Oct 19, 2026 · 55 min
Trump’s alliances and rhetoric put Republicans on the defensive
Bill Kristol: You Can't Hide Your Lyin' Eyes, JD
The discussion connects foreign policy, immigration, corruption allegations, economic strain, and election administration to the stakes of the next congressional contests.
- 1Trump’s alignment with Vladimir Putin leaves Ukraine sidelined while the administration echoes Russia’s framing of the war.
- 2J.D. Vance’s appeals to social cohesion struggle to reconcile unpopular immigration, Iran, and corruption defenses.
- 3Economic pressure, election-denial rhetoric, and Big Tech’s pursuit of influence could shape contests for Senate and House control.
Don't miss
The hosts react to leaked Mike Rogers audio about late-night ballot counting and police at Detroit polling locations, calling it election denialism and voter intimidation.
The brief
Bill Kristol and Tim Miller open with Southern politics before turning to a broader question: can Democrats make the 2026 elections a referendum on Trump and Republican control?
They argue that Trump’s apparent alignment with Vladimir Putin has sidelined Ukraine, amplified attacks on Volodymyr Zelenskyy, and left Russia’s claims largely unchallenged.
J.D. Vance’s defenses of immigration policy, deportations, the Iran war, and Trump’s wealth are presented as an effort to manage unpopular positions through rhetorical concessions.
Economic pressure remains politically potent despite favorable headline indicators, with housing, gasoline, inflation, real wages, and Social Security shaping voters’ lived experience.
The standout moment comes with leaked Mike Rogers audio about ballot counting and police at Detroit polling places, which the hosts condemn as election denialism and intimidation.
The conversation closes on Senate opportunities, the importance of House control, and Big Tech executives’ pursuit of influence and exemptions through their alliance with Trump.
What was said on this episode
23 statements · 8 positive · 14 negative · 1 mixed
Annie Andrews is running a smart campaign.
“I think that she's running a really smart campaign”
Listen at 3:36
Donald Trump is now openly aligned with Vladimir Putin.
“He's just for Putin.”
Listen at 7:53
Donald Trump wants negotiations over Ukraine without Ukrainian participation.
“I guess Trump wants to do that. He certainly wants to do that in Ukraine.”
Listen at 9:32
Donald Trump falsely denies Russia is helping Iran.
“Trump is just lying when he says that they're not helping Iran.”
Listen at 10:51
J.D. Vance is a morally repugnant person.
“he's a real creep and a loathsome guy”
Listen at 15:06
The Iran war was key to the collapse of Trump’s political support in 2026.
“I think it just really was the key to the collapse of this in 2026”
Listen at 16:32
J.D. Vance can make racist nationalist policies sound rational.
“he has an ability to try to make really noxious racist nationalist policies sound rational”
Listen at 18:25
J.D. Vance’s rhetorical repositioning may be politically successful.
“he is being slippery and I'm not sure it's not. It's slightly successful.”
Listen at 20:20
Headline macroeconomic numbers may overstate the real economy’s condition.
“I kind of wonder what's happening in the real economy if that, those numbers are pretty overwhelming.”
Listen at 27:56
Higher interest rates make it harder for young people to buy homes.
“Young people have trouble buying houses because interest rates are up.”
Listen at 28:39
Democrats will win the Michigan and Maine Senate races.
“I think Democrats win Michigan and Maine”
Listen at 31:24
Democrats should emphasize Senate control as a check on Trump.
“we need to have a Democratic Senate. And this is to check Trump.”
Listen at 33:23
Mike Rogers is promoting 2020-style election denialism.
“he is in that audio doing 2020 election denialism”
Listen at 34:40
Mike Rogers is using racial appeals against Detroit voters.
“he's just playing the race card”
Listen at 36:10
Roy Cooper’s performance could enable Democrats to win a North Carolina district unexpectedly.
“I do think that North Carolina is the kind of place Roy Cooper really runs up the numbers that you could get a surprise win in one of these districts.”
Listen at 38:49
The Mississippi Senate race could become competitive for Democrats.
“I think Mississippi could be in play.”
Listen at 39:21
The South Dakota Senate race is closer than commonly perceived.
“the other Senate race that looks, again, a little closer than people realize is South Dakota”
Listen at 41:34
A narrow Democratic House majority would be preferable to Republican control.
“we want robert garcia to have the gavel and jamie raskin to have the gavel”
Listen at 43:05
A diverse group of Democratic House members would benefit the party.
“if the wave happens and you get that group in the house, that's healthy, I think, for the party too”
Listen at 47:14
Technology CEOs want oligarchic government rather than free-market capitalism.
“they want an oligarchy”
Listen at 49:18
Technology CEOs seek unrestricted growth and ambition.
“they want to be able to grow as fast as possible and not have any limits on their ambitions”
Listen at 49:20
Some technology executives have internalized Trumpism’s anti-democratic spirit.
“they sort of merged those together more than I might have explained”
Listen at 50:43
Technology executives’ alignment with Trump harms democracy and requires opposition.
“it's bad for democracy and it really needs to be confronted”
Listen at 52:42
Statements are attributed to the speaker as said on the episode and reflect their view at the time, not PodLume's. They are not advice.
Weekly email
State of the Pod, every Monday
The week's most-discussed names and stories from podcasts, with the moments behind them. Free, five minutes, unsubscribe in one click.