The Megyn Kelly Show
The Megyn Kelly Show

Oct 1, 2026 · 1h 44m

Listen from 48:48

Listen at 48:48

Cornell case tests due process amid public condemnation

"Cornell 7" Lawyer Speaks Out, Plus Bombshell New Texts From "Jane Doe," and Kevin Reddington's Bizarre Tactic | Ep. 1410

The episode examines how university proceedings, disputed evidence, anonymity, and online backlash can shape both legal outcomes and reputations.

3 key takeaways
  1. 1Tara Davis disputes key elements of the Cornell accuser’s account while distinguishing university findings from criminal rape determinations.
  2. 2The discussion argues that doxxing and public demands to destroy defendants’ futures can precede a fair evaluation of evidence.
  3. 3Megyn Kelly criticizes Kevin Reddington’s Lindsay Clancy strategy and questions the treatment of a holdout juror during ongoing proceedings.

Don't miss

Tara Davis explains why a university finding of responsibility should not be treated as a criminal rape finding.

The brief

Attorney Tara Davis describes representing a Cornell defendant through hearings and appeals, while the discussion contrasts changing Title IX procedures with the demands of due process.

Davis disputes parts of the accuser’s account, addresses anonymity and disputed evidence, and separates a university policy finding from a criminal rape determination.

The interview turns to doxxing, threats, and social-media calls to ruin the defendants, raising the question of whether condemnation has replaced evidence review.

Megyn criticizes Kevin Reddington’s defense theory in the Lindsay Clancy case and defends holdout juror Michael Desranville amid a related controversy.

A final report reconstructs Presley Gerber’s last hours at a sober-living facility and questions why staff admitted him while reportedly intoxicated.

What was said on this episode

38 statements · 17 positive · 17 negative · 1 mixed · 3 neutral

  1. Tara Davison Title IXPositive4:54

    Current Title IX rules restore advisors’ attendance and cross-examination rights.

    “So now we are back to... the position of being able to attend, being able to cross-examine witnesses.”

    Listen at 4:54

  2. Tara Davison New York courts’ pseudonym policyPositive6:33

    New York courts are likely to let the accuser proceed under a pseudonym.

    “But I think that the courts are likely to allow her to remain that status”

    Listen at 6:33

  3. Tara Davison New York courts’ pseudonym policyPositive6:34

    New York courts are likely to let Jane Doe proceed anonymously.

    “I think that the courts are likely to allow her to remain that status because of, again, the nature of the allegations”

    Listen at 6:34

  4. Tara Davison Jane DoePositive15:26

    Lopes’s account is that all sexual activity was consensual.

    “So from his perspective, I mean, yes, everything was consensual and there was no question about it.”

    Listen at 15:26

  5. Tara Davison Lopes university sanctionsNegative16:04

    Lopes received a suspension in addition to educational sanctions.

    “He did receive a suspension period.”

    Listen at 16:04

  6. Tara Davison Cornell Title IX sanctionsNegative16:46

    Davis has not encountered a responsible finding punished only with an essay.

    “I can't recall. A single case where someone found responsible was assigned only an essay.”

    Listen at 16:46

  7. Tara Davison Online allegations about Cornell defendantsNegative20:34

    Online allegations will likely remain available indefinitely and affect defendants’ employment prospects.

    “it's going to be out there and it's going to live on the Internet. um you know forever”

    Listen at 20:34

  8. Tara Davison Civil complaint allegations against LopesNegative22:59

    Davis says the civil complaint misstates the hearing evidence about Lopes.

    “Yes, that's just not factual. It's not what was presented in the hearing through any of the testimony, through the evidence.”

    Listen at 22:59

  9. Tara Davison Lopes sexual encounterPositive24:04

    Lopes’s defense is that his sexual encounter with her was consensual.

    “Correct.”

    Listen at 24:04

  10. Tara Davison Ketamine and consent capacityNeutral25:03

    Ketamine matters because it may bear on whether Jane Doe could consent.

    “But here the relevance is to the question of capacity.”

    Listen at 25:03

  11. Tara Davison Ketamine and consent capacityNegative25:06

    Ketamine matters because incapacitation could negate consent under the university’s process.

    “So, you know, in looking at the allegations of sexual assault, the question is whether she was incapacitated such that she could not consent”

    Listen at 25:06

  12. Tara Davison Jane DoePositive26:21

    Davis says Jane Doe was not incapacitated during Lopes’s involvement.

    “she was not incapacitated as far as we saw through all the testimony, her own testimony included, as well as the evidence.”

    Listen at 26:21

  13. Tara Davison Lopes drug usePositive28:16

    Lopes did not use drugs during the incident.

    “No, he didn't use any drugs that night.”

    Listen at 28:16

  14. Tara Davison KetaminePositive29:00

    The hearing panel found Lopes was not involved in ketamine use.

    “No, I believe the hearing panel had found that he wasn't involved in, in the use of the academy that night.”

    Listen at 29:00

  15. Tara Davison KetaminePositive29:01

    The hearing panel found Lopes was not involved in ketamine use that night.

    “the hearing panel had found that he wasn't involved in, in the use of the academy that night.”

    Listen at 29:01

  16. Tara Davison Cornell Title IX proceedingMixed30:42

    Davis says Cornell took the case seriously but an investigator was insufficiently attentive.

    “I think they were taking it seriously. I don't know that they were perhaps. or at least this particular individual was paying attention as much as she should have been throughout the entire thing.”

    Listen at 30:42

  17. Tara Davison Cornell Title IX hearing panelNegative30:44

    A Title IX panelist may not have paid sufficient attention during the hearing.

    “I don't know that they were perhaps. or at least this particular individual was paying attention as much as she should have been throughout the entire thing.”

    Listen at 30:44

  18. Tara Davison Jane DoePositive32:08

    Early messages indicated Jane Doe viewed the encounters as consensual.

    “But the initial ones, there was certainly some indication of that.”

    Listen at 32:08

  19. Tara Davison Cornell Title IX terminologyNeutral33:10

    Cornell classifies relevant policy findings as sexual assault rather than rape.

    “It would have been sexual assault that they would classify it as.”

    Listen at 33:10

  20. Tara Davison DA case reviewNegative33:39

    Public pressure appears to have influenced the DA’s decision to revisit the case.

    “I mean, to me, it seems like pressure to do so.”

    Listen at 33:39

  21. Tara Davison DA’s renewed Cornell investigationNegative33:40

    Public pressure appears to have influenced the DA’s decision to revisit the case.

    “to me, it seems like pressure to do so.”

    Listen at 33:40

  22. Tara Davison Cornell 7 casePositive34:42

    People should remain open-minded and avoid premature conclusions about guilt.

    “I would just, you know, encourage people to be perhaps a bit more open minded and not immediately jump to conclusions about about who did what and who's guilty or not.”

    Listen at 34:42

  23. Tara Davison New York State courtsPositive36:32

    New York generally accommodates litigants proceeding under pseudonyms.

    “But I do think New York State as a general matter, you know, is pretty accommodating in terms of allowing for parties to proceed by pseudonym.”

    Listen at 36:32

  24. Tara Davison New York State courtsPositive36:33

    New York generally accommodates litigants seeking to proceed under pseudonyms.

    “New York State as a general matter, you know, is pretty accommodating in terms of allowing for parties to proceed by pseudonym.”

    Listen at 36:33

  25. Tara Davison Cornell Snapchat messagesNegative38:22

    The Snapchat messages are disturbing and the participants should feel embarrassed.

    “it's disturbing. And I'm sure that, you know, the men that are on there are embarrassed as they should be.”

    Listen at 38:22

  26. Tara Davison College student behaviorNegative39:23

    College students’ experimentation can lead to sanctions and potential criminal activity.

    “Kids do dumb things. And hopefully it's not to this extent where it leads to conduct findings and sanctions and potential criminal activity.”

    Listen at 39:23

  27. Tara Davison College studentsNegative39:23

    College students commonly engage in foolish behavior away from home.

    “Kids do dumb things.”

    Listen at 39:23

  28. Tara Davison Cornell casePositive41:36

    People should wait for more facts before judging the Cornell case.

    “there's a lot of facts that have to come out and i think people need to pause and just wait to see um you know what happens with the case and where this goes”

    Listen at 41:36

  29. Tara Davison Cornell sexual-assault allegationsNeutral43:59

    Campus sexual-assault prevalence does not establish that this case involved assault.

    “But that doesn't mean that that's what happened here.”

    Listen at 43:59

  30. Tara Davison Title IXPositive44:27

    Properly followed Title IX processes generally produce correct outcomes.

    “when the processes are implemented and followed, they do reach correct outcomes.”

    Listen at 44:27

  31. Tara Davison Obama-era Title IX enforcementNegative44:39

    Davis prefers not to restore Obama-era Title IX enforcement.

    “Preferably not.”

    Listen at 44:39

  32. Tara Davison Cornell sanctions criticismNegative46:00

    Public criticism of Cornell sanctions reflects incomplete knowledge of the facts.

    “But this, unfortunately, is another snapshot of people who don't have all the facts”

    Listen at 46:00

  33. Tara Davison Public reactions to Cornell caseNegative46:00

    Public reactions to the Cornell case are based on incomplete facts.

    “this, unfortunately, is another snapshot of people who don't have all the facts”

    Listen at 46:00

  34. Tara Davison Evidence against LopesPositive48:02

    Davis says the evidence did not sufficiently establish a crime by Lopes.

    “there was no evidence sufficient to show that there was a crime committed”

    Listen at 48:02

  35. Tara Davison Jane DoePositive48:48

    Evidence will show Jane Doe appeared aware of what was happening.

    “the evidence will show that she was not presenting in a way that would have suggested that she was not aware of what was happening.”

    Listen at 48:48

  36. Megyn Kellyon Anonymity in rape civil lawsuitsNegative1:15:08

    Megyn argues anonymity should not protect a civil plaintiff seeking money who names defendants.

    “I just don't think there is any reason when you are talking about a civil lawsuit asking for money to protect the identity of a woman alleging rape when she names all of the defendants.”

    Listen at 1:15:08

  37. Megyn Kellyon Kevin ReddingtonNegative1:22:15

    Reddington shifted toward arguing that Clancy may not have committed the murders.

    “Now he's trying to do a defense on the merits like she might not have done it, like actual innocence.”

    Listen at 1:22:15

  38. Megyn Kellyon Lindsey ClancyNegative1:24:13

    Megyn predicts Lindsey Clancy will probably be retried.

    “there is a 99% chance it gets retried”

    Listen at 1:24:13

Statements are attributed to the speaker as said on the episode and reflect their view at the time, not PodLume's. They are not advice.

Weekly email

State of the Pod, every Monday

The week's most-discussed names and stories from podcasts, with the moments behind them. Free, five minutes, unsubscribe in one click.

Listen to the full episode and explore every guest, topic, and moment on PodLume.