Modern Value Investing with Sven Carlin

Mosaic’s assets may outweigh its margin of safety

When To Buy Mosaic Stock NYSE MOS

Mosaic looks inexpensive on asset value, but fertilizer volatility, debt, and competitive pressure could make today’s price premature.

3 key takeaways
  1. 1Mosaic’s phosphate profits are under pressure from sharply higher sulfur costs, weak demand, and reduced capital spending.
  2. 2Esterhazy and Mosaic’s Saudi investment may hold substantial value, yet BHP’s Jansen project threatens to increase potash competition.
  3. 3A roughly 10% mid-cycle cash-flow yield may be too thin for a cyclical company requiring a larger margin of safety.

Don't miss

Carlin argues that Mosaic’s Esterhazy mine alone may be worth more than the company’s entire current market capitalization.

The brief

Sven Carlin examines why Mosaic looks cheap beside its severe operating problems, comparing its historical performance with Nutrien and mapping its phosphate and potash businesses.

Mosaic’s phosphate economics are squeezed by higher sulfur and ammonia costs, weak fertilizer application, borrowing needs, and reduced capital spending, though weaker soils could eventually revive demand.

BHP’s Jansen project could add potash supply and pressure prices, while Carlin argues Mosaic’s Esterhazy mine alone may be worth more than the company’s current market capitalization.

The balance sheet remains central: cash burn and debt constrain Mosaic, while dividends, past high-priced buybacks, asset sales, and its Saudi investment shape the path forward.

The valuation test is unforgiving: Mosaic offers roughly a 10% mid-cycle cash-flow yield, below the 15–20% yield Carlin wants before calling a cyclical fertilizer stock a bargain.

What was said on this episode

14 statements · 4 positive · 8 negative · 2 neutral

  1. Sven Carlinon MosaicPositive0:51

    Mosaic is currently very cheap and offers an investment opportunity

    “now it is surely very cheap and it offers opportunity”

    Listen at 0:51

  2. Sven Carlinon MosaicNegative2:00

    Higher sulfur prices have made Mosaic phosphate production unprofitable

    “sulfur prices due to the war in iran have exploded exploded which doesn't make it profitable for mosaic to produce phosphates at all”

    Listen at 2:00

  3. Sven Carlinon MosaicNegative2:23

    Mosaic will draw at least $500 million annually from its revolver while conditions persist

    “they will have to take at least half a billion out of that each year as long as that situation persists”

    Listen at 2:23

  4. Sven Carlinon Phosphate application ratesNegative2:38

    Low phosphate application rates will reduce crop yields, especially in Brazil

    “low application rates last year this year as phosphates are expensive crop yields will suffer especially where the soil is weaker like brazil”

    Listen at 2:38

  5. Sven Carlinon Phosphate applicationNegative3:23

    Several years without phosphate application eventually harm soil and yields

    “You can have a few years that you don't put it, but then the soil and the yield starts to suffer.”

    Listen at 3:23

  6. BHP’s Jansen project will add eight million annual potash tons and pressure prices

    “they will add 8 million potash tons per annum and that will likely put pressure on the market”

    Listen at 3:49

  7. Sven Carlinon MosaicPositive4:15

    Mosaic’s Esterhazy mine is worth approximately $10 billion before subtracting debt

    “Esterhazy is worth 10 billion, which is double the market capitalization, minus the debt”

    Listen at 4:15

  8. Sven Carlinon MosaicNegative4:28

    Mosaic’s dividend may be cut because the company is not generating cash

    “The dividend can be cut, of course, because no point in paying it if you're not producing the cash.”

    Listen at 4:28

  9. Sven Carlinon MosaicPositive4:48

    A fertilizer-sector rebound will unleash pent-up demand and benefit Mosaic

    “when the bounce back comes it will be with a lot of pent-up demand and then you will see a revenge fertilizer application with mosaic benefiting”

    Listen at 4:48

  10. Sven Carlinon MosaicPositive5:44

    Mosaic can sell its Saudi fertilizer stake in installments totaling about $2 billion

    “they will be allowed to sell one. part, December, 2027, December 28 and December 29, the third part. And that's 2 billion, let's say.”

    Listen at 5:44

  11. Sven Carlinon MosaicNegative6:33

    Mosaic will burn cash and lose money until fertilizer conditions improve

    “They will burn cash, lose money until the situation changes.”

    Listen at 6:33

  12. Sven Carlinon MosaicNeutral6:46

    Mosaic generates roughly $500 million in mid-cycle cash flow, implying a 10% cycle yield

    “I get to around 500 million per year. So we are trading at 10%. cycle yield.”

    Listen at 6:46

  13. Sven Carlinon Cyclical fertilizer companiesNeutral7:05

    Cyclical fertilizer bargains require a 15–20% mid-cycle average yield

    “the bargain buys are at 15-20% mid-cycle average yield”

    Listen at 7:05

  14. Sven Carlinon MosaicNegative7:10

    Mosaic’s price may need to decline another 30% to become a bargain

    “So we need to go down another 30%”

    Listen at 7:10

Statements are attributed to the speaker as said on the episode and reflect their view at the time, not PodLume's. They are not advice.

Weekly email

State of the Pod, every Monday

The week's most-discussed names and stories from podcasts, with the moments behind them. Free, five minutes, unsubscribe in one click.

Listen to the full episode and explore every guest, topic, and moment on PodLume.