The Bulwark Daily
The Bulwark Daily

Sep 7, 2026 · 1h 3m

Listen from 56:02

Listen at 56:02

Past wave elections offer Democrats a midterm playbook

Bill Kristol: A Blue Wave vs. the Toxic Red Tide

The episode tests whether today’s political conditions resemble the backlash, turnout shifts, and strategic failures that produced the 1994 and 2006 waves.

3 key takeaways
  1. 1The 2006 Democratic wave grew from Iraq, Katrina, competence concerns, and late-breaking collapses in Republican races.
  2. 2The 1994 Republican breakthrough paired anti-incumbent backlash with a positive agenda, but Clinton’s healthcare defeat deepened Democratic losses.
  3. 3Democrats’ strongest strategy may target both Trump and a Republican Congress that enables him and avoids meaningful oversight.

Don't miss

Bill Kristol recounts how George Allen’s “macaca” remark and the campaign’s response helped turn a Virginia Senate race toward Jim Webb.

The brief

Tim Miller and Bill Kristol frame the 2026 midterms through two historical waves: Democrats’ 2006 breakthrough and Republicans’ 1994 takeover after decades of Democratic House control.

The early forecast turns on Trump’s approval, the national House vote, and the Senate map, where a broad wave could pull Republican-leaning districts and close races toward Democrats.

The 2006 comparison emphasizes Iraq, Katrina, competence concerns, Harriet Miers, and late campaign collapses, including George Allen’s damaging “macaca” controversy against Jim Webb.

The 1994 account centers on the Contract with America, anti-incumbent sentiment, congressional scandals, and Clinton’s failed healthcare reform, which made Democrats appear threatening to moderates.

The episode’s strategic conclusion is that Democrats should campaign against both Trump and a Republican Congress whose passivity and lack of oversight make it part of the target.

What was said on this episode

36 statements · 18 positive · 11 negative · 1 mixed · 6 neutral

  1. The 2026 midterms will be a big Democratic year.

    “I've thought it would be a big Democratic year for quite a while based on nothing other than just the obvious facts.”

    Listen at 3:48

  2. Bill Kristolon incumbent presidential approval ratingNeutral4:01

    An incumbent president’s approval rating predicts midterm election outcomes.

    “the approval rating of an incumbent president is a good predictor of what happens in a midterm election”

    Listen at 4:01

  3. Trump’s policies could turn a good Democratic year into a very good one.

    “I thought a good year could become a very good year for the Democrats”

    Listen at 4:46

  4. Bill Kristolon 2026 U.S. House electionPositive7:52

    Democrats could win the House 235–200.

    “I've been saying, just to be a little optimistic, just to make the numbers round, 235 to 200 in the House.”

    Listen at 7:52

  5. Bill Kristolon Wave electionsPositive11:33

    Wave elections tend to make close races break toward the wave party.

    “when you get a wave, things tend to tip over to 51-49 your direction”

    Listen at 11:33

  6. Bill Kristolon 2026 competitive Senate racesNeutral11:53

    The four major Senate races may split two-to-two.

    “you could split those, the big 4, 2-2, which is sort of what you were suggesting might be the single most likely outcome”

    Listen at 11:53

  7. Bill Kristolon 2026 Senate electionsMixed12:02

    Late campaign momentum could determine several close Senate races.

    “if the wave continues, this is where it's so important what happens late”

    Listen at 12:02

  8. Bill Kristolon 2026 Democratic Senate majorityPositive12:38

    Democrats could lose an expected state yet still win the Senate majority.

    “the Democrats will lose a state they were supposed to win, maybe Michigan in this case, but maybe Maine, and then still get the majority because Kansas and somewhere else will come through.”

    Listen at 12:38

  9. Bill Kristolon national House vote marginNeutral13:04

    The national House margin will determine close Senate race outcomes.

    “Does it go +8 to drift down to +6, or does it go up to +9? That just makes a big, big difference in these close Senate races.”

    Listen at 13:04

  10. Bill Kristolon George AllenNegative21:27

    George Allen handled the macaca controversy very badly.

    “he handled it very badly.”

    Listen at 21:27

  11. Bill Kristolon wave electionsNegative21:50

    In wave elections, shaky races on Labor Day tend to be lost.

    “in a wave, the stuff that looks shaky on Labor Day goes down.”

    Listen at 21:50

  12. Bill Kristolon George W. Bush Social Security privatization proposalNegative29:30

    Bush’s Social Security privatization proposal would fail politically.

    “this is going to fail. I mean, he has not— the country is not ready for this.”

    Listen at 29:30

  13. Bill Kristolon George W. Bush Social Security privatization proposalNegative30:17

    Bush’s Social Security proposal would politically damage Republicans.

    “I remember early on saying, this is a political— it's going to damage them.”

    Listen at 30:17

  14. Midterm turnout is about two-thirds of presidential-election turnout.

    “The turnout in midterm elections is about 2/3 that of a presidential, sometimes even less”

    Listen at 31:02

  15. Winning midterms requires persuasion, strong base turnout, and depressing opponents’ turnout.

    “the best thing you can have going for you is you persuade some people, that's good. Then you turn out your base big time, and then you depress the other— something the other party does that usually isn't something you do in the opposition depresses its base.”

    Listen at 31:28

  16. Bill Kristolon Republican voter turnoutNegative31:59
    “some Republican voters who still will probably vote Republican in 2028, still think of themselves as Republican, but just, you know, I don't know, just stay home.”

    Listen at 31:59

  17. Anti-Trump sentiment could increase Democratic turnout while depressing Republican turnout.

    “you get the Democratic turnout up and the Republican turnout down”

    Listen at 32:07

  18. Bill Kristolon 2024 presidential marginsNegative32:09
    “If you can get both of those happening at the same time in an electorate that's 2/3 the size of a presidential electorate, that's where, again, that 2024 number of +11 is a little misleading.”

    Listen at 32:09

  19. Hurricane Katrina made it easier to portray Bush’s administration as incompetent.

    “Katrina made it more plausible It's possible to say they're kind of— Bush sold himself competence, toughness, but also competence”

    Listen at 34:20

  20. Bill Kristolon Iraq War managementNegative35:30

    Iraq conditions worsened during the two years after Rumsfeld remained in office.

    “Things got worse over the next 2 years.”

    Listen at 35:30

  21. Bill Kristolon Donald Rumsfeld’s resignationPositive35:39
    “Wouldn't it have been better to do it in September?”

    Listen at 35:39

  22. Bill Kristolon Donald Rumsfeld’s resignationPositive37:01

    Bush should have fired Rumsfeld before the election.

    “He should have done it.”

    Listen at 37:01

  23. The Contract with America improved Republicans’ 1994 performance by roughly half a point.

    “It helped by like half a point. It was not important.”

    Listen at 40:52

  24. Bill Kristolon 1994 Republican campaignPositive42:56

    Republicans’ 1994 campaign successfully challenged the political status quo.

    “they did run against the status quo in a pretty big way.”

    Listen at 42:56

  25. The 1994 election marked a shift toward modern ideological parties.

    “This was the end of old interest group pork barrel politics, I think, in some ways, and the beginning of modern ideological parties”

    Listen at 46:47

  26. Bill Kristolon Bill Clinton healthcare initiativeNegative50:30

    Clinton’s healthcare priority alienated moderate supporters by signaling a leftward shift.

    “putting healthcare ahead of welfare became symbolically very important as he's gone to the left, he's betrayed his moderate supporters.”

    Listen at 50:30

  27. Bill Kristolon U.S. healthcare systemPositive51:24
    “The healthcare system was not that broken. There was no healthcare crisis.”

    Listen at 51:24

  28. Bill Kristolon existing employer-based health insurancePositive52:48

    Republicans should defend existing employer health insurance against Clinton’s proposal.

    “the Republicans should run on that second half, that second poll result. He's endangering your health insurance that you're satisfied with.”

    Listen at 52:48

  29. Bill Kristolon HillarycareNegative52:52

    Republicans successfully portrayed Clinton’s healthcare plan as threatening satisfactory employer insurance.

    “He's endangering your health insurance that you're satisfied with.”

    Listen at 52:52

  30. Bill Kristolon Healthcare reform politicsNeutral53:00

    Defending the healthcare status quo is politically easier than proposing wholesale reform.

    “The status quo is easier to defend than to say, let's risk everything by overturning the whole thing.”

    Listen at 53:00

  31. Bill Kristolon Bill ClintonPositive56:02

    Clinton won reelection decisively after the 1994 Republican wave.

    “'94 was great, and then Clinton promptly won reelection by 7 or 8 points or something in '96”

    Listen at 56:02

  32. Bill Kristolon Democratic Party House strategyPositive58:04

    Democrats regained the House by recruiting candidates from a broader sociological coalition.

    “they got it back by doing exactly what you just said”

    Listen at 58:04

  33. Bill Kristolon Democratic House candidate recruitmentPositive58:04

    Democrats regained the House by recruiting candidates suited to diverse districts.

    “they got it back by doing exactly what you just said, right? Rahm Emanuel recruited a lot of candidates for the House”

    Listen at 58:04

  34. Bill Kristolon Republican-controlled U.S. CongressNegative1:00:13

    The current Republican Congress functions as a rubber stamp for Trump.

    “the Republican Congress now is kind of more like a rubber stamp Congress”

    Listen at 1:00:13

  35. Bill Kristolon Harry TrumanPositive1:01:21

    Democrats should study Harry Truman’s 1948 speeches for campaign messaging.

    “They should go read Harry Truman's speeches from 1948. They're excellent.”

    Listen at 1:01:21

  36. Bill Kristolon Democratic Party 2026 campaignPositive1:01:39

    Democrats should campaign as economically populist, moderate Truman-style candidates.

    “They should run as Harry Truman for the next 2 months.”

    Listen at 1:01:39

Statements are attributed to the speaker as said on the episode and reflect their view at the time, not PodLume's. They are not advice.

Weekly email

State of the Pod, every Monday

The week's most-discussed names and stories from podcasts, with the moments behind them. Free, five minutes, unsubscribe in one click.

Listen to the full episode and explore every guest, topic, and moment on PodLume.

Past wave elections offer Democrats a midterm playbook · PodLume