
Sep 8, 2026 · 1h 41m
Listen from 1:24:06
Listen at 1:24:06
Hanson and Kelly debate MAGA’s next chapter
Lindsay Clancy Wants a PARDON, Plus Violent Leftists as Charlie Kirk Anniversary Approaches, and the Future of MAGA, with Victor Davis Hanson | Ep. 1393
The episode links a high-profile criminal case to broader arguments about political violence, cultural conflict, Republican strategy, and economic frustration.
- 1The Lindsay Clancy mistrial exposes competing claims about mental illness, accountability, deterrence, and the limits of a pardon request.
- 2Victor Davis Hanson argues that Trump transformed the Republican Party while J.D. Vance could help define its succession and direction.
- 3The conversation treats inflation, immigration, universities, Iran, and political violence as tests of conservative credibility before the midterms.
Don't miss
Hanson and Kelly debate whether the Clancy pardon request was legally viable or shifted into an appeal for Trump’s influence.
The brief
Megyn Kelly opens with the Lindsay Clancy mistrial and pardon request, questioning the defense’s legal theory, the insanity argument, and what accountability should require.
Victor Davis Hanson joins the discussion, arguing that therapeutic responses to horrific violence can weaken deterrence while ideological movements increasingly normalize attacks on opponents.
The conversation widens to abortion, gender ideology, immigration, national identity, Iran, and the competing interventionist and non-interventionist currents inside the Republican Party.
Hanson casts Donald Trump as the figure who remade the GOP and considers whether J.D. Vance, Marco Rubio, or Ron DeSantis could shape what follows.
They close on inflation, midterm vulnerability, Charlie Kirk’s counter-revolution, and universities accused of replacing teaching with ideological activism.
What was said on this episode
64 statements · 18 positive · 39 negative · 1 mixed · 6 neutral
President Trump cannot pardon a state crime.
“President Trump can't pardon that.”
Listen at 2:03
Mental illness alone does not excuse criminal behavior.
“Mental illness does not excuse you from criminal behavior.”
Listen at 11:19
Legal insanity requires meeting an extremely high standard.
“It has to rise to the level of legal insanity, which is a nearly impossible standard.”
Listen at 11:23
Lindsay Clancy knew what she was doing during the killings.
“She knew exactly what she was doing.”
Listen at 12:16
A plea deal should require Lindsay Clancy to plead guilty to voluntary manslaughter.
“that deal, I think, is going to have to involve a guilty plea by your client to at least voluntary manslaughter.”
Listen at 12:57
Corey Walsh’s son might be alive without coverage of the Clancy case.
“I think he would be alive.”
Listen at 16:33
Reporting specific suicide methods can encourage imitation.
“it is suggestive and it is a little contagious.”
Listen at 16:55
Sympathetic coverage of child murder may encourage similar crimes.
“The more we talk about this kind of murder in a way that has anything other than abject contempt for the perpetrator, the more we encourage it”
Listen at 17:27
Social condemnation, shame, and law deter people from wrongdoing.
“if people believe there's no deterrence. That's really the only thing that stops people from doing bad things, whether it's social opprobrium or shame or law.”
Listen at 25:26
Normalizing violent acts may encourage distressed parents to commit them without fearing consequences.
“if you channel that this is acceptable, then anybody who feels that the burdens of child rearing or they get depressed one day, then there's a message that they can do some dastardly, horrific act and not pay the price for it.”
Listen at 25:36
The legal insanity defense has a narrow definition.
“that's a very careful, narrow definition.”
Listen at 26:04
Clancy supporters portray child-rearing as exclusively the mother’s domain.
“child rearing is entirely in the domain and child procreation of the mother.”
Listen at 26:45
Society may excuse mothers who harm children after postpartum depression.
“The society at large is going to give her an exemption if she were to do something to the children.”
Listen at 30:03
Coverage of Clancy may make child-killing seem like a coping option to struggling mothers.
“Mothers out there who are struggling, who before wouldn't have even considered this, have now added it to the menu of coping.”
Listen at 30:31
Donald Trump is the first U.S. president whose Secret Service returned fire four times.
“Donald Trump is the first president in U.S. history that the Secret Service had to return fire at a potential assassin on four different occasions.”
Listen at 34:00
Violent left-wing rhetoric is becoming increasingly mainstream.
“this is not necessarily a fringe anymore. It's getting more and more mainstream.”
Listen at 35:49
Society permits abortion of fully formed viable fetuses late in pregnancy.
“that same society allows you to kill a fully formed, viable baby. At the last moment”
Listen at 37:17
No one currently appears capable of replacing Charlie Kirk’s political talent.
“he's not going to be replaced. I don't see anybody on the horizon that has that talent, at least not yet.”
Listen at 39:50
Transgender shooters are overrepresented among mass shooters.
“the percentage of trans shooters in mass shootings. It's way overrepresented.”
Listen at 41:38
Gender transition is not biologically possible, according to Kelly.
“There's no such thing as trans. That's not a thing. You can't transition your gender.”
Listen at 42:01
People identifying as transgender should instead be described as gender-confused men or women.
“that person's gender confused. It's a man who's gender confused.”
Listen at 42:29
Hanson claims 45% of Canada’s population is foreign-born or has foreign-born parents.
“45% of the Canadian population was either not born in the United States or their parents were not born.”
Listen at 47:20
Canada’s centennial initiative seeks 100 million people through immigration within 15–20 years.
“they want to get 100 million people in the next 15 years or 20 years through immigration”
Listen at 47:29
“it's a $7 trillion difference that we invested.”
Listen at 48:33
The Republican Party will not return to its pre-Trump form.
“I don't see us going back to the old Republican Party”
Listen at 56:02
A return to the old Republican free-trade agenda will not be politically viable.
“I don't think it's going to be viable to any of that stuff.”
Listen at 58:11
J.D. Vance is the leading prospective successor within MAGA.
“So it's going to be Vance is the head runner.”
Listen at 58:23
J.D. Vance is the leading prospective Republican successor to Trump.
“it's going to be Vance is the head runner.”
Listen at 58:23
J.D. Vance’s vice presidency strengthens the president’s political power.
“this is one of the few vice presidencies. that is a force multiplier of the president.”
Listen at 59:09
J.D. Vance is aligned with the MAGA movement.
“Vance is going... He is a MAGA person.”
Listen at 59:37
The United States cannot win a war against Iran without deploying ground troops.
“There's no winning a war against Iran unless we go full boots on the ground”
Listen at 1:04:02
Economic sanctions against Iran are working better than military escalation.
“And by all reports, even amongst the far left haters. It's working. It's working a lot better.”
Listen at 1:04:14
Iranian actors will likely launch an October-surprise missile attack before the election.
“they're going to try an October surprise probably a week before the election”
Listen at 1:04:25
A successful Iranian popular demonstration could rapidly transform the country.
“if there should be another demonstration, but this time successful. And I remember when the Berlin Wall fell, two years it took the Soviet Union and six months for most of Eastern Europe. That could change everything.”
Listen at 1:04:43
Economic pressure can impoverish and constrain Iran’s leaders.
“But you can squeeze them into poverty, and that's what we're doing.”
Listen at 1:07:21
Economic pressure can force Iran into poverty.
“you can squeeze them into poverty, and that's what we're doing.”
Listen at 1:07:21
Only six Latin American or Caribbean countries remain anti-American and nondemocratic.
“And now there's only six.”
Listen at 1:07:49
The president’s party has lost seats in 39 of the last 41 midterm elections.
“39 out of the last 41 midterms, the end party loses seats.”
Listen at 1:10:11
Republicans face a difficult 2026 midterm election.
“they're going to be in a tough fight for the midterms.”
Listen at 1:10:27
Republicans will likely retain the Senate but may lose the House.
“I think they'll keep the Senate. I'm not sure about the House”
Listen at 1:12:57
Historical patterns make Republican midterm success unlikely.
“historically, all the odds are against it.”
Listen at 1:15:06
China’s GDP is $10 trillion smaller than the United States despite four times its population.
“China has four times the population. It's $10 trillion smaller still. We're $31 trillion. They're $21 trillion.”
Listen at 1:16:47
Crime is currently at a historical low.
“crime is at a historical low”
Listen at 1:17:11
The Trump administration has deported three million people.
“they've deported 3 million people”
Listen at 1:17:13
U.S. inflation will probably be about 3% this year.
“probably 3% this year”
Listen at 1:17:36
Trump has reduced the inflation rate without reversing prior price increases.
“You can turn down the rate of inflation, which Trump has done.”
Listen at 1:18:16
The prior 20% price increase cannot be reversed.
“there's no way we can undo 20%.”
Listen at 1:18:41
Republicans should have promised to halve inflation rather than reverse price increases.
“What they should have said, we're going to half inflation.”
Listen at 1:18:57
U.S. homeownership is currently about 63%, near its historical average.
“62% is the historical average. It's 63.”
Listen at 1:19:50
Crime is historically low and labor-force participation is approximately 64–65%.
“crime is at a historical low, and labor participation is a little up, actually. It's about 65%, 64%.”
Listen at 1:20:08
The U.S. military recruited 50,000 people in one year and now has excess soldiers.
“We have completely in one year got 50,000 people out of the woodwork that are now enrolled. We have no recruitment problem. We have a problem that we have excess soldiers.”
Listen at 1:21:06
The modern Democratic Party differs fundamentally from Bill Clinton’s party.
“this is not Bill Clinton's Democrats”
Listen at 1:22:30
The Democratic Party has adopted a socialist agenda.
“the Democratic Party had gone socialist”
Listen at 1:23:34
The university Hanson works at no longer resembles the institution he attended.
“The university that I work at is... bears no resemblance whatsoever with the universe that I went there to get a PhD.”
Listen at 1:24:06
University scholarship has become completely mediocre.
“the scholarship is completely mediocre.”
Listen at 1:24:37
Stanford and Yale now award A grades to 80% of students.
“Stanford, Yale now give 80% A's”
Listen at 1:26:16
U.S. university students or graduates hold approximately $1.7 trillion in debt.
“the university has been a toll I think $1.7 trillion in debt”
Listen at 1:27:54
Donald Trump is succeeding in reversing progressive institutional changes.
“He's winning the counter-revolution”
Listen at 1:30:54
Donald Trump is making progress against progressive institutions.
“he is making progress.”
Listen at 1:33:39
Stanford admitted white males at an 8% rate over the last four years.
“They only let 8% white males in the last four years”
Listen at 1:33:52
Public confidence in higher education has fallen from 65% to 34%.
“34% of the people now have confidence in higher education. It used to be 65.”
Listen at 1:36:32
Elite university attendance no longer provides meaningful value.
“Going to Harvard or Yale or Princeton or Stanford doesn't mean anything anymore. I don't think it does.”
Listen at 1:36:42
A self-employed gutter installer reported earning $240,000 after materials.
“I had a bad year. I only made $240,000.”
Listen at 1:38:23
Mark Carney’s anti-American policies will harm Canada economically.
“It's going to be bad, bad, bad economically.”
Listen at 1:40:16
Statements are attributed to the speaker as said on the episode and reflect their view at the time, not PodLume's. They are not advice.
Books & mentions
Some links are affiliate links — PodLume may earn a commission if you buy.
Weekly email
State of the Pod, every Monday
The week's most-discussed names and stories from podcasts, with the moments behind them. Free, five minutes, unsubscribe in one click.
