Nov 2, 2026 · 17 min
Trump Turns Midterms Into a Test of His Political Strength
Where things stand as voting winds down
The episode examines how turnout, polling uncertainty, redistricting and legal challenges could shape a volatile election’s final outcome.
- 1Early Democratic-leaning voting is strong, but Republican Election Day turnout could reshape the picture.
- 2Trump’s rallies and record make the midterms a referendum on his approval, policies and political influence.
- 3Redistricting may aid Republicans, while race calls and post-election lawsuits could extend uncertainty beyond Election Day.
Don't miss
The panel connects strong Democratic-leaning early voting with the unresolved question of whether Republican Election Day turnout will overturn that signal.
The brief
With voting nearly over, Tamara Keith, Mara Liasson and Domenico Montanaro assess the closing arguments, early turnout and key races that will define the election’s final hours.
Early voting appears unusually strong among Democratic-leaning voters, especially in Michigan’s Wayne County, but Republican Election Day participation leaves the overall turnout picture unsettled.
Donald Trump has made the midterms a referendum on himself, forcing voters to weigh his approval, the cost of living, tariffs and foreign policy alongside local races.
The panel explains why narrow polling leads can mislead, and why partisan redistricting may help Republicans without overcoming broader political conditions that remain unfavorable.
The closing tension extends beyond vote totals: lawsuits over alleged noncitizen voting and candidate names could test certification and whether Trump accepts unfavorable results.
The episode ends by previewing how NPR and the Associated Press call races, underscoring that election night depends on evidence, thresholds and careful judgment.
What was said on this episode
16 statements · 3 positive · 10 negative · 2 mixed · 1 neutral
El-Sayed’s lead will likely be smaller than 11 points.
“I would expect that that margin is likely going to be closer than 11 points.”
Listen at 2:58
Low Trump approval among white non-college voters could significantly affect the election.
“And that could have a big impact on the election.”
Listen at 4:21
A strong Democratic result in Florida’s 27th could threaten Republicans nationally and in Latino districts.
“And if Democrats are able to pull up off a victory there or get very, very close, that could spell some trouble for Republicans across the country and a lot of other Latino districts, especially in South Florida and South Texas as well.”
Listen at 5:34
Democrats should mobilize young voters aged 18 to 29.
“Democrats need to get them out to the polls.”
Listen at 6:15
Democrats currently lead in enthusiasm and turnout.
“Democrats have the enthusiasm edge and the turnout edge so far.”
Listen at 7:14
Early voting advantages are unreliable because Republicans vote overwhelmingly on Election Day.
“But you really can't read too much into early voting, even though Democrats have the double digit. edge on early voting because Republicans do vote so overwhelmingly on Election Day.”
Listen at 7:29
Trump’s actions made North Carolina and Texas competitive Democratic pickup opportunities.
“North Carolina and Texas. would not have been in play. We would not be talking about them as possible Democratic pickups. If Donald Trump hadn't decided to push aside... the incumbent in Texas, John Cornyn, who probably would have won pretty easily, or to make life so miserable for Tom Tillis, the Republican incumbent in North Carolina, that he decided not to run at all.”
Listen at 9:18
The president’s party performs worse in midterms when the president’s approval is below 50%.
“It's really worse for the president's party when the president is below 50% as Trump is now.”
Listen at 10:07
Trump’s average approval rating is 38%.
“He's at 38% on average in the polls.”
Listen at 10:14
Trump’s 38% support represents the Republican Party’s floor.
“That's the bare metal base of the Republican Party.”
Listen at 10:39
Trump-driven Republican turnout could limit Democratic wins; low turnout could produce a Republican wipeout.
“if he's able to do that, then they might be able to stem some of these Democratic wins. But if he's not, and there's a low Republican turnout on Election Day, that is going to mean a wipeout for the Republican Party.”
Listen at 11:21
Republican gerrymandering created an advantage smaller than expected.
“I think they gave themselves an advantage, but a much smaller one than they were hoping for.”
Listen at 13:20
Some Republican gerrymanders may backfire, particularly in South Texas.
“Some of these gerrymanders are going to turn out to backfire into dummymanders, especially maybe in South Texas.”
Listen at 13:26
Elon Musk’s campaign spending has not produced the expected Republican polling benefit.
“That's something that a lot of people thought would save Republicans, but it hasn't had the impact, at least as measured in polls, that we thought it might.”
Listen at 14:10
Trump has never accepted election results after losing himself or through his party.
“will Donald Trump accept the results of elections that he loses or that his party loses? He has never done that.”
Listen at 15:24
Trump has contested every election he has lost.
“He's contested every single election he's ever been in that he's lost.”
Listen at 16:12
Statements are attributed to the speaker as said on the episode and reflect their view at the time, not PodLume's. They are not advice.
Weekly email
State of the Pod, every Monday
The week's most-discussed names and stories from podcasts, with the moments behind them. Free, five minutes, unsubscribe in one click.