
Jun 30, 2026 · 3h 59m
Historian Anthony Kaldellis challenges traditional narratives on the fall of Rome
#498 – Anthony Kaldellis: Roman Empire, Byzantine Empire, Rise & Fall of Empires
Understanding the true mechanics of Roman survival and decline reframes how we view the stability and potential vulnerabilities of modern global superpowers.
- 1The Byzantine Empire was the direct continuation of Rome, operating as a monarchic republic where public opinion held emperors accountable.
- 2The Western Roman Empire collapsed due to barbarian invasions and a shrinking tax base, while the East adapted and survived.
- 3External geopolitical shocks rather than internal moral decay ultimately caused the fall of Constantinople in 1453.
Don't miss
Anthony Kaldellis explains how the Hippodrome of Constantinople functioned as a venue for a perpetual referendum, allowing citizens to directly check imperial power.
The brief
Historian Anthony Kaldellis reframes the 2,200-year history of the Roman Empire, arguing that the Eastern Roman or Byzantine Empire was not a separate, decaying medieval state but the direct, unbroken continuation of Rome itself.
Rather than a traditional autocracy, the empire functioned as a monarchic republic. Without a formal right to succession, emperors faced constant public pressure, with the Hippodrome of Constantinople serving as a venue for a perpetual referendum.
The state was highly resilient, unified by the Edict of Caracalla and later by Christianity. While the West collapsed in 476 AD due to a shrinking tax base and invasions, the East survived for another millennium through administrative and military reforms.
Kaldellis challenges the popular narrative of internal moral decay leading to the fall of Constantinople in 1453. Instead, he demonstrates how a series of massive, external geopolitical shocks from the Normans and Turks shattered a highly stable system.
The enduring legacy of Roman governance offers a mirror for modern times, illustrating how the persistent gap between foreign policy rhetoric and action continues to shape the trajectory of global superpowers.
What was said on this episode
92 statements · 45 positive · 19 negative · 2 mixed · 26 neutral
The Eastern Roman Empire directly continued the ancient Roman Empire.
“So the Eastern Roman Empire, this is the direct continuation of the ancient Roman Empire in the East.”
Listen at 9:40
The Eastern Roman Empire directly continued the ancient Roman Empire in the East.
“the Eastern Roman Empire, this is the direct continuation of the ancient Roman Empire in the East”
Listen at 9:41
The Roman state lasted an extraordinarily long and historically unusual period.
“the history of the Roman state, the Roman polity, is something that lasts an extraordinarily long time. Very unique almost in history”
Listen at 10:38
Most of Eastern Roman history involved slow economic and territorial growth.
“But most of its history is one of the slow growth.”
Listen at 18:49
Major historical dates often represent longer processes rather than discrete events.
“those are conventional dates that we use to actually capture what is in fact, a much longer process”
Listen at 19:47
The Eastern and Western Roman Empires did not undergo a single definitive split.
“There was no split between the two halves.”
Listen at 19:52
Roman history is fundamentally the history of a state and political community.
“Roman history is very specifically the history of a state or a political community”
Listen at 22:03
Roman historical narrative maintained continuity across major political and cultural changes.
“And so the narrative of the history of the Roman people is what holds all of this together.”
Listen at 22:49
Roman soldiers swore oaths throughout the empire’s history.
“we know that Roman soldiers swore an oath throughout all of the centuries of the empire”
Listen at 31:02
Roman soldiers swore loyalty oaths throughout the empire’s history.
“Roman soldiers swore an oath throughout all of the centuries of the empire.”
Listen at 31:02
Roman law gave Jewish women greater legal rights than they had elsewhere.
“Jewish women have more rights than Jewish women do elsewhere, because where Roman law is not operative”
Listen at 32:42
Eastern Roman authorities presented themselves as responsive and accountable to subjects.
“that the authorities are responsive to the needs of their subjects, that they are often accountable.”
Listen at 34:57
Eastern Roman emperors generally acted sincerely on their stated governing principles.
“my research suggests that the emperors and the authorities were generally sincere in what they said.”
Listen at 38:25
Eastern Roman emperors were incentivized to serve their subjects.
“they were actually incentivized to do this.”
Listen at 38:59
The Roman imperial system lacked an established hereditary right to the throne.
“ultimately it is that there is no right to the throne”
Listen at 39:47
The Eastern Roman Empire experienced approximately 120 civil wars over a millennium.
“There's something like 120 civil wars.”
Listen at 43:21
Approximately 46% of Constantinople’s emperors were violently overthrown.
“Something like 46% of the emperors of Constantinople are overthrown through violence.”
Listen at 44:10
Emperors reduced coup risk by governing in ways that maintained popular goodwill.
“the best way to avoid that fate is to actually do the things that will make people happy so that they don't support a rebel”
Listen at 44:43
Eastern Roman emperors faced an ongoing popular referendum on their legitimacy.
“We just call it a perpetual referendum.”
Listen at 46:57
Public gatherings functioned as popular consultation and tests of political consensus.
“it is definitely a form of popular consultation and a testing of consensus”
Listen at 49:21
Eastern Roman emperors sometimes reversed policies after popular opposition.
“emperors like literally can backtrack when they see that the people are against something in a matter of policy”
Listen at 50:11
Caracalla’s 212 edict extended Roman citizenship to everybody in the empire.
“extended citizenship to everybody”
Listen at 57:31
Ordinary Egyptians largely did not appear to experience the third-century crisis as an everyday catastrophe.
“if you go to Egypt, for example, which is kind of out of the right. What's going on there? How are people living there? And we can see how people are living in Egypt because we have all these papyrus documents from Egypt and for the most part they don't seem to be experiencing a crisis”
Listen at 1:06:34
Diocletian expanded the Roman government and possibly its army.
“Diocletian creates a larger government, possibly a larger army.”
Listen at 1:11:45
Diocletian successfully stabilized revenue, armies, and rebellions through administrative reforms.
“He was mostly successful. So in terms of generating revenue from a much more troubled and kind of precarious situation, sustaining large armies and putting down these rebellions and usurpations. And he was generally successful at doing that”
Listen at 1:14:26
Diocletian’s administrative reforms were mostly successful.
“He was mostly successful.”
Listen at 1:14:26
Taxation was central to the functioning of the East Roman state.
“Taxation is the heart of it”
Listen at 1:16:02
Taxation was central to the functioning of the Eastern Roman state.
“Taxation is the heart of it.”
Listen at 1:16:02
Diocletian’s political stability enabled renewed economic and demographic growth.
“if you provide that context of stability, the economic growth, the demographic growth will return. And Diocletian created that context”
Listen at 1:21:14
Diocletian created conditions for economic and demographic recovery.
“And Diocletian created that context.”
Listen at 1:21:19
Constantine became sole ruler of the Roman Empire in 324.
“Constantine emerges in 324 as the sole ruler of the entire Roman Empire.”
Listen at 1:22:57
Constantinople was conceived as a new eastern Rome.
“Constantinople, AKA New Rome”
Listen at 1:24:12
Constantinople’s location enabled emperors to operate between the Danube and Euphrates frontiers.
“Constantinople is right between the Danube and the Euphrates. These are two major frontiers. And so it allows emperors to move between the two”
Listen at 1:26:58
Constantinople helped unify the Balkans, Asia Minor, and Syria.
“And Constantinople ultimately functions as a kind of clamp that unifies this whole area.”
Listen at 1:27:38
Constantine’s foundation of Constantinople and Christian conversion had major historical consequences.
“The creating Constantinople and converting to Christianity and setting the empire on a path to conversion, these are major like world history level decisions”
Listen at 1:32:44
Christianity was incorporated into the Roman imperial system.
“that the religion was co opted by the imperial system.”
Listen at 1:34:59
Christianity was incorporated into the Roman imperial system.
“that the religion was co opted by the imperial system”
Listen at 1:34:59
The empire likely became majority Christian only by the fifth century.
“We probably can't talk about a majority Christian society until maybe the fifth century or early fifths, mid fifths.”
Listen at 1:44:42
Christianity’s diverse forms made it highly adaptable across Roman society.
“it has this kind of manifold diversity, right, that makes it very adaptable”
Listen at 1:48:31
Christianity simultaneously intensified polarization and strengthened social unity.
“Christianity, in contrast to say, the ancient religions, is both far more polarizing but also far more powerful as a unifying force at the same time”
Listen at 1:49:12
Constantinople grew to roughly 500,000 people within two centuries.
“it grew to a city of a half a million in two centuries.”
Listen at 1:59:49
Barbarian territorial gains reduced Roman tax revenues and weakened its armies.
“This created this kind of vicious cycle because then the Roman state lost access to the resources from those provinces, that is the taxes.”
Listen at 2:05:06
The Eastern Roman Empire benefited strategically from its geography.
“So the east does have that kind of advantage.”
Listen at 2:08:54
Local communities’ continued allegiance helped the Eastern Roman Empire survive invasions.
“Ultimately, I think it's the decision made by local communities to stick with the Roman state”
Listen at 2:09:06
Eastern Roman military strength ranged from roughly 100,000 to 250,000.
“It can have anywhere between 100,000 at a minimum at a low point, up to maybe about 250,000 at a high point”
Listen at 2:13:36
The civilian administration primarily funded the army through taxation.
“Principally it is to find the funds to pay for this army, which is the single largest expense on the state budget.”
Listen at 2:14:19
Eunuchs served as useful counterweights to established bureaucratic and military networks.
“eunuchs were perfect for this reason because often their origin was from outside the empire or they were former slaves.”
Listen at 2:20:46
The Eastern Roman state censused virtually every piece of arable land for centuries.
“This is a state in which everybody. Piece of arable land has been censused for centuries.”
Listen at 2:25:16
Taxation was a principal force integrating the Eastern Roman Empire.
“So what you're saying is taxation is the thing that brings the empire together.”
Listen at 2:26:33
The Roman emperor was ideologically expected to serve the political community.
“the role of the emperor, whether he's Caesar or Vasilevs or whatever language, was to serve the polity.”
Listen at 2:29:03
The emperor was expected to work for the Roman republic.
“the emperor was expected to be working for the republic.”
Listen at 2:32:58
Justinian’s codification became the main source for modern knowledge of Roman law.
“This is a massive work of codification and it is our main source for Roman law.”
Listen at 2:41:06
Justinian’s conquests overstretched resources and weakened his successors’ defenses.
“He overstretched his resources, leaving his successors with a much more dangerous situation to defend.”
Listen at 2:47:15
Justinian’s forces killed more than 30,000 protesters during the Nika revolt.
“he orders his armies to slaughter the protesters, leaving more than 30,000 dead.”
Listen at 2:49:51
“I think that would have brought this society to a halt, just logistically speaking. And so I believe in a much more moderate impact”
Listen at 2:52:05
The Plague of Justinian had a more moderate impact than maximalist estimates suggest.
“And so I believe in a much more moderate impact.”
Listen at 2:52:12
The sixth-century plague did not halt taxation, courts, or military campaigns.
“This does not happen in the 6th century.”
Listen at 2:52:42
Justinian left the empire overextended and militarily vulnerable.
“Well, he left it overextended, so his successors had to deal with many more problems along many more fronts with fewer military forces”
Listen at 2:53:31
The Roman-Persian wars exhausted both empires, enabling Arab conquest.
“They've destroyed each other in these wars. And eventually Heraclius calls in his Turkish allies and they go on a field trip through Mesopotamia and this causes a coup in Persia and Khusrau is killed.”
Listen at 3:00:13
Greek fire and naval defenses helped ensure Roman state survival.
“And that ensures the survival of, of the Roman state in some form.”
Listen at 3:05:14
Constantinople was well prepared to resist the Arab siege.
“The city was very well prepared.”
Listen at 3:08:58
Iconoclasm primarily involved a small elite group rather than broad popular demand.
“I don't know, maybe 100, 200 people are, like, seriously invested in this and they're going at it.”
Listen at 3:12:25
Simultaneous attacks by Turks, Pechenegs, and Normans caused an Eastern Roman crisis.
“under the pressure of this three part attack, this expansionist and what had become more imperial state buckles and enters. Another one of these crises”
Listen at 3:16:40
The eleventh-century crisis mainly resulted from simultaneous external attacks, not internal decay.
“I think that's what happened. I think that's the main narrative. Not that there weren't problems. There were. But no state can, medieval or ancient, can realistically survive the simultaneous attack of three very different kinds of enemies”
Listen at 3:18:59
East Roman crises were discrete, short-lived external shocks.
“the crises that this polity, this state, this society that it undergoes are a discrete number of them. I can tell you what they are, and we've talked about most of them so far. They don't last very long, and they are all sudden challenges that appear from the outside”
Listen at 3:22:01
Eastern Roman institutions promoted stabilization and gradual growth after crises.
“I see this as a society whose internal organization primes it to stabilize and embark on steady growth.”
Listen at 3:23:36
Eastern Roman resilience began declining between 1300 and 1350.
“I would say early 14th century, somewhere between 1300 and 1350, the sources of resilience begin to dry up”
Listen at 3:28:58
Foreign invasions were the primary cause of the Eastern Roman collapse.
“Oh, foreign invasions. There's no question.”
Listen at 3:31:19
The Eastern Roman Empire ultimately collapsed because successive invasions exhausted its territorial fallback options.
“It's foreign invasions. More those which they could not cope with, they coped with lots of them. But, you know, all it takes is to lose to one and you lose some part of your territory, and if you keep losing enough, you won't have anything to fall back on”
Listen at 3:31:22
The Roman Empire lacked significant internal forces that would have threatened its survival.
“absent those forces, I don't see any for any forces of internal decomposition that would have imperiled it, you know, significantly.”
Listen at 3:34:38
East Roman stability rested on responsive governance and a unified Roman-Orthodox identity.
“First is that an extraordinary effort was made by the authorities to persuade their subjects that they were ruling on their behalf. And I think for the most part actually tended to do so. And the second is that it had a very tightly unified identity as Roman and as orthodox”
Listen at 3:36:23
Roman authorities generally ruled on behalf of their subjects and persuaded them of that.
“an extraordinary effort was made by the authorities to persuade their subjects that they were ruling on their behalf. And I think for the most part actually tended to do so.”
Listen at 3:36:24
The East Roman Empire had a tightly unified Roman and Orthodox identity.
“it had a very tightly unified identity as Roman and as orthodox.”
Listen at 3:36:38
Rhetorical strategies produce different levels of compliance and consensus despite identical practical aims.
“Those two just rhetorical strategies they're aiming at the same practical outcome will produce very different levels of compliance. Right. And consensus.”
Listen at 3:38:28
Political rhetoric must be credible and supported by corresponding action.
“It has to be credible. You can't just say it and then not do it.”
Listen at 3:38:51
Leaders best establish legitimacy by actually behaving as benevolent rulers.
“the best way to persuade your subjects that you're legitimate benevolent kings is to be that.”
Listen at 3:39:54
States should invest in broadly beneficial institutions and explain their costs for long-term success.
“investing in institutions that work for the majority of your subjects, even if indirectly, like they have to pay a cost for them, but you have to explain to them why they're paying that cost is to the benefit of the ruling classes as well because ideally you're thinking about long term success and not just your own short term gain.”
Listen at 3:41:34
Modern societies would benefit from institutions that explain their purpose to citizens.
“institutions that explain to people why they exist. Yeah, I think we could use some of that.”
Listen at 3:42:20
The Roman army mostly protected the empire's subjects as emperors claimed.
“for the most part they're doing that.”
Listen at 3:43:32
Most of the world does not believe American leaders' stated war aims, including democracy promotion.
“I don't think most of the world even believes, you know, what American leaders say their goals are, especially when it comes to like war, like spreading democracy”
Listen at 3:44:27
The Vietnam War severely damaged U.S. military leadership's credibility and constrained later wars.
“it took them so long to be able to like wage, you know, these empire wars again because of the sheer damage that the Vietnam War did to the credibility of the military leadership in the country.”
Listen at 3:45:49
Human psychology and recurring human behaviors persist across historical periods.
“more or less, human beings are going to. More or less they're going to be after. Right. They love and they hate and they have ambitions and they're incompetent.”
Listen at 3:48:48
Culture modifies the expression of broadly shared human psychological traits.
“culture will modify, will set the dials, right, but that the dials go from 1 to 10.”
Listen at 3:49:16
Exceptional individuals can sometimes change the course of history.
“I think so occasionally, yes.”
Listen at 3:49:40
Cultural systems and ideologies do not completely determine every person's thinking.
“I also don't think that cultural Systems or ideologies are so effectively totalitarian that they sort of colonize the mind of every person.”
Listen at 3:49:51
Humanity is currently in its third major historical phase: industrial-technological society.
“we're now living through a technological first, industrial.”
Listen at 3:51:34
Humanity will enter a fourth major historical phase.
“I'm pretty sure there will be.”
Listen at 3:52:06
Humanity's major technology-related problems are solvable to some extent.
“I think they're solvable problems to a certain degree.”
Listen at 3:55:16
Many contemporary technological and civilizational problems are solvable if elites are restrained.
“I think they're solvable problems to a certain degree. Like, if we can rein in some elites, a lot of these problems can be fixed”
Listen at 3:55:16
Constraining powerful elites could fix many technology-related societal problems.
“if we can rein in some elites, a lot of these problems can be fixed.”
Listen at 3:55:19
The amount of human misery is probably decreasing each year.
“The amount of, like, sheer misery is probably objectively decreasing every year now.”
Listen at 3:56:54
Overall conditions do not justify despair about humanity's future.
“But overall, I don't see a reason to despair and not have hope.”
Listen at 3:57:06
Statements are attributed to the speaker as said on the episode and reflect their view at the time, not PodLume's. They are not advice.
Books & mentions
Weekly email
State of the Pod, every Monday
The week's most-discussed names and stories from podcasts, with the moments behind them. Free, five minutes, unsubscribe in one click.