
Jul 27, 2026 · 2h 0m
Neurologist warns improper vitamin D use can disrupt sleep and gut health
Vitamin D Expert: The Supplement World Is Giving The WRONG Advice!
Modern indoor lifestyles have depleted our natural hormone levels, and understanding the delicate balance of vitamins is essential to reclaiming deep, restorative sleep.
- 1Vitamin D acts as a skin-produced hormone that is critical for deep sleep and brain-washing glymphatic processes.
- 2Supplementing with vitamin D without balancing B vitamins can deplete your body and alter your gut microbiome.
- 3Natural sunlight remains biologically superior to synthetic pills for regulating sleep cycles and overall metabolic health.
Don't miss
Steven Bartlett uses Gemini Pro to fact-check the connection between the gut microbiome and sleep disorders, confirming the scientific validity of Dr. Gominak's hypothesis.
The brief
Neurologist Dr. Stasha Gominak challenges standard medical wisdom by linking the global sleep crisis directly to indoor lifestyles that deprive us of natural sunlight, disrupting both hormone production and our biological repair systems.
While vitamin D is widely treated as a simple supplement, it actually functions as a hormone made on our skin. Gominak warns that taking high doses of vitamin D without balancing B vitamins can inadvertently drain the body and disrupt the gut microbiome.
To prove the gut-sleep connection, host Steven Bartlett uses Gemini Pro to fact-check Gominak's hypothesis in real time, confirming a strong, clinically recognized scientific link between microbiome health and deep sleep cycles.
Through her RightSleep protocol, Gominak advocates for behavioral changes first, explaining why natural sunlight is biologically superior to synthetic pills and how geographic location and skin pigment dictate our daily needs.
What was said on this episode
83 statements · 40 positive · 30 negative · 2 mixed · 11 neutral
- Stasha Gominakon vitamin adviceNegative0:00
Mainstream vitamin advice is wrong.
“The vitamin world is giving the wrong advice.”
Listen at 0:00
- Stasha Gominakon Dietary supplementsNegative0:03
Improper supplement use can be as dangerous as taking drugs.
“if you do not know what you're doing with them, they're just as dangerous as any drug you could put in your mouth”
Listen at 0:03
- Stasha Gominakon vitamin supplementsNegative0:05
Improper supplement use can be as dangerous as drug use.
“they're just as dangerous as any drug you could put in your mouth.”
Listen at 0:05
Vitamin D supplementation is not equivalent to outdoor exposure.
“supplementing with vitamin D is not the same as being outdoors”
Listen at 0:09
- Stasha Gominakon vitamin D deficiencyNegative0:20
Vitamin D deficiency can impair the brain’s ability to sleep.
“when we're deficient in this vitamin, our brain actually forgets how to sleep.”
Listen at 0:20
Vitamin D should be classified as a hormone rather than a vitamin.
“vitamin D is a hormone”
Listen at 1:25
- Stasha Gominakon Right Sleep protocolPositive3:58
Her sleep protocol is based on brain chemistry rather than behavioral blame.
“those steps are based on brain chemistry, not on you do it wrong”
Listen at 3:58
- Stasha Gominakon behavioral sleep treatmentNegative4:08
Standard behavioral sleep treatments have not helped many of her patients.
“The usual sleep treatment is behavioral. Blackout, curtains, white noise, go to bed at the same time, recognize your bedroom as a quiet place for sleep, et cetera. That is not something that's helped the people who wind up with me.”
Listen at 4:08
CPAP may improve headaches by extending deep sleep.
“I think maybe it's allowing her to stay in deep sleep longer.”
Listen at 5:28
- Stasha Gominakon human outdoor livingNeutral6:56
Humans are biologically adapted to outdoor living.
“Humans were meant to to live outdoors like every other animal.”
Listen at 6:56
Her patients had roughly one-sixth of expected REM sleep.
“they're actually one sixth of the amount of REM sleep they should have.”
Listen at 13:50
Returning to REM sleep can improve mood.
“If I'm allowed to go back to sleep, if I have the proper brain chemistry to allow me to fall back into REM sleep, I will wake in a better mood.”
Listen at 14:30
- Stasha Gominakon vitamin D and acetylcholinePositive15:59
Vitamin D supports production of acetylcholine through an enzyme pathway.
“vitamin D makes the enzyme or the protein that makes a certain reaction happen that makes acetylcholine.”
Listen at 15:59
- Stasha Gominakon indoor livingNegative16:58
Moving indoors can produce a chemical deficiency state.
“This is actually a chemical deficiency state that happens when you move indoors.”
Listen at 16:58
- Stasha Gominakon vitamin supplementationPositive18:03
Underlying deficiency states can be corrected through vitamins.
“I would claim that there's a deficiency state in the background that you can actually fix, and you can fix it, but it's through vitamins.”
Listen at 18:03
- Stasha Gominakon Vitamin supplementsNegative19:18
Vitamins can be as dangerous as drugs when used improperly.
“Vitamins are a form of biohacking. They're just as dangerous as any drug you could put in your mouth.”
Listen at 19:18
- Stasha Gominakon global sleep problemsNegative19:52
Billions of people worldwide experience sleep problems.
“Billions. It's around the world.”
Listen at 19:52
- Stasha Gominakon vitamin treatmentPositive21:43
Her patients reverted to a 10 p.m.–6 a.m. sleep schedule after vitamin treatment.
“everybody I was doing this vitamin stuff with would revert back to fall asleep at 10 and wake up at 6.”
Listen at 21:43
- Stasha Gominakon night-shift workNegative22:20
Humans cannot normally sustain night work with normal brain chemistry.
“humans really can't work nights if they have normal brain chemistry.”
Listen at 22:20
- Stasha Gominakon Severely disrupted deep sleepNegative29:19
Severely disrupted deep sleep may indicate a brainstem disorder and future stroke risk.
“This is a brainstem disorder of chemistry. That's going to mean she might meet me 10 years from now with a stroke.”
Listen at 29:19
- Stasha Gominakon absent deep sleepNegative29:19
The patient’s absent deep sleep reflects a brainstem chemical disorder.
“This is a brainstem disorder of chemistry.”
Listen at 29:19
- Stasha Gominakon nonrestorative sleepNegative30:04
Nonrestorative sleep causes disease.
“This implies that the reason why you get a disease is because your sleep is not restorative.”
Listen at 30:04
- Stasha Gominakon Vitamin D receptorsNeutral35:58
Vitamin D receptors occur in brain regions controlling paralysis and sleep timing.
“vitamin D receptors are in this nucleus that paralyzes us and in the nucleus that are the clock nuclei that determine what time it is”
Listen at 35:58
- Stasha Gominakon vitamin D receptors in the brainNeutral36:19
Vitamin D receptors in sleep-related brain regions indicate vitamin D has a function there.
“That means vitamin D is doing something.”
Listen at 36:19
Very low vitamin D can cause the brain to lose normal sleep function.
“when our D goes very low, our brain actually forgets how to sleep.”
Listen at 38:44
- Stasha Gominakon vitamin D receptor activationPositive39:38
Vitamin D receptor activation produces an enzyme involved in acetylcholine synthesis.
“The protein that it makes is an enzyme that makes acetylcholine.”
Listen at 39:38
Vitamin D should be classified as a hormone made on the skin.
“There was a mistake made in calling it a vitamin. It is made on our skin.”
Listen at 40:57
- Stasha Gominakon hormone supplementationPositive47:43
Hormone supplementation should be guided by blood levels.
“hormones are always done by blood levels”
Listen at 47:43
- Stasha Gominakon Hormone levelsNeutral47:48
Healthy hormone levels remain within a narrow range.
“the normal state for the human body in every biologic animal, including plants, is that hormones stay in a tight little narrow band”
Listen at 47:48
- Stasha Gominakon vitamin D dosingPositive48:42
Vitamin D dosing should be personalized like other hormone treatments.
“Absolutely. Any hormone that you take”
Listen at 48:42
Each person requires an individualized vitamin D amount.
“every single person needs a unique amount.”
Listen at 52:33
Patients report better sleep after vitamin D levels exceed approximately 60.
“I find out also that if you get past about a level of 60, that's when they come back and say, you know what? My sleep is better.”
Listen at 52:44
Sleep improved for patients whose vitamin D levels exceeded about 60.
“if you get past about a level of 60, that's when they come back and say, you know what? My sleep is better.”
Listen at 52:46
- Stasha Gominakon pantothenic acid (B5)Negative58:04
Blocking pantothenic acid can cause insomnia.
“If you block B5, you get insomnia.”
Listen at 58:04
- Stasha Gominakon B-vitamin supplementationNegative59:00
Excess B-vitamin supplementation can cause insomnia-like stimulation.
“If it's too much, it'll act like caffeine. It'll keep you up at night.”
Listen at 59:00
- Stasha Gominakon gut microbiomePositive1:00:50
Gut bacteria produce all eight B vitamins that humans absorb.
“These eight chemicals called B, all of them are made by bacteria and we absorb them.”
Listen at 1:00:50
- Stasha Gominakon gut microbiomePositive1:03:25
The microbiome supplies the body’s B vitamins.
“We should start thinking about the microbiome as the production system that supplies the B vitamins to the body.”
Listen at 1:03:25
Vitamin D alone did not resolve patients’ IBS symptoms.
“The vitamin D was gonna fix their belly. And it didn't.”
Listen at 1:04:14
Vitamin D supplementation can positively change stool bacterial composition.
“And yes, that's the answer.”
Listen at 1:05:50
- Stasha Gominakon vitamin D and gut microbiomePositive1:06:50
Humans provide vitamin D to microbiota, which provide B vitamins in return.
“we have to provide D. They in turn provide us with B's.”
Listen at 1:06:50
Vitamin D alone does not restore the microbiome.
“The D by itself did not correct the microbiome.”
Listen at 1:07:10
Vitamin D alone worsened her deficiency state by failing to correct her microbiome.
“The D did not correct my microbiome. It actually made me deficient.”
Listen at 1:07:30
- Stasha Gominakon B50 supplementationPositive1:07:44
B50 supplementation usually restores patients’ systems toward normal.
“Most of the time, what happens after the B50 is everything comes back to normal.”
Listen at 1:07:44
Short-term B50 supplementation can restart the gut microbiome.
“by giving them B50 for a short period of time, you're kind of jump starting the gut microbiome”
Listen at 1:08:30
B50 should be used for three months to restart microbiome function, then stopped.
“you want to give it to them for three months, let them jump start, and then they'll do their job and then you leave them alone.”
Listen at 1:08:40
- Stasha Gominakon Madeline’s Right Sleep treatmentPositive1:12:03
Madeline’s depression and pain improved after the Right Sleep program.
“Her depression is gone. She stopped three medicines that we've been using for pain control.”
Listen at 1:12:03
People with sleep or medical problems may improve by maintaining vitamin D above 60.
“if you have a sleep problem or medical problems, you will do better if you get Your D above 60 and keep it around there.”
Listen at 1:13:07
- Stasha Gominakon Lactobacillus reuteriNegative1:14:41
Lactobacillus reuteri absence causes loss of a specific metabolite.
“if you do not have a specific bacteria called Lactobacillus reuteri, you will be missing a brand new metabolite or chemical”
Listen at 1:14:41
- Stasha Gominakon vitamin D deficiencyNegative1:16:53
Vitamin D deficiency alters the microbiome and reduces gut B-vitamin production.
“Vitamin D deficiency changes the intestinal microbiome, reducing B vitamin production in the gut.”
Listen at 1:16:53
Low vitamin D can cause microbiome loss and multiple diseases.
“as their D goes low, they lose their microbiome and then they die of one of the multiple diseases that are linked to this multiple deficiency state.”
Listen at 1:18:33
- Stasha Gominakon vitamin D and B-vitamin deficiencyNegative1:21:39
Gominak rejects the consensus that vitamin D does not cause B-vitamin deficiency.
“Absolutely.”
Listen at 1:21:39
- Stasha Gominakon coenzyme A deficiencyNegative1:22:00
The vitamin pathway ultimately involves coenzyme A deficiency.
“it's way more complicated than you and I have talked about. And where you finally arrive is actually at Coenzyme A deficiency.”
Listen at 1:22:00
- Stasha Gominakon Natalie’s treatmentPositive1:23:26
Natalie’s postpartum depression and elevated heart rate resolved after treatment.
“Her antidepressant went away. Her postpartum depression cleared her high heart rate.”
Listen at 1:23:26
- Stasha Gominakon vitamin and microbiome restorationPositive1:24:15
Restoring missing inputs can allow the body to resume self-supporting microbiome function.
“if there's a mistake made, like we move indoors and we give back what is needed to get the normal microbiome, then you should assume that your body will go back to supporting itself.”
Listen at 1:24:15
- Stasha Gominakon behavioral sleep measuresPositive1:24:53
People should try behavioral sleep measures before supplements.
“do the behavioral cognitive stuff first.”
Listen at 1:24:53
- Stasha Gominakon supplementsNegative1:25:04
People who improve with behavioral measures should avoid supplements.
“if that's all you need, do not mess around with supplements.”
Listen at 1:25:04
- Stasha Gominakon Right Sleep protocolPositive1:25:09
People with persistent sleep problems should learn about her vitamin-based approach.
“if you've already done the behavioral changes, then go to my website, read about the ideas, or listen to this podcast and see whether or not the ideas there feel like they apply to you”
Listen at 1:25:09
People with low B12 should take separate B12 supplementation initially.
“The first three months, if your B12 is low, you will take B12 as a separate supplement.”
Listen at 1:26:00
- Stasha Gominakon vitamin D dosingPositive1:27:04
Vitamin D dosing should be adjusted monthly according to measured levels.
“you're adjusting your vitamin D dosing based on recommendations based on your D levels that you're doing every month.”
Listen at 1:27:04
- Stasha Gominakon supplementationMixed1:28:57
Supplementation benefits people only when correcting a problem.
“supplementation is only good for you if there's something wrong with you that you're trying to correct.”
Listen at 1:28:57
- Stasha Gominakon outdoor exposure and dietPositive1:31:12
Outdoor exposure and diet are preferable when health problems are minor.
“I think you could actually do that if there's not much wrong with you. I think that's the better path.”
Listen at 1:31:12
- Stasha Gominakon Sunlight exposurePositive1:32:25
Sun-exposed skin produces many compounds besides vitamin D.
“there are probably 15, 20 other chemicals that are being made at the same time”
Listen at 1:32:25
- Stasha Gominakon vitamin supplementsPositive1:33:57
Supplements are a faster and easier intervention for severe problems.
“This is the easy way. This is the fast way.”
Listen at 1:33:57
- Stasha Gominakon Outdoor exposure and fermented foodsPositive1:34:27
More outdoor exposure and fermented foods are healthier approaches to disease.
“I think the healthier approach to all of our diseases is to be outside much more and to include these fermented foods.”
Listen at 1:34:27
- Stasha Gominakon outdoor exposure and fermented foodsPositive1:34:28
More outdoor time and fermented foods are healthier approaches to disease.
“the healthier approach to all of our diseases is to be outside much more and to include these fermented foods.”
Listen at 1:34:28
- Stasha Gominakon redhead pigmentationPositive1:35:22
Redhead pigmentation adaptations may facilitate vitamin D production in low-sunlight environments.
“the redhead gene came about in the far north, Viking, Scotland, and those places don't get much sunlight. That means it cleared out the blocker of the thing that collected that energy and allowed people who lived in very overcast environments to make D”
Listen at 1:35:22
- Stasha Gominakon diabetes and sleep disordersNeutral1:37:24
Diabetes and sleep disorders share underlying chemistry rather than direct causation.
“diabetes is happening in parallel with the sleep disorder. It's not caused by the sleep disorder. It has similar chemical in the background.”
Listen at 1:37:24
- Stasha Gominakon direct sunlightMixed1:39:24
Direct sunlight is needed for skin vitamin D production but should be limited to prevent burns.
“you have to be in direct sunlight to make vitamin D on your skin. But you should limit the amount that you do so you do not burn your skin.”
Listen at 1:39:24
- Stasha Gominakon sunlight through windowsNegative1:39:55
Window-filtered sunlight cannot produce vitamin D.
“you can't make anything through the window.”
Listen at 1:39:55
- Stasha Gominakon Cloudy outdoor exposurePositive1:40:14
Cloudy outdoor conditions can still allow skin vitamin D production.
“you can make some vitamin D on a day that it's cloudy”
Listen at 1:40:14
- Stasha Gominakon cloudy outdoor exposurePositive1:40:14
Cloudy outdoor conditions can still permit some vitamin D production.
“you can make some vitamin D on a day that it's cloudy.”
Listen at 1:40:14
Probiotic use did not correct her patients’ microbiomes.
“I was on probiotics and so were my patients when we started. And it had not corrected the microbiome.”
Listen at 1:42:52
- Stasha Gominakon Individualized dietPositive1:44:28
People should choose the diet that best suits their individual response.
“I would claim that that means you should eat the diet that works for you.”
Listen at 1:44:28
- Stasha Gominakon individualized dietPositive1:44:31
People should choose diets that work for their individual bodies.
“you should eat the diet that works for you.”
Listen at 1:44:31
Diet affects the composition of the gut microbiome.
“your diet absolutely affects who lives inside you.”
Listen at 1:46:35
- Stasha Gominakon narcolepsyPositive1:49:20
Narcolepsy may be treatable through the same vitamin-based approach.
“That turns out to be treatable in the same way.”
Listen at 1:49:20
- Stasha Gominakon severe sleep disordersNegative1:50:03
Severe narcolepsy or sleep apnea is unlikely to resolve through lifestyle changes alone.
“they are unlikely to be able to cure that with going outside and kimchi.”
Listen at 1:50:03
- Stasha Gominakon NarcolepsyPositive1:51:49
Some people can cure narcolepsy through her proposed approach.
“people can cure their narcolepsy”
Listen at 1:51:49
A patient reportedly cured narcolepsy using continuous nicotine patches.
“she has completely cured herself by using nicotine patches around the clock.”
Listen at 1:51:57
Nicotine duplicates acetylcholine’s effects.
“Nicotine is the duplicate of acetylcholine.”
Listen at 1:52:16
- Stasha Gominakon Parkinson’s disease and smokingPositive1:52:49
Smokers with Parkinson’s disease have reportedly done better because Parkinson’s involves acetylcholine deficiency.
“the guys with Parkinson's disease who smoked throughout the last 30 years have been shown to do better Because Parkinson's disease is an acetylcholine deficiency state.”
Listen at 1:52:49
Parkinson’s disease is caused by acetylcholine deficiency.
“Parkinson's disease is an acetylcholine deficiency state.”
Listen at 1:52:56
- Stasha Gominakon sleep disordersNegative1:55:57
Most sleep disorders are fundamentally related to vitamin D and microbiome-produced factors.
“Most of the sleep disorders, including sleep apnea, narcolepsy, all the ones that the neurologists have described are really related at basis by D and multiple things that are made by the microbiome”
Listen at 1:55:57
Statements are attributed to the speaker as said on the episode and reflect their view at the time, not PodLume's. They are not advice.
Books & mentions
The RightSleep Protocol Workbook
Dr. Gominak's step-by-step guide to balancing vitamin D and B vitamins to restore natural sleep cycles
Weekly email
State of the Pod, every Monday
The week's most-discussed names and stories from podcasts, with the moments behind them. Free, five minutes, unsubscribe in one click.