
Aug 12, 2026 · 59 min
Wisconsin upset exposes Democrats’ polling and strategy gaps
Dave Weigel: Polls Wrong, Hong Gone
The Wisconsin primary tests whether Democratic candidates can win by emphasizing local credibility and generational change over nationalized progressive politics.
- 1David Crowley’s Wisconsin victory exposed polling, turnout, spending, and Republican-intervention assumptions.
- 2The hosts argue local candidates need distinct strategies rather than simply importing national Democratic or DSA agendas.
- 3The broader map remains unsettled, with John Fetterman and vulnerable voting rights shaping Democrats’ Senate path.
Don't miss
Miller and Weigel use Francesca Hong’s Wisconsin defeat to show how polling, spending, and national political assumptions can misread a local primary.
The brief
Tim Miller opens with a troubling National Guard confrontation near his vehicle in Washington, framing the episode around intimidation and the erosion of ordinary civil liberties.
David Weigel joins Miller to dissect Wisconsin’s surprise primary: David Crowley defeated Francesca Hong despite Republican efforts to boost her, exposing failures in polling, turnout, and spending assumptions.
The Wisconsin result becomes a broader argument about Democratic strategy, as the hosts weigh local credibility and moderate or populist alternatives against nationalized progressive campaigns.
They turn to the party’s generational fight, examining donor-backed recruitment and younger candidates who want a fresh approach without adopting the full DSA agenda.
The conversation closes on the Senate map, Republican recruitment, John Fetterman’s wildcard role, and Democratic efforts to protect vulnerable votes.
What was said on this episode
33 statements · 15 positive · 16 negative · 1 mixed · 1 neutral
Republicans expected Francesca Hong’s victory to benefit their campaign strategy.
“Republicans were giddy about a Hong victory.”
Listen at 12:34
Wisconsin Democrats could win a trifecta and redraw the state maps.
“the entire story of Wisconsin Democrats is slowly gaining ground, or not losing it, in every election until one day this year you can win a trifecta and redraw the state maps.”
Listen at 13:04
David Crowley won Wisconsin’s Democratic gubernatorial primary.
“he grinds it out and he wins.”
Listen at 15:45
Francesca Hong had posted tweets supporting abolition of prisons and police.
“the conversation turned to, let's call them woke tweets she had sent between 2019 and 2021 about abolishing prison, abolishing police.”
Listen at 17:06
Francesca Hong lacked the progressive endorsements and strategists received by some candidates.
“she did not get the same progressive endorsements and strategists as some candidates.”
Listen at 17:33
Tony Evers directed super PAC spending supporting Crowley and opposing Hong.
“It did help that Evers directed money to super PACs that were on the air for Crowley and on the air against Hong.”
Listen at 19:46
Tony Evers directed super PAC spending supporting Crowley and opposing Hong.
“Evers directed money to super PACs that were on the air for Crowley and on the air against Hong.”
Listen at 19:47
Rural America lacks a hidden socialist electorate awaiting such candidates.
“there is not a secret socialist vote in rural America that is waiting for this kind of candidate.”
Listen at 26:01
Some former Democratic voters can be persuaded by candidates presented as different.
“there are people who used to vote for Democrats who can be convinced that this Democrat is a little bit different.”
Listen at 26:30
Voters are not necessarily seeking the most anti-establishment candidate.
“It's not clear to me that voters are just saying, I want the most anti-establishment person.”
Listen at 28:40
Voters prefer candidates who have not lost elections.
“They want a person who didn't who's not a loser.”
Listen at 28:44
Angie Craig struggled politically because of her Lake and Riley Act vote.
“it seemed like it was hard for her to get past that vote.”
Listen at 29:26
Democrats who supported the bill or resolution are severely harmed in primaries.
“What has happened to everyone who voted for that bill in the Democratic primary or the resolution is that they get destroyed by it.”
Listen at 31:49
ICE-related votes harmed Raja Krishnamoorthi politically.
“I've seen that hurt Raja Krishnamoorthi in Illinois.”
Listen at 32:17
The Bench recruits young, active congressional candidates who are not necessarily left-wing.
“The Bench is a big donor-funded effort with good Democratic strategists to recruit and nominate candidates who are young and active and they think would be very good members of Congress, but not necessarily left-wing.”
Listen at 35:31
John Larson’s defeat represented voters’ decisive rejection of older Democrats.
“it was just a completely definitive rejection of old Democrats.”
Listen at 37:17
Democratic voters rejected John Larson over age and perceived ineffectiveness against Trump.
“It is, we are worried that you are too old and you are not effective at fighting Trump.”
Listen at 37:30
Democratic voters are unwilling to excuse repeated electoral losses.
“Democratic voters say, you lost though. We would give you a mulligan on the first one because of Russia and all the stuff. Hillary won the popular vote.”
Listen at 37:53
Democratic candidates must acknowledge that their decade-long strategy failed.
“you have to tell Democratic voters, you recognize that the strategy has not worked the last decade”
Listen at 38:20
Democratic voters favor candidates offering positive alternatives over candidates merely attacking the left.
“If only the left is offering something new and you're attacking the left, Democratic voters we're seeing are going to, I think, go to the people that are offering them a positive vision and another way to kind of go at Trump.”
Listen at 39:00
Moulton’s path depends on non-enrolled voters offsetting losses among registered Democrats.
“He loses with Democrats. That is his path. 50% by losing Democrats and winning those voters who non-ideologically are just tired of old people.”
Listen at 41:57
Republicans will have more campaign money than Democrats in this cycle.
“Republicans will have more money.”
Listen at 44:35
Republican attacks over Talarico’s past statements did not defeat him politically.
“that didn't put him away.”
Listen at 45:19
Improved Latino performance and Black turnout could make Texas competitive for Democrats.
“If Democrats go to their 2020 even numbers with Latino voters, 2018 would be better in Texas if they turn out the Black vote”
Listen at 45:36
Alaska is a more promising Democratic target than Texas because it costs less.
“Alaska seems more promising for Democrats just because it's cheaper.”
Listen at 46:06
Republican candidate recruitment has been poor this election cycle.
“the Republican recruitment has been basically bad this cycle.”
Listen at 47:29
Republicans are portraying every Democratic opponent as extreme or communist.
“they're just running against every Democrat like, this is the future, this is communism.”
Listen at 49:18
Republicans may perform poorly if they rely only on negative attacks without a positive agenda.
“I can see an election where it doesn't go very well for them and everyone agrees that, that was, that was silly. They should have tried to do something positive instead of just warning about”
Listen at 49:32
John Fetterman would currently lose a Pennsylvania Democratic primary.
“He would not win a primary in Pennsylvania if it was held today.”
Listen at 53:22
A Republican Senate would replace retiring Alito and Thomas with young conservatives.
“The point will be for Sam Alito and Clarence Thomas to retire and be replaced by young conservatives.”
Listen at 54:11
Left-wing hostility increased Fetterman’s antipathy toward the left and sympathy for Republicans.
“him being bullied all the time by leftists clearly made him hate the left more than he ever has in his life, makes him sympathetic to Republicans.”
Listen at 55:24
Democrats should cultivate John Fetterman to prevent him moving toward Republicans.
“Democrats need to work on him.”
Listen at 55:56
Fetterman is unlikely to end his career by enabling a Republican Supreme Court supermajority.
“I'm just skeptical that he would end his career in politics, electoral politics, making sure that Republicans have a Supreme Court supermajority that will unwind most of what he ran on.”
Listen at 55:57
Statements are attributed to the speaker as said on the episode and reflect their view at the time, not PodLume's. They are not advice.
Books & mentions
Weekly email
State of the Pod, every Monday
The week's most-discussed names and stories from podcasts, with the moments behind them. Free, five minutes, unsubscribe in one click.
