “you can pretty much add five or six percentage points to whatever Republicans are doing in the polls in North Carolina.”

    Listen at 1:10:37

  37. Roy Cooperon Democratic campaign strategyPositive1:13:59

    Democrats should emphasize basic concerns such as safety and education.

    “sticking to the basics is important because most people want to live in a safe community.”

    Listen at 1:13:59

  38. Roy Cooperon North Carolina jobsPositive1:15:13

    Cooper’s administration helped create 640,000 better-paying jobs.

    “We helped create 640,000 new better paying jobs”

    Listen at 1:15:13

  39. Roy Cooperon Democratic PartyPositive1:16:40

    Democrats should prioritize winning swing races over fixing party structure.

    “not worry about fixing the Democratic Party.”

    Listen at 1:16:40

  40. Roy Cooperon U.S. border securityPositive1:18:57

    The United States needs a strong and secure border.

    “we need a strong, secure border”

    Listen at 1:18:57

  41. Roy Cooperon Deportation of violent criminalsPositive1:19:08

    The United States should deport violent criminals.

    “we need to deport violent criminals”

    Listen at 1:19:08

  42. Roy Cooperon ICE officersPositive1:19:31

    ICE officers should follow local law-enforcement rules and training standards.

    “At the very least, ICE officers should have to obey by the same rules and have the same training that local and state law enforcement have.”

    Listen at 1:19:31

  43. Roy Cooperon ICE officersPositive1:19:33

    ICE officers should follow local law-enforcement rules and training standards.

    “ICE officers should have to obey by the same rules and have the same training that local and state law enforcement have.”

    Listen at 1:19:33

  44. Roy Cooperon Immigration detention hearingsPositive1:20:37

    Immigration detainees should receive fair hearings on their legal status.

    “we also need to have a system where they can have a fair hearing about. their legal status in the United States.”

    Listen at 1:20:37

  45. Roy Cooperon College sportsNeutral1:22:03

    College sports are becoming more professionalized.

    “College sports are moving toward the professional level.”

    Listen at 1:22:03

  46. Roy Cooperon College athletesPositive1:22:08

    College athletes should have been paid.

    “I think players should have been paid.”

    Listen at 1:22:08

  47. Roy Cooperon College athletesPositive1:22:09

    College athletes should have been paid previously.

    “players should have been paid.”

    Listen at 1:22:09

  48. The Tar Heels may have a successful basketball season this year.

    “I'm going to bet that the Tar Heels might have a pretty good year this year.”

    Listen at 1:22:21

  49. Roy Cooperon Charlotte HornetsPositive1:23:43

    The Charlotte Hornets have the core of a good team.

    “But I think they've got the core of... good team.”

    Listen at 1:23:43

  50. The Hornets have a good core but must improve beyond the play-in level.

    “I think they've got the core of... good team. You've got to get out of this play-in game level where they are. They've got to get back to where they need to be.”

    Listen at 1:23:43

Statements are attributed to the speaker as said on the episode and reflect their view at the time, not PodLume's. They are not advice.

Books & mentions

Some links are affiliate links — PodLume may earn a commission if you buy.

Weekly email

State of the Pod, every Monday

The week's most-discussed names and stories from podcasts, with the moments behind them. Free, five minutes, unsubscribe in one click.

Listen to the full episode and explore every guest, topic, and moment on PodLume.