Pod Save America
Pod Save America

Aug 11, 2026 · 1h 53m

Democrats debate a working-class reset

Can Dems Put Woke to Bed?

The episode tests whether Democrats can defend civil rights while addressing affordability, public safety, and voter distrust without surrendering the argument to Republican framing.

3 key takeaways
  1. 1The hosts argue Democrats must separate unpopular rhetoric from civil-rights commitments while confronting Republican responsibility for policy failures.
  2. 2Sam Forstag links wildfire cuts, housing costs, public lands, and AI oversight to Democrats’ struggle to rebuild working-class credibility.
  3. 3The episode connects national political fights—from Iran and vaccines to women’s sports—with the messaging pressures shaping the midterms.

Don't miss

Sam Forstag connects his smokejumper experience and Montana’s affordability crisis to a broader argument that Democrats must rebuild trust through material results.

The brief

Jon Favreau and Jon Lovett survey a crowded political landscape: Trump’s stalled Iran war, Netanyahu’s rejection of Palestinian statehood, vaccine misinformation, and Todd Blanche’s confirmation.

Their central argument is that Democrats should acknowledge where progressive rhetoric alienated voters without abandoning civil rights, abortion rights, or scrutiny of Republican power.

The hosts then examine primary contests, women’s sports, and Hunter Biden’s right-wing media tour as examples of how attention and political framing can distort priorities.

Sam Forstag, a Montana smokejumper and union organizer, describes wildfire-response cuts, housing pressures, public lands, and AI oversight as practical tests of Democratic credibility.

Forstag’s account shifts the debate from slogans to lived experience: Democrats, he argues, must address material problems before lecturing working-class voters about their interests.

What was said on this episode

68 statements · 12 positive · 49 negative · 1 mixed · 6 neutral

  1. Jon Favreauon Trump’s Iran warNegative4:38

    Trump is seeking a way to accept defeat in Iran

    “the president is desperately looking for a way to accept defeat in Iran”

    Listen at 4:38

  2. Trump’s administration has added 548,000 net jobs with very slow growth

    “Trump's administration has only added 548,000 net jobs so far, which is considered very slow growth.”

    Listen at 5:34

  3. Weak economic numbers will cause many Republican members of Congress to lose reelection

    “these are the types of numbers that will make a lot of Republican members of Congress lose their jobs come November.”

    Listen at 6:08

  4. Jon Lovetton Donald TrumpNegative6:17

    Trump’s job approval rating is 22 points underwater

    “Trump's net approval rating on jobs, he is now 22 points underwater”

    Listen at 6:17

  5. Jon Lovetton Donald TrumpNegative7:29

    Trump appears politically weak after the Iran war

    “Trump looks weak.”

    Listen at 7:29

  6. Jon Favreauon Iran and Strait of HormuzNegative8:01

    Iran is unlikely to reopen the Strait of Hormuz because it is leverage

    “I don't think the strait is going to be open because Iran has recognized correctly that this is their sole point of leverage now.”

    Listen at 8:01

  7. Jon Favreauon Further US strikes on IranNegative9:16

    Further US strikes are not supported by intelligence as a way to force Iranian negotiations.

    “there is no intelligence that said that any further US strikes would bring them to the negotiating table”

    Listen at 9:16

  8. Jon Lovetton Trump post-midterm Iran policyNegative11:16

    Losing the midterms could enable Trump to undertake drastic escalation

    “losing the midterm may weaken him politically, but might put him in a position to do something drastic and quite terrible.”

    Listen at 11:16

  9. Jon Favreauon Trump’s Iran warNegative11:42

    Trump may capitulate further after the midterms to end the war

    “you could see him doing that again after the midterms just to get it off his plate”

    Listen at 11:42

  10. Netanyahu is obstructing a viable two-state solution

    “Benjamin Netanyahu is the obstacle to that possibility”

    Listen at 16:27

  11. Jon Favreauon Israeli election and Palestinian statehoodNegative16:43

    Removing Netanyahu through an election may not fundamentally change the situation

    “I don't know that an election, even that gets rid of Netanyahu, is going to fundamentally change too much about that scenario”

    Listen at 16:43

  12. Jon Favreauon U.S. measles casesNegative20:48

    The United States exceeded its entire 2025 measles total by July

    “The U.S. passed all of 2025's measles total by July so far this year.”

    Listen at 20:48

  13. Jon Lovetton Splitting the MMR vaccineNegative21:29

    Splitting the MMR vaccine schedule causes mumps and rubella outbreaks.

    “what do you end up with? You end up with outbreaks of mumps and rubella. That's just what happens.”

    Listen at 21:29

  14. Jon Lovetton Split MMR vaccinationNegative21:30

    Splitting the MMR vaccine causes mumps and rubella outbreaks

    “You end up with outbreaks of mumps and rubella. That's just what happens.”

    Listen at 21:30

  15. Jon Lovetton VaccineNegative23:29

    Removing recommended vaccines will cause more children to contract hepatitis B

    “when you remove some of these vaccines and say, what could happen? Well, what's gonna happen is there's gonna be a bunch of kids that get hep B.”

    Listen at 23:29

  16. Jon Lovetton Delayed childhood vaccinationNegative23:49

    Delaying childhood vaccinations will cause some children serious injury or death

    “if you increase the window, if you cause more delays, if people don't show up to the doctor, inside of that group of kids are people that are gonna get hurt, maybe permanently injured, maybe die.”

    Listen at 23:49

  17. Jon Favreauon COVID vaccination and miscarriagePositive25:18

    Testing found no meaningful miscarriage safety problem with COVID vaccination

    “Then they tested it. Of course, it was like by the time it was widely available, like it was fine”

    Listen at 25:18

  18. Jon Lovetton COVID vaccine miscarriage riskPositive27:10

    COVID vaccination was not associated with a statistically significant miscarriage increase

    “there wasn't a spike. It didn't go above, there wasn't a statistically significant increase in miscarriages.”

    Listen at 27:10

  19. Jon Lovetton Modern childhood vaccinesPositive28:21

    Modern childhood vaccines contain about one-tenth the antigens of an older pertussis shot

    “the dozen or so vaccines that kids will get in early childhood today actually have less, far less, like a 10th as much of the kind of antigens that was in one pertussis shot 30 years ago.”

    Listen at 28:21

  20. Jon Lovetton Todd BlancheNegative32:24

    Blanche oversaw unprecedented politicization of the Justice Department

    “he has now put forward as his Attorney General nomination someone who oversaw the politicization of the Justice Department unlike anything before in American history”

    Listen at 32:24

  21. Jon Lovetton Bill CassidyNegative33:33

    Bill Cassidy surrendered his Senate leverage to Donald Trump during the attorney-general confirmation.

    “he completely gave up that power to Donald Trump”

    Listen at 33:33

  22. Republican senators had substantial power to impose conditions on Blanche

    “They had so much power.”

    Listen at 34:46

  23. Jon Lovetton Senate restrictions on IRS settlementsPositive35:05

    Republican senators could have legally restricted future IRS settlements.

    “They could have, in law, they could have passed a law that said no settlement with the IRS could carry forward into the future”

    Listen at 35:05

  24. Jon Favreauon Republican midterm strategyPositive37:44

    Republicans believe exploiting Democratic infighting is their best midterm strategy

    “Republicans are betting that their only chance to win the midterms now is to capitalize on the Democratic infighting”

    Listen at 37:44

  25. Jon Lovetton Republican anti-Democratic messagingNegative39:35

    Republican attacks portraying Democrats as extreme are fearmongering

    “I don't, because one is a fearmongering message about Democrats trying to make every Democrat sound like the craziest thing people saw on the internet.”

    Listen at 39:35

  26. Jon Lovetton Roe v. WadeNegative39:56

    Republicans cannot campaign away responsibility for overturning Roe.

    “there's no campaigning that they can do to, uh, defuse the fact that they overturned Roe.”

    Listen at 39:56

  27. Jon Favreauon Republican extremism messagingPositive41:50

    Extremism attacks may influence inattentive voters at the margins

    “on the margins, for, you know, voters who aren't paying attention until they go cast a ballot, could this work? Maybe.”

    Listen at 41:50

  28. Jon Lovetton Right-wing political messagingNegative42:12

    The political right makes extreme Republicans appear reasonable and Democrats extreme

    “It is, from the right, is an effort to make extreme Republicans seem reasonable and reasonable Democrats seem extreme”

    Listen at 42:12

  29. Francesca Hong would need to reassure voters about public safety

    “she's going to have to if she's the nominee, reassurance of people that she cares about public safety”

    Listen at 44:25

  30. Candidates should probably avoid calling themselves socialists

    “That's why you probably shouldn't call yourself a socialist, right?”

    Listen at 46:31

  31. Jon Favreauon Democratic ideological labelsNegative47:41

    Ideological labels are not helpful for Democratic candidates.

    “the labeling doesn't seem like it's helpful in, in, in any way, shape, or form.”

    Listen at 47:41

  32. Jon Lovetton “Woke One Was Crazy”Negative50:08

    “Woke One Was Crazy” is broadly accurate about excesses of the 2020-era left.

    “it has the benefit of just being kind of true.”

    Listen at 50:08

  33. Jon Favreauon Political persuasionPositive54:32

    Persuasion is more effective than public shaming for political change

    “the most effective way is to try to like bring people along, to persuade them.”

    Listen at 54:32

  34. Jon Lovetton Looting during protestsNegative58:51

    Looting is morally wrong because it harms businesses and workers

    “because looting is wrong, because that business being destroyed hurts the people that work there, the people that own that business”

    Listen at 58:51

  35. Jon Favreauon Political apologies and changed positionsPositive1:00:24

    Political leaders should welcome changed views and apologies

    “changing your mind is good, apologies are good, recognizing that past positions weren't the best is good.”

    Listen at 1:00:24

  36. Jon Lovetton Abolish the police sloganNegative1:02:38

    Lovett rejects abolishing police and regrets embracing that slogan

    “I don't wanna abolish the police. I think that that's dumb and I regret embracing it as a slogan because it doesn't actually capture what I think.”

    Listen at 1:02:38

  37. Jon Lovetton Tom TiffanyNegative1:05:44

    Tom Tiffany denies the legitimacy of elections.

    “Tom Tiffany is an election denier.”

    Listen at 1:05:44

  38. Jon Lovetton Wisconsin votersNegative1:05:59

    Wisconsin voters do not want an election-denying Republican candidate.

    “The Republicans are not doing that. Tom Tiffany, the voters of Wisconsin do not want an election denier.”

    Listen at 1:05:59

  39. Jon Lovetton WNBANegative1:12:26

    Transgender women seeking WNBA participation should undergo transition.

    “if they would like to play in the WNBA, they better fucking transition.”

    Listen at 1:12:26

  40. Jon Favreauon WNBA eligibility rulesNeutral1:12:47

    WNBA rules do not make eligibility based solely on self-identification

    “nothing in the rules says that.”

    Listen at 1:12:47

  41. Jon Lovetton Tucker CarlsonNegative1:15:27

    Tucker Carlson has hosted Holocaust deniers and embraced antisemitic conspiracy theories.

    “Tucker Carlson has had Holocaust deniers on his show. He has embraced a whole host of antisemitic conspiracy theories.”

    Listen at 1:15:27

  42. Sam Forstagon Federal wildfire-service cutsNegative1:23:34

    Federal wildfire-service cuts hampered public safety

    “public safety was hampered.”

    Listen at 1:23:34

  43. Sam Forstagon Federal wildfire-service cutsNegative1:24:06

    Federal wildfire-service cuts lengthen wildfire suppression efforts.

    “it takes longer to fight those fires.”

    Listen at 1:24:06

  44. Sam Forstagon Wildfire response resourcesNegative1:24:06

    Reduced wildfire resources lengthen firefighting operations

    “it takes longer to fight those fires”

    Listen at 1:24:06

  45. Sam Forstagon Wildfire-service privatizationNegative1:24:30

    Wildfire-service cuts and privatization aim to create private profit

    “the real goal here was cuts and privatization to turn it into another source of profit.”

    Listen at 1:24:30

  46. Sam Forstagon Western MontanaNegative1:26:03

    Western Montana has the least affordable housing market nationally

    “we have the least affordable housing market in the country”

    Listen at 1:26:03

  47. Sam Forstagon MontanaNegative1:26:21

    Average home prices approach $600,000 in Missoula and $900,000 in Bozeman

    “in Missoula, it's just shy of $600K. You go to Bozeman, it's around $900,000”

    Listen at 1:26:21

  48. Sam Forstagon MontanaNegative1:26:39

    Average Montana childcare costs approach $19,000

    “The average cost of childcare is just shy of $19K”

    Listen at 1:26:39

  49. Sam Forstagon MontanaNegative1:27:22

    Homelessness doubled or tripled in every major Montana city over five years

    “homelessness just doubled or tripled in every major city in Montana over the preceding 5 years”

    Listen at 1:27:22

  50. Sam Forstagon Montana DemocratsPositive1:29:45

    Montana Democrats have won despite Trump gaining power

    “Democrats have found a way in Montana to win even when Donald Trump is gaining power.”

    Listen at 1:29:45

  51. Sam Forstagon MontanaNeutral1:29:50

    18,000 Montanans split their 2024 votes between Trump and Tester.

    “18,000 Montanans voted for Donald Trump and Jon Tester in 2024.”

    Listen at 1:29:50

  52. Sam Forstagon Democratic PartyNegative1:32:09

    The Democratic Party is no longer the party of working people

    “we are now quite literally not the party of working people.”

    Listen at 1:32:09

  53. Sam Forstagon Working-class votersNegative1:32:12

    Most working people earning under $100,000 voted Republican

    “Most working people, most folks making under $100K just voted for Republicans.”

    Listen at 1:32:12

  54. The federal government’s primary role is protecting constitutional freedoms

    “there are 2 primary roles for the federal government. First and foremost, it's to protect your constitutional freedoms”

    Listen at 1:34:38

  55. The federal government should meet basic needs when markets fail

    “Second, it's to make sure you can meet your basic material needs when the market is not meeting them.”

    Listen at 1:34:45

  56. Montana Republicans repeatedly invested in top-income tax cuts

    “they invested in tax cuts to cut the top income tax bracket year after year after year”

    Listen at 1:37:43

  57. Much Inflation Reduction Act funding was not disbursed.

    “a whole lot of that money never actually got out the door”

    Listen at 1:40:21

  58. Sam Forstagon MontanaNegative1:40:38

    Kathy’s mobile-home lot rent rose from $370 to over $800 monthly

    “Kathy's lot rent has gone from $370 a month to over $800.”

    Listen at 1:40:38

  59. Sam Forstagon Data CenterNegative1:41:56

    Federal law should require data centers to provide their own power

    “we need to pass a damn law at the federal level saying they can't build these things until and unless they show that they're gonna provide all their own power.”

    Listen at 1:41:56

  60. Sam Forstagon Data-center developmentNeutral1:42:18

    The data-center industry plans to spend $4 trillion over seven years

    “They're planning to spend $4 trillion on data center development in the next 7 years.”

    Listen at 1:42:18

  61. Artificial intelligence may be the country’s biggest existential threat

    “this technology is perhaps the biggest existential threat that we've got as a country.”

    Listen at 1:42:32

  62. AI could cure cancer or cause human extinction.

    “this is a technology that could cure cancer or it could kill all of humanity.”

    Listen at 1:42:44

  63. Sam Forstagon Artificial intelligence regulationNegative1:43:05

    Artificial intelligence currently lacks effective oversight and regulation

    “There's no oversight or regulation of this right now, functionally speaking.”

    Listen at 1:43:05

  64. Sam Forstagon Artificial intelligence regulationNegative1:43:19

    Failure to regulate AI will create serious future problems

    “we're going to be in a tough spot.”

    Listen at 1:43:19

  65. Jon Lovetton Montana independent Senate candidatePositive1:43:50

    The Democratic candidate should withdraw so voters can unite behind the independent.

    “so that everyone can coalesce around the independent candidate.”

    Listen at 1:43:50

  66. Sam Forstagon Montana Senate raceNegative1:44:35

    Two competing candidates cannot defeat the Republican while both remain in the race

    “neither candidate's going to have a chance of winning against the Republican as long as they're both in this race.”

    Listen at 1:44:35

  67. Sam Forstagon Montana political issuesNeutral1:47:15

    Gun rights and public lands protection are consensus issues in Montana

    “protecting your gun rights and protecting your public lands, those are the 2 consensus issues in a place like Montana”

    Listen at 1:47:15

  68. Sam Forstagon Montana wildfire staffingNegative1:48:04

    Montana wildfire staffing fell 20%, losing 2,000 qualified firefighters

    “we're down 20%, we've lost 2,000 red-carded firefighters.”

    Listen at 1:48:04

Statements are attributed to the speaker as said on the episode and reflect their view at the time, not PodLume's. They are not advice.

Weekly email

State of the Pod, every Monday

The week's most-discussed names and stories from podcasts, with the moments behind them. Free, five minutes, unsubscribe in one click.

Listen to the full episode and explore every guest, topic, and moment on PodLume.