
Nov 20, 2026 · 1h 18m
Playoff chaos grows as upset risks expose ranking flaws
Week 12 Upset Alerts + CFP Committee Under Fire
The episode connects Week 12’s vulnerable contenders to a broader dispute over how the playoff field is judged and explained.
- 1Week 12 upset risks involving Ohio State, Miami, UCLA, Indiana, Notre Dame, and Utah could reorder the playoff picture.
- 2Pate argues the playoff committee needs clearer criteria, radical transparency, and more consistent communication about its rankings.
- 3His Commissioner’s Poll rewards strong wins and consistency while defending Alabama, Texas, Wake Forest, and several SEC teams.
Don't miss
Pate maps how losses by UCLA, Indiana, or Tennessee could reorder the playoff field while Oregon and Kentucky build late momentum.
The brief
Josh Pate opens by arguing that frustration with the College Football Playoff committee is justified, calling for radical transparency and clearer ranking criteria.
His Week 12 upset board spans Ohio State, Wake Forest, Texas Tech, Miami, UCLA, Indiana, Notre Dame, and Utah, with concern shaped by form, matchups, situations, and betting lines.
Pate’s Commissioner’s Poll defends Alabama, Texas, Wake Forest, and several SEC teams while insisting that strong wins matter more than conference-driven assumptions.
The season’s surprises include Wake Forest, UCLA, Kentucky, and Utah; Oklahoma, Michigan, Texas A&M, and LSU fall short of expectations.
The sharpest playoff scenarios turn on losses by UCLA, Indiana, or Tennessee, while Oregon’s momentum and Kentucky’s closing wins could reshape the field.
Pate closes with viewing guidance, current betting selections, and a preview of the live Montana show after mapping the weekend’s most consequential games.
Weekly email
State of the Pod, every Monday
The week's most-discussed names and stories from podcasts, with the moments behind them. Free, five minutes, unsubscribe in one click.