
Oct 12, 2026 · 1h 2m
Listen from 45:53
Listen at 45:53
Texas infighting exposes Republican midterm vulnerabilities
Bill Kristol: The Paxton Nightmare Is Costing Republicans Big Time
The episode connects a costly Texas Republican feud to broader questions about Democratic gains, Trump’s foreign policy, and authoritarian abuse.
- 1The Ken Paxton fight could drain Republican resources while giving Democrats openings in Texas and other competitive races.
- 2Polling and anti-incumbent sentiment suggest Democratic opportunities, though candidate quality and perceptions of ideological extremism remain significant obstacles.
- 3Trump’s selective outrage over Russia, Saudi Arabia, and immigration enforcement reveals a foreign-policy and governing style built around political theater.
Don't miss
Miller and Kristol connect the raid on Ilhan Omar’s home to a broader pattern of authoritarian abuse disguised as political theater.
The brief
Tim Miller and Bill Kristol open with the Ken Paxton controversy, arguing that misinformation, conspiracy politics, and MAGA media have escaped meaningful consequences.
The Paxton-James Talarico contest becomes a case study in Republican vulnerability: money and attention spent defending Texas could be unavailable in more competitive races.
They assess Democratic openings across the midterms, weighing anti-incumbent sentiment, candidate quality, redistricting, fundraising, and shifting support among white working-class and evangelical voters.
The conversation then turns to Trump’s Russia policy, selective condemnation of violence, and energy messaging, which Miller and Kristol portray as narrative management rather than coherent strategy.
The standout exchange links the raid on Ilhan Omar’s home to broader authoritarian abuse, warning that politically staged enforcement remains dangerous even when it looks clumsy.
The episode closes with guarded optimism about Democratic prospects alongside concern over what the administration can do before voters get another chance to respond.
What was said on this episode
48 statements · 21 positive · 25 negative · 1 mixed · 1 neutral
The Tallarico rumor reflects Paxton campaign desperation and spreads easily through right-wing media.
“The whole thing is extremely bizarre. And I think, well, it speaks to the desperation of where the Ken Paxton campaign is. And also, just like how easy it is to move totally fake nonsense around the right media.”
Listen at 4:09
The Paxton campaign is desperate, and right-wing media easily spreads fabricated stories.
“it speaks to the desperation of where the Ken Paxton campaign is. And also, just like how easy it is to move totally fake nonsense around the right media.”
Listen at 4:15
Paxton campaign officials were pushing the Tallarico rumor behind the scenes.
“I mean, they were obviously, I think, pushing it behind the scenes.”
Listen at 5:14
MAGA conspiracy promoters have not faced meaningful consequences for their conduct.
“they haven't paid a price for this”
Listen at 7:41
A Pizzagate promoter is about to become the president’s press secretary.
“The actual great point an actual promoter of pizzagate is about to become the press secretary to the president of the united states”
Listen at 7:43
Creating fake controversies benefits people in MAGA political circles.
“Being the person that creates fake... controversies has been a boon in MAGA world.”
Listen at 8:19
Conspiratorial, controversial, and racist behavior benefits MAGA-aligned political operatives.
“it actually benefits you to be conspiratorial, controversial, a little racist.”
Listen at 9:35
Trump’s second term is more radical and pervasive than widely appreciated.
“The radicalness of the Trump second term, I feel like maybe we haven't quite done justice to that.”
Listen at 9:46
Hegseth’s defense team includes extremists previously excluded during Trump’s first term.
“Look at the people around Hexeth. They have real lunatics who were blackballed in the Trump first term and who were right back in there at pretty high levels in defense”
Listen at 10:38
Republicans will pay an electoral price in November for extremist administration personnel.
“There will be a price to be paid this November.”
Listen at 10:56
Ken Paxton and Greg Abbott are likely to lose their respective Texas races.
“I think, I think Paximili is going to lose. And I think Abbott may lose as well.”
Listen at 12:27
Bill Kristol predicts Ken Paxton will lose and Greg Abbott may lose.
“I think Paximili is going to lose. And I think Abbott may lose as well.”
Listen at 12:27
The Paxton campaign could cost Republicans victories in Kansas or Alaska.
“The Paxton thing might be such a nightmare that it ends up costing them Kansas or Alaska or something”
Listen at 12:45
Gina Hinojosa remains the underdog in Texas’s governor’s race.
“I think she's still the underdog as we sit here today, October 12th”
Listen at 15:48
Ken Paxton is weakening the Republican ticket, while Greg Abbott is struggling.
“Paxton is dragging the whole ticket down. Abbott is struggling.”
Listen at 16:32
The Texas governor’s race is competitive and winnable for Democrats.
“So in play. And I just got to say, like, this is very. It's winnable.”
Listen at 16:46
Democrats should invest heavily in the Texas governor’s race.
“I think the Democrats should be going all in on the Texas governor's race right now.”
Listen at 18:46
Winning the Texas or Florida governorship would have major political implications.
“The implications of winning the governorship in Texas, either Texas or Florida.”
Listen at 19:23
Democratic victories in Texas and Ohio would reshape American politics for four years.
“If you want Texas and Ohio, which I think is totally doable at this point, you're changing American politics for the next four years.”
Listen at 19:28
Texas Republican policies have harmed residents and are contributing to Abbott’s poor performance.
“the actual effects on people's lives, I agree. Texas has been such a leader, and this is probably why Abbott isn't doing very well”
Listen at 19:50
Andy Beshear could raise $25 million for the Texas governor’s race from five major donors.
“Bashir got on TV today or got on the phone today, really, honestly, until five big donors. He could raise $25 million for Texas.”
Listen at 20:59
Democrats are likely to win Virginia’s first and second congressional districts.
“now it looks like Democrats are going to win, I think, Virginia 1 and Virginia 2.”
Listen at 25:59
Perriello may win Virginia’s fifth congressional district.
“A lot of Democrats I know think Perriello can win there.”
Listen at 26:32
Virginia’s sixth congressional district is competitive for Democrats.
“And then I think serious people think that Virginia 6. which Spanberger lost by 17 points, is in play as well.”
Listen at 26:42
Virginia’s sixth congressional district is competitive for Democrats.
“I think serious people think that Virginia 6. which Spanberger lost by 17 points, is in play as well.”
Listen at 26:43
Virginia’s first and second congressional districts are safe Democratic seats.
“I think Virginia 1 and 2 are safe.”
Listen at 27:47
Inflation-hit areas and voters will shift most toward Democrats.
“the areas that are getting hit the hardest and the voters that are getting hit the hardest by inflation, I think we're going to see the biggest swings”
Listen at 30:00
White working-class voters are moving away from Trump in key states.
“you're seeing real movement, and that's making the difference.”
Listen at 30:33
Working-class and poorer voters appear to be moving away from Trump.
“they are peeling away from Trump, it seems.”
Listen at 31:25
A Democratic Senate majority of 53 seats would likely persist with a Democratic president.
“winning the Senate by 52 plus, really 53 or 54. They're not going to lose the Senate if they go in with 53 seats and a Democratic president wins at the top of the ticket.”
Listen at 32:59
A Democratic Senate majority above 52 seats would increase the odds of a 2029 Democratic trifecta.
“if Democrats could win the Senate by more than 52 seats this time, and if they can then help keep Trump's numbers down in 27, 28, you are increasing the odds of a Democratic trifecta in 2029”
Listen at 33:11
A larger Democratic Senate majority and low Trump approval increase odds of a 2029 trifecta.
“you are increasing the odds of a Democratic trifecta in 2029”
Listen at 33:17
Trump, Clarence Thomas, and Samuel Alito would not retire if Democrats win the Senate.
“the Democrats win the Senate this time, Trump, Thomas, and Alito won't retire”
Listen at 33:36
A Democratic president and Senate could flip Thomas and Alito’s Supreme Court seats.
“you could actually get a flip of those seats on the Supreme Court. with the Democratic president and the Democratic Senate.”
Listen at 33:48
A Senate seat is currently much more consequential than a House seat.
“One Senate seat is worth like five houses at this point.”
Listen at 34:14
Trump is importing Russian diesel to reduce diesel prices before the midterms.
“Trump is going around it to now import Russian diesel to try to get the diesel price down 10 more cents before the midterms.”
Listen at 38:38
Russian diesel imports are unlikely to be large enough to materially affect supply.
“there's not enough Russian diesel that could come if any is going to come, honestly, which is very unclear.”
Listen at 39:35
The Iran war is driving changes in global energy prices.
“What's changing world energy prices is the war in Iran. There's no question about it.”
Listen at 39:52
Russia continued attacking Ukrainian energy infrastructure after Trump announced an energy ceasefire.
“Russia continued their attacks on a heating and power plant in Kharkiv and infrastructure in Zaporizhia. after Trump said that there was an energy ceasefire.”
Listen at 40:48
Ukrainian counterattacks destroyed two of Yandex’s five data centers.
“They took out two of five data centers belonging to Russian tech giant Yandex”
Listen at 41:13
European governments have adopted tougher policies because they take Putin’s aggression seriously.
“in Europe, one reason they've gotten tougher and behaved pretty well, I've got to say, over the last several years. is they took seriously the notion that we can't let Putin get away with this aggression.”
Listen at 42:05
Tom Cotton has roughly a 90% chance of winning reelection in Arkansas.
“most likely won't lose. I don't think it's 100%, though. It's 90% probably that he'll win.”
Listen at 45:53
The Iran war caused the Saudi Arabia crisis to spiral out of control.
“And this has spiraled totally out of control on Saudi Arabia. And it is all due to the war of choice that we started in Iran.”
Listen at 48:38
The Iran war caused the escalating attacks and disruption in Saudi Arabia.
“it is all due to the war of choice that we started in Iran.”
Listen at 48:43
The Ilhan Omar raid occurred three weeks before an election.
“let's just have a raid three weeks before an election.”
Listen at 52:37
The Trump administration is using federal power against political opponents in an authoritarian manner.
“the degree to which they're using the levers of power to do this kind of thing is... It's so stupid even to be saying this anymore. But if this were happening in another country, we would know exactly what's going on”
Listen at 55:01
Clumsy authoritarian regimes have caused many people to suffer and die.
“An awful lot of people have suffered and died, honestly, in very ham-handed authoritarian regimes.”
Listen at 57:21
A Democratic Congress could stop some abuses, but the executive branch remains powerful.
“Democratic Congress could stop some of it, but executive branch is very, very powerful.”
Listen at 58:09
Statements are attributed to the speaker as said on the episode and reflect their view at the time, not PodLume's. They are not advice.
Books & mentions
Some links are affiliate links — PodLume may earn a commission if you buy.
Weekly email
State of the Pod, every Monday
The week's most-discussed names and stories from podcasts, with the moments behind them. Free, five minutes, unsubscribe in one click.
