The Megyn Kelly Show
The Megyn Kelly Show

Sep 30, 2026 · 1h 43m

Listen from 3:48

Listen at 3:48

Cornell case exposes clash over evidence, consent and New York law

The Truth About Every Angle of the Cornell Case, From the Original "Jane Doe" 2024 Story to Media Lies Today | Ep. 1409

The episode examines how conflicting accounts, evidentiary limits and legal standards shape public judgments about a serious civil lawsuit.

3 key takeaways
  1. 1The discussion centers on conflicting accounts about intoxication, consent, alleged drugging and the timeline of the Cornell incident.
  2. 2Megyn Kelly argues that New York law and the available evidence constrained the district attorney’s ability to bring charges.
  3. 3The episode criticizes media and political commentary for presenting disputed allegations without sufficient attention to legal and factual nuance.

Don't miss

The sharpest exchange contrasts the district attorney’s explanation of legal constraints with criticism that the case was not investigated adequately.

The brief

Megyn Kelly opens with a civil lawsuit alleging that a former Cornell student was drugged and gang raped, then focuses on the evidence and legal response.

The central dispute turns on conflicting accounts from 2024 and 2026, the significance of intoxication and consent, and what New York law permits prosecutors to charge.

Kelly challenges public commentary, including Representative Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez’s description of the allegations, arguing that the available account does not establish drugging.

The district attorney’s defense is that New York law constrained the office, while the woman’s contemporaneous recollection and lack of direct contact with prosecutors mattered.

Kelly closes by criticizing Jake Tapper and other commentators for overlooking legal details, calling the case sad but widely misrepresented.

What was said on this episode

27 statements · 2 positive · 17 negative · 3 mixed · 5 neutral

  1. Megyn Kellyon Potential rape caseNegative1:37

    Potential rape charges face serious legal problems.

    “I see some serious problems with any potential rape case that the DA may try to bring.”

    Listen at 1:37

  2. Megyn Kellyon Cornell fraternity conductNeutral3:05

    Disgusting texts and inappropriate threesomes do not establish rape.

    “But disgusting texts and inappropriate threesomes where you're openly celebrating it with your fraternity brothers does not make you a rapist.”

    Listen at 3:05

  3. The DA appears to be an honest broker.

    “And I believe that we will. I believe the DA involved in this case seems like an honest broker.”

    Listen at 3:48

  4. Megyn Kellyon Jane DoeNegative6:48

    The reporting delay and initial police choice undermine the allegation.

    “The delay, the chatting with the friends, and then the decision to go to campus police says a lot to me.”

    Listen at 6:48

  5. Megyn Kellyon Cornell civil lawsuitNegative9:20

    The civil lawsuit reframes consensual threesomes as gang rape.

    “One person's threesome is... a greedy tort lawyer's gang rape.”

    Listen at 9:20

  6. Megyn Kellyon Accused Cornell menNegative14:43

    One accused man was fired from his bank job.

    “One has already been fired from his job at a Wells Fargo bank.”

    Listen at 14:43

  7. Megyn Kellyon Accuser anonymity in civil casesNegative17:20

    Not all accusers should automatically receive identity protection.

    “And I just I don't think we can continue this farce of pretending all accusers are actual victims whose identities must be protected.”

    Listen at 17:20

  8. Megyn Kellyon Sexual-assault allegationsNeutral18:37

    Serious allegations should be made under the accuser’s name.

    “If you're going to make an allegation that is as serious as that, you're going to have to stand behind it.”

    Listen at 18:37

  9. Megyn Kellyon alcoholNegative20:50

    Ten drinks in three hours impair judgment.

    “10 drinks in three hours? What do you think is going to happen? You think your judgment's going to be intact?”

    Listen at 20:50

  10. Megyn Kellyon alcoholNegative21:37

    Two drinks are enough to impair judgment.

    “Two drinks. That'll do it.”

    Listen at 21:37

  11. Megyn Kellyon Cornell defendant number twoNegative23:24

    Defendant two deserved expulsion if allegations are true.

    “And I hope he was one of the two who got expelled.”

    Listen at 23:24

  12. Megyn Kellyon Cornell defendant number twoMixed23:31

    Defendant two is not a rapist but behaved reprehensibly.

    “I do not see him as a rapist or a gang rapist, but he really has got to spend some time with God and hopefully his own conscience and think about what went down that night.”

    Listen at 23:31

  13. Megyn Kellyon ConsentNeutral35:25

    Trying again after “I’m tired” does not necessarily negate consent.

    “And so just because they tried again after I'm tired does not, absolutely does not mean there's been no consent.”

    Listen at 35:25

  14. Megyn Kellyon New York rape lawNegative43:03

    Voluntary conscious intoxication without physical incapacitation cannot support rape charges under New York law.

    “if you allege that you were voluntarily intoxicated, that you were conscious, but very drunk, or high, very high on drugs, but conscious, and that the reason you got very drunk or very high was your own choices to drink a lot or do a lot of drugs, but you are not physically incapacitated, i.e., passed out or asleep, you cannot be charged.”

    Listen at 43:03

  15. Megyn Kellyon New York rape lawNeutral44:29

    A charge would require an allegation that drugs or alcohol were administered without consent.

    “And she did not consent. to take the drug or drink the drink. That's what we're going to need.”

    Listen at 44:29

  16. Stopping when asked indicates neither forcible sex nor total incapacitation.

    “That is not forcible sex. That is not total incapacitation.”

    Listen at 52:16

  17. Megyn Kellyon Cornell fraternity conductNegative1:05:28

    The alleged conduct was immoral but did not satisfy criminal-law requirements.

    “But it's not a crime. unless certain legal boxes are checked and they're not here.”

    Listen at 1:05:28

  18. Megyn Kellyon Cornell fraternity behaviorMixed1:11:04

    The fraternity behavior was wrong but not illegal.

    “all this behavior is wrong, as I've conceded, but not illegal in my view.”

    Listen at 1:11:04

  19. Megyn Kellyon Jane DoeNegative1:15:35

    Jane Doe’s account described voluntary intoxication without inability to control conduct.

    “what we have here is a situation where she was very high and very drunk. due to the drugs she chose to take, the drinks she chose to have, and then is not alleging a situation when she sat down with police where she was incapable of controlling her own conduct.”

    Listen at 1:15:35

  20. Megyn Kellyon Cornell defendants' statementsNegative1:19:19

    The defendants had not issued statements, which Kelly expects will hurt Jane Doe's case.

    “The boys have issued no statement. I don't think it's going to get better for her when the boys issue their statement.”

    Listen at 1:19:19

  21. Megyn Kellyon Cornell civil lawsuitNegative1:21:26

    Her account creates a legal problem for the civil case.

    “This is a problem for her legally.”

    Listen at 1:21:26

  22. Megyn Kellyon Jane DoeNegative1:37:39

    Her 2024 statement could not support prosecution.

    “there is no way. according to her statement in 2024, that any prosecutor would have brought forth the case.”

    Listen at 1:37:39

  23. Megyn Kellyon Voluntary intoxication under New York lawNeutral1:37:52

    Voluntary alcohol and ketamine use does not itself establish criminal sexual assault.

    “If you voluntarily drink 10 beers and you voluntarily ingest ketamine, but that intoxication...”

    Listen at 1:37:52

  24. Megyn Kellyon Jane DoePositive1:38:11

    Megyn says Jane Doe’s 2024 statement indicated consent to sexual activity.

    “Her statement in 2024, she consented to the sexual activity.”

    Listen at 1:38:11

  25. Megyn Kellyon Jane DoeMixed1:38:28

    Jane Doe's 2024 and 2026 accounts differ.

    “But in 2024, she said one thing. And now in 2026, she's saying another thing.”

    Listen at 1:38:28

  26. Megyn Kellyon Chi-Fi group chatNegative1:39:58

    The fraternity group-chat messages do not admit drugging her.

    “there is nothing on here about admitting that they drugged her.”

    Listen at 1:39:58

  27. Kelly says AOC's account contains false claims.

    “That's just lies. Those are lies.”

    Listen at 1:40:31

Statements are attributed to the speaker as said on the episode and reflect their view at the time, not PodLume's. They are not advice.

Weekly email

State of the Pod, every Monday

The week's most-discussed names and stories from podcasts, with the moments behind them. Free, five minutes, unsubscribe in one click.

Listen to the full episode and explore every guest, topic, and moment on PodLume.