Modern Value Investing with Sven Carlin

Listen from 0:56

Listen at 0:56

Hermès still commands a premium after its 50% fall

Hermes Stocks is Not Yet Cheap, Despite The Quality!

The episode tests whether Hermès’s brand strength and financial quality can justify a valuation that remains high amid weaker luxury demand.

3 key takeaways
  1. 1Hermès retains exceptional pricing power, financial strength, and long-term growth potential despite softer luxury demand.
  2. 2A 1.3% dividend yield, limited buybacks, possible dilution, and modest shareholder returns weaken the investment case.
  3. 3Brand scarcity and resale strength do not, in Sven Carlin’s view, justify paying nearly 30 times earnings.

Don't miss

Carlin contrasts Hermès’s exceptional scarcity and pricing power with a near-30 earnings multiple to argue that quality does not justify any price.

The brief

Sven Carlin frames Hermès as a value-investing test: a stock down more than 50% from its peak may look cheaper without being cheap.

Hermès combines exceptional brand power, pricing strength, financial resilience, and long-term growth potential with weaker luxury demand, including softness in the Middle East and Asia’s importance.

Carlin argues that modest capital needs do not automatically improve the case when the dividend yield is only 1.3%, buybacks are limited, and dilution remains possible.

The episode’s sharpest tension is between Hermès’s scarcity and resale strength and a valuation near 30 times earnings, which Carlin says still demands too much.

By modeling higher dividend yields under slower-growth assumptions, Carlin concludes that Hermès may need to fall further before value investors can call it a bargain.

What was said on this episode

14 statements · 3 positive · 8 negative · 1 mixed · 2 neutral

  1. Sven Carlinon HermèsNegative0:23

    Hermès stock has fallen more than 50% from its peak.

    “the stock price, it's down more than 50% from the peak”

    Listen at 0:23

  2. Sven Carlinon HermèsMixed0:56

    Hermès still has 6% growth despite its stock falling 50%.

    “We still have growth rates, 6% growth, but the stock is 50% down.”

    Listen at 0:56

  3. Sven Carlinon Hermès salesNeutral1:19

    Visiting Asians likely account for about half of Hermès’s non-Asian sales.

    “this is an Asian luxury purchasing stock and likely half of the sales in the rest of the world are from visiting Asians”

    Listen at 1:19

  4. Sven Carlinon Hermès balance sheetPositive2:12

    Hermès has very little debt relative to shareholder equity.

    “Very little debt compared to shareholder equity. Great, staggering balance sheet.”

    Listen at 2:12

  5. Sven Carlinon Hermès capital expenditureNeutral2:53

    Hermès capital expenditure is about 20% of net income.

    “20% of net income”

    Listen at 2:53

  6. Sven Carlinon Hermès dividend yieldNegative3:22

    Hermès’s dividend yield is currently 1.3% after the stock’s 50% decline.

    “Dividend yield now 1.3%, 50% down and 1.3%.”

    Listen at 3:22

  7. Sven Carlinon Hermès dividend yieldNegative3:46

    Hermès would warrant a 3–5% dividend yield under slower growth.

    “For this company, at least, especially if we are medium to slower growth scenario ahead, 3 to 5% yield.”

    Listen at 3:46

  8. Sven Carlinon HermèsNegative3:56
    “the price 320. That's still 80% down.”

    Listen at 3:56

  9. Sven Carlinon HermèsNegative4:07

    A 3% yield scenario implies a Hermès share price of 500, 60% below current levels.

    “3% dividend yield, 16 times 3, 500. The stock price, still just 60%.”

    Listen at 4:07

  10. Sven Carlinon Hermès growth cycleNegative4:24

    Hermès’s exceptional growth and market cycle will eventually end.

    “everything must end at some point”

    Listen at 4:24

  11. Sven Carlinon Hermès products versus stockPositive4:50

    Buying and reselling a Hermès scarf or bag may outperform investing in its stock.

    “If I had to invest in something, then buy a scarf or a bag and then sell it later for more. You will make more money than this.”

    Listen at 4:50

  12. Sven Carlinon HermèsNegative5:02

    Hermès stock is unattractive when purchased at an excessive price.

    “if you pay too much of a price, it's crazy”

    Listen at 5:02

  13. Sven Carlinon Hermès market capitalization and index demandPositive5:18

    Rising Hermès market capitalization increases index weight and attracts pension-fund buying.

    “as the market cap goes higher, the market weight capitalization in the European indices goes higher, the stupid pension funds buy more, and you get a higher and higher stock price”

    Listen at 5:18

  14. Sven Carlinon Hermès stock valuationNegative5:43

    Hermès remains excessively valued at a P/E ratio of 30 and 1.3% dividend yield.

    “a P ratio of 30, a dividend of 1.3%, still craziness”

    Listen at 5:43

Statements are attributed to the speaker as said on the episode and reflect their view at the time, not PodLume's. They are not advice.

Weekly email

State of the Pod, every Monday

The week's most-discussed names and stories from podcasts, with the moments behind them. Free, five minutes, unsubscribe in one click.

Listen to the full episode and explore every guest, topic, and moment on PodLume.

Hermès still commands a premium after its 50% fall · PodLume