Politics Politics Politics
Politics Politics Politics

Sep 17, 2026 · 1h 3m

Listen from 29:59

Listen at 29:59

Iran and gas prices test Trump’s midterm strength

Is Iran Making Trump Into Jimmy Carter? Making Sense of Talarico’s Texas Pivots (with Michael Cohen)

The episode examines whether economic pressure could reshape the midterms while candidates in Ohio, Texas, and Michigan recalibrate their strategies.

3 key takeaways
  1. 1Iran and rising gas prices could revive comparisons between Donald Trump and Jimmy Carter by weakening his economic standing.
  2. 2James Talarico’s Texas strategy hinges on broadening his appeal without alienating Democratic voters on cultural issues.
  3. 3A narrowly divided House or Senate could produce difficult governing conditions after the midterms.

Don't miss

Michael Cohen explains why the Texas and Ohio contests reveal different risks in negative advertising and ideological repositioning.

The brief

Justin and Michael Cohen open with the question of whether Iran and rising gas prices could damage Donald Trump enough to echo Jimmy Carter’s economic troubles.

Ohio’s governor’s race becomes a case study in negative advertising, as Vivek Ramaswamy’s attacks on Amy Acton raise questions about character attacks and campaign misfires.

In Texas, heavy spending and the Paxton–Talarico contest expose the challenge of building statewide appeal while navigating football, cultural issues, and party pressure.

The Michigan discussion turns to Abdul El-Sayed’s association with Hassan Piker and the political difficulty of distancing from an influential online audience.

The closing scenarios range from Republican control of both chambers to a narrow Democratic House majority or Republican Senate, each carrying serious governing constraints.

What was said on this episode

25 statements · 11 positive · 11 negative · 3 neutral

  1. Justin Youngon gas pricesNegative4:36

    Gas prices are driving economic negativity and Democratic midterm prospects.

    “the economic negativity in this country that has created an environment where Democrats are looking to do very well in the midterms is entirely about one thing, the price of gas.”

    Listen at 4:36

  2. Justin Youngon Iran WarNegative13:08

    The Iran war is politically poisonous for average voters.

    “This is just strychnine for the average voter.”

    Listen at 13:08

  3. A Republican midterm overperformance would require Iran’s regime to fall.

    “I would say that if that were to happen, the regime would have to fall.”

    Listen at 16:11

  4. Michael Cohenon Ohio governor’s race advertisingNegative23:33

    Early nuclear advertising indicates the opposing campaign is worried.

    “usually that stuff is like, you know, the last... couple weeks of the campaign, but if we're in September, that means that, number one, the other guys are worried”

    Listen at 23:33

  5. Early attacks on Amy Acton indicate serious campaign or polling problems for Vivek Ramaswamy.

    “seeing an ad against Amy Acton this early is pretty much an oh shit moment. uh for the campaign like oh god you know something in our polling is terrible something in in the whole vibes of the campaign is terrible we've got to do something now to go talk about the other guy”

    Listen at 26:49

  6. Michael Cohenon personal campaign attacksNegative28:50

    Personal attacks can backfire if the target appears normal and the sponsor looks unreasonable.

    “there's a possibility of boomerang right so if all of a sudden you start seeing any acting with her family and everything looks very normal you know vivek looks like the guy is just you know shouting mcshow face and you end up in a situation where it boomerangs back on the candidate that send it out.”

    Listen at 28:50

  7. Outside-group attacks on Amy Acton are strategically defensible for Vivek Ramaswamy.

    “what they're trying to do is to try to help Vivek. I would say, again, too early. But, you know, as long as it's coming from an outside group and it's not like Vivek's standing there saying, she's an alcoholic and she beats her kids. You know, then it is roughly defensible from a campaign strategy standpoint and even execution.”

    Listen at 29:52

  8. Outsourced personal attacks are strategically defensible for Vivek’s campaign.

    “as long as it's coming from an outside group and it's not like Vivek's standing there saying, she's an alcoholic and she beats her kids. You know, then it is roughly defensible from a campaign strategy standpoint and even execution.”

    Listen at 29:59

  9. Michael Cohenon Ken PaxtonPositive35:26

    Ken Paxton presents himself as authentically Texan.

    “I think that Paxton, for all his nefariousness and problems as a candidate, does come off as a Texan.”

    Listen at 35:26

  10. Attacking Paxton’s character alone will not win Tallarico 50 percent plus one.

    “the idea that you're going to attack Paxton and make your entire campaign about how Paxton is just a bad dude is just not going to get you to 50 plus one.”

    Listen at 37:20

  11. Michael Cohenon Ken Paxton pollingNeutral37:52

    Polling showing Talarico ahead may undercount socially unacceptable Paxton supporters.

    “I think there's a... a non-response error in there of people who are not taking the surveys, who think they understand that it's socially unacceptable to like Paxton, so they're just not taking the poll.”

    Listen at 37:52

  12. Michael Cohenon Ken Paxton–James Talarico Texas Senate racePositive38:10

    Ken Paxton will narrowly defeat James Talarico in Texas.

    “So I think Paxton's going to squeak by. I don't see Tauro Rico winning this.”

    Listen at 38:10

  13. Michael Cohenon Ken PaxtonPositive38:10

    Michael Cohen predicts Ken Paxton will narrowly win.

    “So I think Paxton's going to squeak by.”

    Listen at 38:10

  14. Tallarico’s transgender-policy shift is a conventional general-election pivot.

    “this is a classic pivot to the middle, you know, general election strategy”

    Listen at 41:35

  15. Talarico’s positioning is intended to blunt anticipated attacks about transgender issues.

    “the reason why you do that now is because you're waiting on the they-them ad, right?”

    Listen at 42:09

  16. Tallarico can neutralize a politically explosive Texas issue by rejecting it.

    “So you basically, like, you know, segment that issue off that you know is nuclear, particularly in Texas, and you just say, look, I'm not going to do it.”

    Listen at 42:32

  17. Tallarico must fund advertising to make his transgender-policy pivot credible.

    “It's not just sufficient enough for him to say it on Fox. He actually has to put money behind it”

    Listen at 44:49

  18. Abdul El-Sayed should publicly sever ties with Hassan Piker.

    “Son, you need to cut this guy loose. there's the answer right and you know you just you do a sit down interview um and you say you know what it you know it's taken me a long time to get there because i'm a loyal guy but that can't stand you know we have to we have to yeah i he has to cut the guy loose”

    Listen at 48:19

  19. Abdul El-Sayed should sever ties with Hassan Piker.

    “he has to cut the guy loose”

    Listen at 48:39

  20. Justin Youngon Hasan PikerNegative50:15

    Hassan Piker could turn El-Sayed’s distancing into a damaging personal media conflict.

    “if Hassan wants to scorch the earth and say that al-Sayed is making a mistake, it is not beyond Hassan to make this about himself”

    Listen at 50:15

  21. Cutting Hassan Piker is necessary for El-Sayed to improve his winning chances.

    “if I want him to win, I'm going to, you know, be strapped to a chair, you know, a truth serum, and I'm going to be telling him, you've got to cut this guy.”

    Listen at 52:32

  22. El-Sayed must moderate his presentation to win Michigan’s purple electorate.

    “he still has to find himself a place to normie, because right now he's not normie”

    Listen at 52:42

  23. A narrow Democratic House win and closely divided Senate is the likeliest scenario.

    “Winning name only. It's actually the most fun scenario for all of us who watch this because everyone's miserable.”

    Listen at 56:21

  24. Michael Cohenon Post-2026 CongressNegative57:31

    A narrowly divided post-midterm Congress would be relatively dysfunctional.

    “And also votes he'd prefer not to take. I mean, so there's going to be everyone in this scenario is going to be unhappy. And that is essentially where the country is anyway. They're very unhappy with all their choices and they're basically going to get a Congress that is going to be relatively dysfunctional.”

    Listen at 57:31

  25. Michael Cohenon post-2026 CongressNegative57:44

    The post-midterm Congress will be relatively dysfunctional.

    “they're basically going to get a Congress that is going to be relatively dysfunctional.”

    Listen at 57:44

Statements are attributed to the speaker as said on the episode and reflect their view at the time, not PodLume's. They are not advice.

Books & mentions

Some links are affiliate links — PodLume may earn a commission if you buy.

Weekly email

State of the Pod, every Monday

The week's most-discussed names and stories from podcasts, with the moments behind them. Free, five minutes, unsubscribe in one click.

Listen to the full episode and explore every guest, topic, and moment on PodLume.