
Oct 12, 2026 · 1h 42m
Listen from 20:34
Listen at 20:34
Kelly and Jashinsky challenge media narratives on sex, celebrity, and politics
The Cornell Jane Doe Hoax and Media Cover-Up, and Kelly Clarkson Goes to War Over Mechanical Bird, with Emily Jashinsky | Ep. 1416
The episode examines how incomplete evidence, celebrity influence, and online outrage can shape public judgments before facts are settled.
- 1Kelly and Jashinsky argue that legal standards for rape allegations should not be replaced by trauma, feelings, or retrospective interpretations alone.
- 2The Kelly Clarkson dispute becomes a case study in how celebrity complaints can expose small businesses to disproportionate online harassment.
- 3Conflicting accounts involving Ilhan Omar and James Tallarico prompt scrutiny of political accountability, evidence, and conspiracy claims.
Don't miss
The hosts use the mechanical-bird dispute to show how a celebrity’s account can mobilize disproportionate online pressure against a small shop.
The brief
Megyn Kelly and Emily Jashinsky open by challenging Alex Cooper’s commentary on the Cornell Jane Doe controversy and the way media figures frame sexual allegations.
Their central argument is that legal conclusions require evidence tied to the applicable standard, not simply trauma, later feelings, or a compelling public narrative.
The Kelly Clarkson dispute over a $15,000 mechanical bird becomes a test of celebrity power: a public complaint can send online crowds toward a small shop.
The episode closes with unresolved questions involving Ilhan Omar and James Tallarico, weighing political accountability against unreliable evidence and conspiracy claims.
What was said on this episode
15 statements · 11 negative · 1 mixed · 3 neutral
The Cornell case is a fabricated hoax rather than a gang rape.
“the whole thing is a hoax. This is a made up.”
Listen at 6:24
Casual sex is not empowering for most women.
“in the vast vast majority of cases no”
Listen at 7:12
Post-sex oxytocin release explains women’s negative responses to casual sex.
“It is a chemical biological fact. It's about oxytocin levels that are released after sex.”
Listen at 7:36
New York law requires physical helplessness for intoxication to constitute rape.
“The standard is physical helplessness. That is the only way that this could have been transformed into a rape.”
Listen at 15:19
New York case law interprets physical helplessness as unconsciousness.
“The case law interpreting that legal standard has said that means unconscious.”
Listen at 15:44
Jane Doe’s sworn statement described consent throughout the encounter.
“what she went on to describe was consent every step of the way”
Listen at 20:34
Alex Cooper’s sexual advice is physically dangerous for women.
“What she says is legitimately, genuinely, physically, literally dangerous for women.”
Listen at 31:33
People should not be imprisoned when available evidence describes consensual conduct.
“you don't get to lock people up when that is the evidence.”
Listen at 33:28
Insufficient-evidence prosecutions can push young men toward resentment politics.
“what you are going to do is send a chunk of young men further into resentment politics”
Listen at 36:55
Some media outlets are receiving selective leaks from Jane Doe’s legal team.
“some of these media outlets are clearly getting selective leaks from Jane Doe's legal team”
Listen at 40:41
Journalists should avoid definitive conclusions when evidence is incomplete.
“Your job isn't to say that something definitively happened or didn't”
Listen at 50:06
The Kelly Clarkson store dispute probably resulted from miscommunication.
“there was... probably some type of miscommunication.”
Listen at 1:05:14
Celebrity social-media attacks on small businesses can backfire on the celebrity.
“it can boomerang back on you too”
Listen at 1:05:43
Evidence substantially warrants investigating Ilhan Omar’s immigration and marriage records.
“there's also substantial evidence to warrant an investigation in both of those cases.”
Listen at 1:29:16
James Tallarico’s account of spending nine days in bed with flu is implausible.
“I have a real, very tough time believing James Tallarico's story, that he was just sitting in bed for nine days.”
Listen at 1:40:56
Statements are attributed to the speaker as said on the episode and reflect their view at the time, not PodLume's. They are not advice.
Weekly email
State of the Pod, every Monday
The week's most-discussed names and stories from podcasts, with the moments behind them. Free, five minutes, unsubscribe in one click.