Oct 23, 2026 · 1h 3m
Ohio attack ad exposes Republican backlash beyond one race
When Negative Goes Negative (with Sarah Longwell)
The episode tests whether a damaging Ohio campaign tactic reflects a broader Republican problem with voter enthusiasm, candidate quality, and party loyalty.
- 1Sarah Longwell’s focus groups suggest the Ohio ad reached dissatisfied Trump voters and intensified doubts about Republican candidates.
- 2The panel argues that backlash over one race can spread down-ballot when voters already feel frustrated with the party.
- 3Competitive Senate contests reveal an enthusiasm gap that could make Republican tribal loyalty less reliable in November.
Don't miss
Sarah Longwell describes an enthusiasm gap among dissatisfied Trump voters who may remain unhappy with Democrats but feel little attachment to Republican candidates.
The brief
Vivek Ramaswamy’s attack ad against Amy Acton becomes the episode’s central case study: a tactic that reportedly tested well but triggered moral backlash among Republicans and undecided voters.
Sarah Longwell’s focus-group work suggests the controversy matters because dissatisfied Trump voters are already weakly attached to Republican candidates, making an Ohio scandal harder to contain.
The panel widens the lens to Michigan, Maine, South Carolina, Mississippi, and Kansas, where anti-establishment moods and candidate liabilities are making familiar Republican advantages less dependable.
The discussion’s sharpest tension is whether Republican voters remain loyal to the party out of enthusiasm or merely tribal habit as economic and political frustrations accumulate.
Longwell’s account of rural frustration over prices, war, and data centers links the Ohio controversy to a larger warning: Republican candidates cannot assume Trump’s presence solves their problems.
What was said on this episode
24 statements · 6 positive · 16 negative · 2 neutral
Ramaswamy’s advertisement is a major act of political suicide.
“this is one of the biggest acts of political suicide I've ever seen”
Listen at 6:32
Mike DeWine’s comments effectively endorse Amy Acton.
“now you've got him on camera saying, she's always been truthful with me. She's not a liar. Effectively endorsing her.”
Listen at 8:07
Every Ohio focus-group participant had heard and seen Ramaswamy’s ad.
“every single person had heard about the ad and had seen the ad”
Listen at 10:29
The ad pushed some Ohio voters toward abstention or supporting Amy Acton.
“many people had been like, I mean, we're either like, I'm going to sit it out now, or I've made up my mind in favor of Amy Acton”
Listen at 10:52
A legitimate advertisement test would not have approved the Ramaswamy ad.
“There is no legit ad test that would have ever cleared that thing. I just, I don't believe it.”
Listen at 14:01
J.D. Vance’s imitation of Trump makes voters dislike him.
“J.D. Vance is just a mortal man. And people look at that mortal man and go, why is this guy such a dick?”
Listen at 16:01
The field is more likely than J.D. Vance to win the nomination.
“I'll take the field against Vance and a bet on the nomination.”
Listen at 17:18
Vivek Ramaswamy becomes less popular as voters hear more from him.
“He is one of those people who the more you hear from him, the less people like him.”
Listen at 21:39
The Ohio advertisement controversy cannot help Jon Husted’s Senate campaign.
“this can't help Husted, who's already struggling with Sherrod Brown”
Listen at 25:08
Amy Acton should capitalize on the backlash for about 48 hours, then pivot to substantive issues.
“I think she's got about. 48 hours of this, and then if I were her, I would hard pivot to grown-up stuff.”
Listen at 27:36
Rural voters who usually boost Republicans will abstain in large numbers in 2026.
“the rural voters who normally provide Republicans their margins are the ones who stay home in droves”
Listen at 29:34
Donald Trump’s campaign travel will have little electoral effect.
“I don't think Trump's travel will affect much.”
Listen at 31:28
Mike Rogers is unlikely to defeat Abdul El-Sayed.
“I don't think, I don't think he can beat El-Sayed.”
Listen at 35:12
Abdul El-Sayed will trail Michigan’s Democratic gubernatorial nominee but benefit from weak anti-Muslim attacks.
“I think that El-Sayed, you know, for the reasons you said, Mike, will do less, obviously less well than the gubernatorial candidate. It'll be closer, but. I think that he's over—I think the Republicans are so counting on Islamophobia and the sort of he's a terrorist kind of argument.”
Listen at 36:15
Susan Collins’s institutional expertise may not help her win in 2026.
“I'm not sure being a master of the system is the key to success in 2026.”
Listen at 38:49
Biden-Collins voters view Susan Collins as effectively rubber-stamping Trump and will not reelect her.
“The voters basically are saying, she's rubber stamping Trump. I think she's a smart person. I think she's a kind person, but I will not do it again.”
Listen at 43:10
Maine voters may thank Susan Collins but replace her with Troy Jackson.
“I think people want to say thanks. I'll remember the old one. And here's a gold watch.”
Listen at 44:07
Dissatisfied Trump voters show a large enthusiasm gap favoring Democrats.
“there's an enormous enthusiasm gap”
Listen at 48:16
Republican enthusiasm will face a substantial ceiling in the 2026 midterms.
“I think there is going to be a real ceiling on Republican enthusiasm”
Listen at 49:11
Darlene Graham will probably lose South Carolina’s Senate race by five to seven points.
“I think she probably loses by five to seven points”
Listen at 52:28
A sufficiently large Democratic wave could make Mississippi competitive for Scott Colom.
“if there is a gigantic wave, anything can happen”
Listen at 53:36
Democrats are likely to win a large House majority in 2026.
“I would bet on the high side. on the house. I think that this margin is going to”
Listen at 57:15
Democrats could gain 30 House seats in 2026.
“I don't think it's crazy to think they could net 30.”
Listen at 57:44
Allegations about the Kansas doctor’s patient treatment are a serious electoral problem.
“That's all people talked about in the focus group. I mean, there was one woman who said, I tried to meet with him because I have this liver condition and he wouldn't talk to me. So yeah, I think it's a real problem for him.”
Listen at 58:53
Statements are attributed to the speaker as said on the episode and reflect their view at the time, not PodLume's. They are not advice.
Books & mentions
Some links are affiliate links — PodLume may earn a commission if you buy.
Weekly email
State of the Pod, every Monday
The week's most-discussed names and stories from podcasts, with the moments behind them. Free, five minutes, unsubscribe in one click.