
Sep 10, 2026 · 1h 36m
Listen from 1:27:19
Listen at 1:27:19
Pedro Gonzalez confronts the movement he helped radicalize
Sarah Longwell and Pedro Gonzalez: Meet the Young MAGA Edgelords—and the One Who Got Away
The episode examines whether Trump-shaped Republicanism can survive Donald Trump—and whether former supporters can return to democratic politics.
- 1Young MAGA conservatives are unlikely to revive the pre-Trump GOP, especially as racial nationalism remains central to succession plans.
- 2Pedro Gonzalez traces how online right-wing activism normalized racial, misogynistic, and authoritarian politics before forcing a personal reckoning.
- 3Sarah Longwell and Gonzalez debate whether shame, consequences, and reality can open a path back from MAGA without abandoning democratic standards.
Don't miss
Pedro Gonzalez publicly confronts the behavior and rhetoric that defined his MAGA years, and explains the personal reckoning that led him out.
The brief
Sarah Longwell argues that young Republicans shaped by Trump are not waiting to restore the old GOP; their foreign-policy and political assumptions have changed.
Longwell and Tim Miller also examine AI’s political future, weighing better information against campaigns, billionaires, and other actors manipulating what voters see as true.
Pedro Gonzalez recounts his rise through online right-wing activism and MAGA media, where access to figures such as Tucker Carlson and J.D. Vance rewarded increasingly extreme politics.
Gonzalez describes race, sex, resentment, and racial nationalism as central to the Trumpian right, while arguing that opportunists preserve influence through loyalty tests and countersignaling.
The sharpest turn comes when Gonzalez confronts his own past attacks, explaining how shame, exposure, and introspection helped him leave MAGA and reconsider democratic belonging.
He and Miller reject a universal formula for political change but debate how consequences can matter without closing the door to former supporters’ return.
What was said on this episode
44 statements · 8 positive · 28 negative · 2 mixed · 6 neutral
Sarah Longwell believes Trump’s proposed $5,000 Republican-win payment may violate the law.
“I just would be shocked if that is not a legal violation.”
Listen at 3:35
Trump refuses to remove tariffs because he wants a trade war with Canada.
“he's unwilling to get rid of the tariffs because he wants to be in a trade war with Canada.”
Listen at 5:39
Trump is unwilling to end the Iran war because he lacks an exit strategy.
“He is unwilling to end the war in Iran because he doesn't know how to get out.”
Listen at 5:44
Trump wants Republicans to win the midterms.
“He does want to win.”
Listen at 6:09
Trump must appear on the ballot to mobilize Trump-only voters.
“Trump has to literally be on the ballot to turn out the people who are the Trump-only voters.”
Listen at 8:34
Trump-only voters generally do not participate in midterm elections.
“They don't turn out in midterms.”
Listen at 9:07
Trump’s midterm campaigning may marginally help some vulnerable red states.
“I don't think it's like really gonna work, but on the margins, could it possibly help some of these, shore up a couple of these red states”
Listen at 9:46
Sarah Longwell predicts John Fetterman is unlikely to seek reelection.
“I very much doubt he runs again.”
Listen at 14:03
Tim Miller believes John Fetterman could switch political parties if the Senate is tied.
“I do think a switch is very possible.”
Listen at 15:46
The Republican Party will not return to its pre-Trump form.
“we're not going back to the old Republican Party”
Listen at 20:10
Sarah Longwell rejects a return to the pre-Trump Republican Party.
“No, absolutely not.”
Listen at 20:28
Young Republican voters shaped by Trump exhibit toxic political behavior.
“this new generation is coming up and they have been taught by Trump how to behave, and they're quite toxic.”
Listen at 20:30
Young voters in both parties tend toward isolationism and anti-Israel views.
“They are isolationist in their foreign policy and they're anti-Israel in their foreign policy”
Listen at 21:30
Young voters are among the first groups to abandon Trump politically.
“they're the last-in, first-out voters.”
Listen at 23:23
Sarah Longwell thinks Joe Rogan could move back toward Democrats after Trump.
“I could see Joe Rogan in a post-Trump era floating back, certainly policy-wise.”
Listen at 23:47
Young people remain politically recoverable for Democrats.
“I don't think that young people are lost.”
Listen at 23:54
AI will worsen voters’ difficulty evaluating political information.
“the AI of it all is about to come along and make the whole thing a lot worse.”
Listen at 25:23
AI has a nonzero chance of causing catastrophe through nuclear-missile launch.
“the odds that AI is both like catastrophic, like they, the— but they figure out how to launch a nuclear missile and we all end up, you know, in the rubble, um, is a non-zero chance.”
Listen at 25:41
AI can provide better factual answers than Facebook acquaintances.
“when people are like, what is true? And they're asking AI, they're actually getting much better answers than they get from their neighbor on Facebook”
Listen at 26:42
Many people will soon ask AI whom they should vote for.
“The number of people who are going to start typing in, who should I vote for, to AI is about to be really high.”
Listen at 27:07
Political actors will try to manipulate AI-generated voting advice.
“People are going to try to manipulate that, right?”
Listen at 27:15
AI is creating a new political information conflict.
“We're entering into an entirely new information battle”
Listen at 27:22
The Trumpian right conceptualizes minorities, immigrants, and white allies as enemies.
“the real enemy of the right is basically minorities and immigrants and their white allies.”
Listen at 43:04
The modern right understands politics as a racial conflict.
“the right understands itself as in kind of a racial conflict with its enemies.”
Listen at 43:40
Trump’s first-term excesses were constrained by people around him.
“he was restrained by people around him.”
Listen at 47:33
Pedro Gonzalez says Trump’s first-term tendencies were restrained but later worsened.
“his worst tendencies were restrained. I think that he was bad then in a sense, and he got much worse over time.”
Listen at 47:37
Trump’s conduct deteriorated over time.
“he got much worse over time.”
Listen at 47:42
Pedro Gonzalez says Trump-era right-wing politics seeks to deprive women of agency.
“women are, to the degree that is possible, they need to be deprived of agency.”
Listen at 55:36
The Trump-era right seeks to reduce women’s political agency and influence.
“They need to be deprived of agency. They need to be kept out of politics. They need to be pushed out of the movement.”
Listen at 55:40
A MAGA successor mainly needs anti-immigrant, traditional-gender, and culture-war politics.
“That's probably sufficient. That's MAGA, right?”
Listen at 59:26
J.D. Vance is a better MAGA successor than Marco Rubio.
“I can see someone like him being a much better fit as a successor to Trump than Marco Rubio.”
Listen at 1:02:27
Tucker Carlson’s effectiveness at Fox depended on writers and institutional constraints.
“If he was effective rhetorically at Fox, it's because of his writers and the people around him that hemmed him in and controlled him.”
Listen at 1:05:08
Tucker Carlson became more extreme after leaving Fox’s institutional constraints.
“once those guardrails were removed, like Trump, he just went insane.”
Listen at 1:05:14
Trump-era conservatives support giving Palantir and Elon Musk extensive government access.
“give Palantir the keys to the kingdom, give, you know, Elon Musk access to like all of the federal government's data, let them run wild”
Listen at 1:13:01
Claremont is currently a terrible organization.
“Now I think Claremont is a terrible organization.”
Listen at 1:20:17
The conservative movement cannot be saved in the foreseeable future.
“I don't think, uh, can, can be saved in the foreseeable future.”
Listen at 1:21:44
No reliable formula exists for pulling people out of MAGA.
“I don't think there's a formula that you can reliably apply to shaking someone out of it.”
Listen at 1:25:51
Pedro Gonzalez says no universal formula reliably pulls people out of MAGA.
“I don't think there is a formula.”
Listen at 1:27:19
Shame can strongly motivate people to reconsider MAGA commitments.
“shame is, is a pretty powerful motivator.”
Listen at 1:27:26
MAGA members often need personally consequential reality checks to recognize error.
“you have to be kind of mugged by reality as, as a member of MAGA in order to realize that you were wrong.”
Listen at 1:28:00
Former MAGA supporters should retain a path to join democratic opposition.
“I think there should still be a path for people like that to, to, to come back in and, and help you somehow, to be part of like the opposition.”
Listen at 1:30:12
Dehumanizing immigrants can expand into broader denial of rights and dignity.
“if you believe that you can deprive a human of their rights, of their dignity, that doesn't stop with their immigration status.”
Listen at 1:32:26
Pedro Gonzalez says the right now demands heritage-based American identity.
“where it's arrived at now is like, it's not enough to be an American, you have to be a heritage American.”
Listen at 1:33:40
The right increasingly defines authentic American identity as specifically white and heritage-based.
“you have to be a heritage American. What does that mean? Well, it's a very specific kind of white American”
Listen at 1:33:44
Statements are attributed to the speaker as said on the episode and reflect their view at the time, not PodLume's. They are not advice.
Books & mentions
Weekly email
State of the Pod, every Monday
The week's most-discussed names and stories from podcasts, with the moments behind them. Free, five minutes, unsubscribe in one click.
