Josh Pate's College Football Show
Josh Pate's College Football Show

Nov 18, 2026 · 1h 39m

Playoff rankings expose the committee’s résumé double standard

CFP Rankings Reaction + Week 12 Predictions & Lane Kiffin Heat

Josh Pate connects Week 12 predictions and coaching pressure to a larger dispute over how the playoff committee evaluates teams and access.

3 key takeaways
  1. 1Pate picks Tennessee over LSU and Georgia against South Carolina while weighing quarterback health, defense, and late-game execution.
  2. 2The JP Poll separates neutral-field power from résumé rankings, defending LSU’s placement while highlighting widening gaps among contenders.
  3. 3The latest rankings revive questions about Texas, Alabama, Tennessee, Wake Forest, and whether expanded access helps Group of Six programs.

Don't miss

Pate argues that Texas is ranked too low while Alabama receives more favorable treatment than Indiana under the committee’s résumé standards.

The brief

Josh Pate opens with Week 12 picks, using LSU–Tennessee and Georgia–South Carolina to examine quarterback uncertainty, home-field defense, turnovers, and red-zone execution.

Indiana’s résumé becomes a test of consistency: Pate credits its conference schedule but questions how coaches selectively invoke close losses, injuries, and opponent quality.

The JP Poll measures neutral-field power rather than résumé strength, allowing Pate to defend LSU’s ranking while comparing Georgia, Notre Dame, Miami, Wake Forest, and Penn State.

Lane Kiffin’s pressure at LSU reflects a broader warning about expensive rosters: spending alone cannot solve quarterback play, staff changes, unrealistic expectations, or poor execution.

Pate’s playoff reaction centers on Texas being ranked too low and Alabama receiving different treatment from Indiana, exposing the committee’s uneven use of résumé standards.

The episode closes on the expanded playoff’s limits for Group of Six teams, then maps bubble scenarios involving Tennessee, Texas Tech, Kentucky, and Wake Forest.

Weekly email

State of the Pod, every Monday

The week's most-discussed names and stories from podcasts, with the moments behind them. Free, five minutes, unsubscribe in one click.

Listen to the full episode and explore every guest, topic, and moment on PodLume.