The Megyn Kelly Show
The Megyn Kelly Show

Oct 19, 2026 · 1h 42m

Listen from 1:13:59

Listen at 1:13:59

DNA claims intensify scrutiny of Ilhan Omar’s family history

The Ilhan Omar Brother and Sister Mystery, Plus Key "You Can See Everything" Reference, and Victoria's Secret Fashion Show Uproar | Ep. 1421

The episode examines unresolved allegations about Ilhan Omar’s marriages, immigration history, and family relationships while distinguishing reported claims from substantiated facts.

3 key takeaways
  1. 1Preya Samson details reporting on Omar’s marriages, family relationships, and the records underlying longstanding allegations.
  2. 2The discussion considers whether DNA evidence could clarify disputed relationships and potential immigration fraud claims.
  3. 3Megyn Kelly also questions allegations involving Kimberly Guilfoyle and Katie Zakaria’s legal credentials and White House role.

Don't miss

Preya Samson explains how reported DNA collection could potentially resolve longstanding questions about Ilhan Omar’s family relationships.

The brief

Megyn Kelly opens with the Elizabeth Holmes documentary, then pivots to reports that federal agents obtained DNA from Ilhan Omar’s family through a dumpster search.

Guest Preya Samson explains her investigation into Omar’s marriages, naturalization records, family relationships, and the allegations surrounding Ahmed Nur Said Elmi.

The central question is whether genetic evidence and preserved social-media posts could clarify disputed family connections, while critics frame the inquiry as an attack on immigrants and people of color.

The episode then turns to unsubstantiated allegations involving Kimberly Guilfoyle, with Kelly stressing that defamatory claims could bring legal consequences.

A final segment scrutinizes Katie Zakaria’s White House briefing, preparation claims, and distinction between attending law school, passing the bar, and practicing law.

What was said on this episode

47 statements · 14 positive · 27 negative · 6 neutral

  1. Megyn recommends watching the Elizabeth Holmes documentary.

    “go see it. I think it's worth your time.”

    Listen at 0:26

  2. Megyn Kellyon Federal investigation into Ilhan Omar’s family relationshipsNeutral8:53

    DNA collection indicates investigators are examining Omar family relationships.

    “A DNA dumpster dive definitely means that they were. that they're looking into the familial relations”

    Listen at 8:53

  3. Megyn Kellyon Ilhan OmarNegative8:57

    Megyn says investigators are examining Omar family relationships and possible fraud.

    “they're looking into the familial relations and trying to figure out once and for all, what's what, like what really is what, who's, who is related to whom, who married whom, and just how widespread is the fraud inside of this family.”

    Listen at 8:57

  4. Megyn Kellyon Ilhan Omar investigationNeutral17:57

    The investigation into Ilhan Omar began during Joe Biden’s administration.

    “the investigation into Ilhan Omar began under Joe Biden”

    Listen at 17:57

  5. Megyn Kellyon Ilhan OmarNegative20:07

    Megyn says Omar should leave the country if she is not a verified citizen.

    “If she is not a citizen, she's not a valid, verified U.S. citizen, she needs to go.”

    Listen at 20:07

  6. Megyn Kellyon Ilhan OmarNegative20:15

    Ilhan Omar should be imprisoned if she committed harmful immigration fraud.

    “if she did commit immigration fraud that hurt people, she should go into prison”

    Listen at 20:15

  7. Preya says records showed marriage-license requests involving Omar’s ex-husband and alleged brother.

    “what we ended up finding were that there were two marriage uh license requests one for her now ex-husband um and then one for her brother who has been identified”

    Listen at 23:38

  8. Preya says Omar’s marriage arrangements raised concerns.

    “That started raising red flags.”

    Listen at 25:59

  9. Preya says available reporting does not suggest Omar and her father lacked naturalization.

    “there's nothing to suggest that they haven't been naturalized. That has never been the question at hand.”

    Listen at 29:03

  10. Preya Samsundaron Ilhan Omar and her father’s naturalizationPositive29:03

    Preya says available reporting does not suggest Omar and her father lacked naturalization.

    “there's nothing to suggest that they haven't been naturalized”

    Listen at 29:03

  11. Preya Samsundaron U.S. refugee naturalization processNeutral30:04

    Preya says it is uncertain whether administrations expedited naturalizations then.

    “whether or not they were fast tracking naturalizations at that point, we're not entirely sure.”

    Listen at 30:04

  12. Preya Samsundaron Ilhan Omar investigationPositive32:45

    Preya characterizes the Omar investigation as evidence-driven rather than partisan.

    “This is not by any means a political witch hunt. This is about looking at where the evidence is leading them.”

    Listen at 32:45

  13. Preya Samsundaron Ilhan Omar investigationPositive32:45

    Preya assesses the Omar investigation as evidence-driven rather than politically motivated.

    “This is not by any means a political witch hunt. This is about looking at where the evidence is leading them.”

    Listen at 32:45

  14. Preya Samsundaron Ilhan Omar investigationNeutral34:01

    Preya speculates Biden officials reopened scrutiny to resolve the Omar allegations.

    “My guess is that the Biden administration decided to pull the string a little bit, maybe to close the books on this once and for all”

    Listen at 34:01

  15. Preya says Omar’s marriage appeared akin to green-card fraud.

    “I think anybody who had done some digging into Ilhan at the time, I think that they would have discovered that this would have been something akin to green card fraud, a scam green card marriage.”

    Listen at 37:36

  16. Preya assesses Omar’s marriage as potentially fraudulent for green-card purposes.

    “this would have been something akin to green card fraud, a scam green card marriage”

    Listen at 37:44

  17. Preya Samsundaron DNA testing of Omar familyPositive38:45

    Preya says DNA testing could establish Omar family relationships.

    “we've tested the dna and we can link these individuals as members of the same family having the same bloodline”

    Listen at 38:45

  18. Preya Samsundaron DNA testing of Ilhan Omar’s familyPositive38:47

    DNA testing could establish that Omar and relatives share a family bloodline.

    “we can link these individuals as members of the same family having the same bloodline”

    Listen at 38:47

  19. Preya Samsundaron Immigration law violationsNegative41:27

    Preya recommends legal consequences for immigrants who break U.S. laws.

    “if you're breaking the laws of this country, then you should face the consequences.”

    Listen at 41:27

  20. Preya Samsundaron Ilhan Omar’s alleged marriage to Ahmed ElmiNegative45:37

    Somali community members discussed allegations that Ilhan Omar married her brother.

    “members of the Somali community were talking about this in great lengths, about Ilhan Omar marrying her brother”

    Listen at 45:37

  21. Preya Samsundaron Social-media evidence concerning Ilhan Omar’s familyNegative50:40

    Preya expected social-media evidence to disappear after reporting began.

    “things were going to start moving and things were going to start disappearing very quickly”

    Listen at 50:40

  22. Donald Trump fired Kimberly Guilfoyle as ambassador to Greece.

    “the president asked her, well, he fired her”

    Listen at 52:31

  23. Guilfoyle is accused of using her ambassadorship for luxury travel and hospitality.

    “she grifted and that she used the position to sort of get private jet air travel, very fancy hotel rooms, fancy dinners all over Greece”

    Listen at 56:39

  24. Kimberly Guilfoyle is being investigated by the State Department inspector general.

    “she's being investigated by the State Department IG”

    Listen at 59:04

  25. Megyn says investigators can determine whether Guilfoyle took bribes as ambassador.

    “whether she took bribes, whether she was doing her bidding versus ours while ambassador to Greece”

    Listen at 1:07:25

  26. Megyn says Guilfoyle previously demonstrated commitment to justice and worked as a San Francisco DA.

    “she did have a commitment to justice when she went to law school, and she was a young DA in San Francisco”

    Listen at 1:10:58

  27. Megyn Kellyon Media industryNegative1:11:36

    Megyn says the media industry can corrupt participants independently of politics.

    “that industry can be corrupting itself, separate and apart from politics.”

    Listen at 1:11:36

  28. Megyn Kellyon Fame and political proximityNegative1:11:57

    Megyn argues fame and proximity to politicians can erode ethical judgment.

    “You can lose your moral tether. You can start making compromised decisions.”

    Listen at 1:11:57

  29. Megyn Kellyon Political environmentNegative1:12:19

    Megyn says immersion around politicians can corrupt people.

    “it can be corrupting.”

    Listen at 1:12:19

  30. Megyn Kellyon Katie ZakariaNegative1:13:59

    Reports broadly claim Susie Wiles arranged for Katie Zakaria to fail.

    “the reports are pretty universal that it was Susie Wiles who set her up to fail”

    Listen at 1:13:59

  31. Megyn Kellyon Katie Zakaria White House briefingNegative1:16:30

    Megyn assesses Katie Zakaria’s White House briefing as unsuccessful.

    “that did not go well.”

    Listen at 1:16:30

  32. Megyn Kellyon Presenting oneself as a lawyer without passing the barNegative1:17:46

    Megyn says people should not present themselves as lawyers without passing the bar exam.

    “every lawyer knows that you don't hold yourself out as a lawyer, an attorney, whatever you want to call yourself, unless you've passed the bar exam”

    Listen at 1:17:46

  33. Megyn Kellyon Donald Trump and Katie ZakariaNegative1:18:00

    Megyn says Trump apparently believed Zakaria was an attorney.

    “President Trump appears to have been fooled by this line.”

    Listen at 1:18:00

  34. Megyn Kellyon Katie ZachariaNegative1:19:37

    Megyn says Zakaria had to leave the press-secretary role.

    “she had to go.”

    Listen at 1:19:37

  35. Megyn Kellyon Donald Trump’s selection of Katie ZakariaNegative1:20:33

    Megyn assesses Trump’s selection of Katie Zakaria as a rare hiring mistake.

    “this just seems to have been a misfire and a rare one for him for this particular role”

    Listen at 1:20:33

  36. Megyn recommends a combative style for the next White House press secretary.

    “We want to see the press secretary put the press in their place.”

    Listen at 1:21:56

  37. Megyn Kellyon Next White House press secretary selectionPositive1:22:09

    Megyn predicts the next press-secretary selection will be better.

    “hopefully that's a very short chapter. We'll get past it and we'll do better on the next selection.”

    Listen at 1:22:09

  38. Megyn Kellyon Victoria’s Secret use of obese modelsNegative1:26:39

    Megyn rejects obese models as Victoria’s Secret brand representatives.

    “the notion that we have to have obese angels at the Victoria's Secret fashion show or as the face of the brand was absurd from the start and remains so”

    Listen at 1:26:39

  39. Megyn says Victoria’s Secret moved away from obese models for a reason.

    “There is a reason they moved past that.”

    Listen at 1:26:49

  40. The Victoria’s Secret fantasy bra is valued at $50 million.

    “it is a $50 million creation by Jacob. Arabo of Jake and Co.”

    Listen at 1:27:46

  41. Megyn Kellyon Men’s body preferencesNeutral1:31:36

    Megyn says men generally prefer fuller-bodied figures over anorexic ones.

    “Men don't like anorexic figures.”

    Listen at 1:31:36

  42. Megyn Kellyon Women’s clothing and sexual abuseNegative1:33:16

    Megyn rejects the claim that women’s clothing causes sexual abuse.

    “what a woman wears. leads to sexual abuse, which is an old trope I thought we got rid of”

    Listen at 1:33:16

  43. Megyn Kellyon Sexy lingeriePositive1:35:25

    Megyn says sexy lingerie can increase a woman’s feeling of sexiness.

    “the sexy lingerie that makes a woman feel more sexy”

    Listen at 1:35:25

  44. Megyn Kellyon Perceptions of female sexinessNeutral1:36:53

    Megyn says women generally share men’s preferences about female sexiness.

    “what men find sexy on a woman, most women do too.”

    Listen at 1:36:53

  45. Megyn Kellyon Clothing and sexual assaultNegative1:38:54

    Megyn says clothing does not cause sexual assault.

    “It doesn't matter what the Victoria's Secret models are wearing. It doesn't matter. what Jane Doe was wearing.”

    Listen at 1:38:54

  46. Megyn Kellyon Cornell sexual encounterNegative1:39:38

    Megyn attributes the Cornell sexual encounter to changing sexual attitudes.

    “It happened because she thought that attitudes around sex and sexuality are changing.”

    Listen at 1:39:38

  47. Megyn Kellyon Women displaying their bodies at fashion showsPositive1:40:15

    Megyn endorses women displaying their bodies in appropriate fashion settings.

    “allowing women to lean into showing off their body parts in an appropriate setting”

    Listen at 1:40:15

Statements are attributed to the speaker as said on the episode and reflect their view at the time, not PodLume's. They are not advice.

Weekly email

State of the Pod, every Monday

The week's most-discussed names and stories from podcasts, with the moments behind them. Free, five minutes, unsubscribe in one click.

Listen to the full episode and explore every guest, topic, and moment on PodLume.